Brighton council threw man’s belongings in skip after he died, says brother
The brother of a 29-year-old man found dead in temporary council accommodation says he has been left bereft after his sibling’s belongings were disposed of by council contractors.Simon Byrne had made an appointment with Brighton and Hove officials to collect the possessions of his brother Chris, who had died from a drug overdose.However, when he arrived, he discovered Chris’s lodgings had already been cleared.“I was pointed to a small suitcase in the caretaker’s [building],” he said.“The rest of his things, including his bracelets and other tangible memories, had been thrown into a skip with no opportunity for me as his only surviving family member to go through them.
”The case has exposed a gap in protections for families of deceased council tenants, with regulators and government departments unclear who holds councils to account when a tenant dies intestate,Different authorities have different policies, with some accepting proof of identity from next of kin in order to allow access to a property while others insist on grants of probate – a lengthy legal process which can take months,In some cases, relatives’ ashes have been destroyed by local authority operatives when a tenancy ended,Last month the Guardian reported on a family who lost cherished heirlooms when a council discarded the contents of a flat after its tenant went missing, presumed dead,East Riding council had refused to allow next of kin access to the property and disposed of 75-year-old Robert Bracegirdle’s belongings before a coroner had declared the pensioner dead.
The family had been unable to apply for probate without a death certificate,The council admitted that it should have dealt with the case more empathetically, and said it had since changed its processes,In Cambridge, the daughters of a council tenant who died intestate were also barred from entering his flat by the local authority, despite having a key and submitting proof of identity,Ailsa Mackenzie and her sister were told that their father’s possessions would be stored in a garage or disposed of if probate was not granted before the tenancy was repossessed,Probate applications are taking up to 16 weeks to process, but the family of Glen Hutchinson were told that his home would be cleared after a month.
Cambridge council said it was required by law to insist on a grant of probate if a tenant had not registered next of kin, and agreed not to clear the flat until probate was granted after the Guardian intervened.Relatives should not be required to have probate to enter a property, according to Ian Bond, of the Law Society’s wills and equity committee.“Most local authorities allow those entitled to claim probate access without the official grant to deal with the clearance and to locate important papers,” he said.Councils are regulated by the local government and social care ombudsman (LGSCO) and complaints concerning council housing are adjudicated by the housing ombudsman.However, an investigation by the Guardian found confusion over which body had remit over the mishandling of deceased tenants’ belongings.
The LGSCO admitted there was an “accountability and resolution gap” for issues which fell between the jurisdiction of both ombudsman services.“These situations are an example of where complex jurisdictional arrangements let people down, and so we are keen to see our powers to investigate local government services simplified and the gaps closed,” said the LGSCO’s chief executive, Nigel Ellis.The housing ombudsman, Richard Blakeway, agreed that there was concern about some councils’ treatment of families when a tenancy ended.“Whilst we have not investigated cases involving probate, we have seen cases where landlords have been heavy-handed in ending tenancies,” he said.“This has included confiscating or destroying residents’ personal belongings, with a few stark examples where the ashes of relatives have been disposed of.
Landlords’ communication during this has often lacked empathy, with residents being given inaccurate information about accessing the property or clearing it before the time offered for collecting personal possessions,”There was also confusion among government departments, with the Ministry of Justice and the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government each claiming the other was responsible for guiding councils on their obligations when bereaved families needed access to a council property,The housing and local government select committee said it was unacceptable for families to be threatened with the destruction of a loved ones’ personal effects, but it had not investigated the issue,Chris Byrne’s possessions were destroyed in error by a contractor who no longer worked for the council, according to Brighton and Hove,“During the process of cleaning the property and making it suitable for the next of kin to visit, some items were unfortunately disposed of by our cleaning contractor,” said Gill Williams, the council cabinet member for housing and new homes.
“We do understand how important someone’s belongings are to their friends and family and apologise for any additional distress and upset this caused in relation to this very sad loss.”Simon Byrne said that rifling through a skip in the hope of finding remnants of his brother’s life had been humiliating.“Councils will store belongings for those waiting to move into accommodation – people who are alive,” he said.“Tenants who die are treated as if they never existed.”
Elon Musk to ‘summon MPs to US to explain threats to American citizens’
Elon Musk has said UK MPs “will be summoned to the United States of America to explain their censorship and threats to American citizens” in a fresh escalation of tensions between the world’s richest man and Labour.Musk, who has been a fixture at the side of Donald Trump since his re-election as US president, was responding to a Guardian report on Wednesday that the Commons’ science and technology select committee would call him to give evidence in the new year in its inquiry into the spread of harmful content on social media after the August riots.The committee’s chair, Chi Onwurah, a Labour MP, said she wanted to see how Musk, who owns the X social media platform, “reconciles his promotion of freedom of expression with his promotion of pure disinformation”.X hosts accounts by figures including Tommy Robinson and Andrew Tate, who were accused of inciting people to join Islamophobic protests.Musk, who has more than 205 million followers on X, responded by saying the MPs would be summoned to the US
Google must sell Chrome to end search monopoly, says US justice department
The US Department of Justice has proposed a far-reaching overhaul of Google’s structure and business practices, including the sale of its Chrome browser, in a bid to end its monopoly on internet search.The DoJ proposals follow a landmark court ruling in August in which a federal judge ruled that Google maintained an illegal monopoly over search services.The proposals filed to a Washington federal court include the forced sale of the Chrome browser and a five-year ban from entering the browser market; a block on paying third parties such as Apple to make Google the default search engine on their products; and divestment of the Android mobile operating system if the initial proposals do not work.The DoJ also said Google should give publishers and content creators the ability to block their data from being used to train its artificial intelligence models. It wants Google’s search index, a database of all the webpages it has crawled, to be available to rivals, along with search results
Apple Watch Series 10 review: thinner, lighter and basically the same
A larger screen and thinner body mark the biggest change to the Apple Watch in years, but you might have to squint to see it.The Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.That is because Apple has kept much the same design on the outside despite requiring significant changes on the inside to make the watch thinner and lighter
Nvidia earnings: AI chip leader shows no signs of stopping mammoth growth
The AI chipmaker Nvidia, the world’s most valuable company and the engine of the artificial-intelligence boom, rolled out another set of quarterly results on Wednesday to investors’ delight.The company, whose value has soared by $2.2tn this year to $3.6tn on the back of near-doubling of chip sales, said it had revenue of $35.08bn, against expectations of $33
Opt out: how to stop tech companies spying on your phone as Trump promises mass deportations
There are no federal privacy regulations to protect your information – here’s how you can do it yourselfWelcome to Opt Out, a semi-regular column in which we help you navigate your online privacy and show you how to say no to surveillance. The last column covered how to talk to your family about not posting your baby’s photos on the internet.President-elect Donald Trump has promised to execute the largest mass deportation of undocumented immigrants in American history, and many rights groups are concerned he’ll also introduce or reinstate rules that target broader immigrant communities as well – even if they’ve come through legal pathways or have been naturalized. If his prior administration is any indication, that can include people from certain Muslim-majority countries, asylum seekers and refugees.Civil liberties groups are bracing for what this will mean for the privacy and data security of immigrants around the country
Can a fluffy robot really replace a cat or dog? My weird, emotional week with an AI pet
Casio says Moflin can develop its own personality and build a rapport with its owner – and it doesn’t need food, exercise or a litter tray. But is it essentially comforting or alienating?It looks faintly like one half of a small pair of very fluffy slippers. It squeaks and wriggles and nestles in the palm of my hand, black eyes hidden beneath a mop of silvery-white fur. It weighs about the same as a tin of soup. It doesn’t need to be fed or walked and it doesn’t use a litter tray; it’s guaranteed not to leave “gifts” on my doorstep
‘He was for us’: everyone has anecdotes about John Prescott in his village
Growing up with Nigel Farage: inside Reform UK’s push for the next election
UK imposes asset freezes and travel bans on three ‘kleptocrats’
John Prescott, British former deputy prime minister, dies aged 86
It was a time for niceties in the Commons. Kemi doesn’t do niceties | John Crace
‘His robustness had a dignity to it’: readers’ encounters with John Prescott