Sport may be a blunt tool of social change, but it’s time to take a stand against Israel | Jonathan Liew
Probably you already know what this is.Probably before you read a word of it, you decided what it was, where you stand on it, how you’re going to feel about it.The headline, there’s your first clue.Maybe you recognised the name of the writer and drew your own conclusions.And of course there’s the Guardian masthead at the top, the world’s leading bat‑signal for wet liberals, so already there’s a self‑selecting audience there.
Or maybe you came via a social media link that already told you what to expect,Necessary, vital, powerful,Great piece by so-and-so,A shocking antisemitic screed by an unashamed Jew-hater,Sides are taken.
Feelings are felt.Minds are not changed.So we mumble things.We despair quietly.We watch our words, stay silent, or simply look away.
Because to do otherwise is to run a gauntlet of threats, smears and abuse, a very public excoriation whose very purpose is to distract, divide, dishearten.Is starvation bad? Ack, it’s complicated.What about the bombing of hospitals or residential areas? Ah, right can of worms you’ve opened there.In the meantime almost two million people in Gaza are at risk of starving to death.In the meantime the Gazan ministry of health reported that 76 Palestinians were killed in 24 hours on Monday, but nobody seems to know who did it, or whose fault it was, or whether this is a welcome or unwelcome development.
In the meantime the national security minister of Israel is promising the “voluntary transfer of all Gazan citizens”.But then in this particular space – the space where an unhinged ethnonationalist far-right government meets the soiled earth that used to constitute public discourse – nothing really means anything any more.Words can indicate anything you want.Actions have no consequences.The United Nations is bad, actually, and bombings are a form of defence, and newborn babies can be collateral damage, and the dead are not dead, because you cannot be human if you never existed in the first place.
At which point, a little gauchely and with a deep reluctance: enter sport,Over the past 13 months, since the appalling attack on Israel by Hamas in October last year, sport has tried to present the smallest possible target amid the carnage that followed,The line is: there is no line,Occasionally a punishment beating would be handed out to an athlete who failed to hold this no-line line,Mainz sacked the winger Anwar El Ghazi for posting “stop the killing”.
The Australia batter Usman Khawaja was banned from displaying the message “all lives are equal” on his shoes during a Test match.Otherwise, business as usual.But recent events have threatened this fragile omertà, a darkness lurking just beyond the windows that can no longer be ignored or held at bay.A series of coordinated attacks on Maccabi Tel Aviv fans at a Europa League game against Ajax drew international condemnation and almost ended up bringing down the Dutch government.There were scuffles and empty seats at a Nations League game between France and Israel, which Emmanuel Macron attended as an act of solidarity.
And last Monday, there was global outrage at the killing of two Gazan footballers, Eyad Abu-Khater and Hisham Al-Thaltini, in Israeli air strikes.Obviously I’m joking about the last one.Nobody gave a shit about that.Or any of the 344 Palestinian footballers killed by Israel since last October, or the fact that teams from Israel’s West Bank settlements play in their domestic league in violation of Fifa rules, or that the Palestinian West Bank league has been suspended indefinitely.In the face of this, inaction begins to feel like its own conscious choice.
It’s six months since Fifa promised a prompt ruling on whether or not to impose sanctions on Israel’s national team for the actions of its government, and we’re still waiting.It’s four months since Israeli athletes competed at the Olympic Games after the International Olympic Committee president, Thomas Bach, declared: “We are not in the political business.” It’s two months since a major Israeli assault on Jenin, in the occupied West Bank, destroyed the town’s main football stadium.I’ve been thinking a lot about hopelessness recently.Pretty much everyone I know is scarred and scared, bruised and hurting.
And tired; so tired.Amid all this, the ruins of conventional politics, the desecration of our common ground, a stinging question: what hope can sport possibly have of making a difference? Can it ever be more than a cocoon, a means of escaping the real world rather than changing it? In other words: what are we all doing here?A “Free Palestine” banner at Celtic Park or the Parc des Princes; the 60,000 empty seats at the Stade de France last Thursday; a few small words of solidarity from a global icons like Coco Gauff or Lewis Hamilton or Kyrie Irving: does this mean anything, beyond what it is? Can this ever be more than flickering lighter flames in the teeth of an unstoppable, genocidal gale?Nobody knows.But we know, or we should know, right from wrong.Killing children is wrong.A government that declares some humans as more worthless than others is wrong.
Presiding over a famine is wrong,How is this complicated? How is this the start of a debate, rather than the end of one? How is it remotely possible to frame this horrific extravaganza of violence as the benign option, and the resistance to it — even when it comes from Jews themselves — as some kind of sublimated hatred, rather than the simplest act of conscience there is?To resist this Israeli regime is not incompatible with resisting a Saudi World Cup or a Russian Olympic team or a Taliban ban on women’s sport,Indeed this is one and the same resistance: a resistance to the doctrine of untouchable power, a resistance to violence and othering as the solution to our common problems,And even if sport is a blunt and pointless tool of social change, it must nonetheless be deployed,Because there remains – even in this warped, fucked fairground mirror of a world – a thing called right and a thing called wrong.
For the Palestinians sport has always been a form of expression, a place of wonder and play, a brief taste of freedom, a locus of international recognition, and so of course it cannot be allowed to live.Probably you’ve already decided what you think about this.But even one mind is worth changing, just as surely as one life is worth saving.
Electric shock: carmakers battle strict UK electric car rules as big fines loom
When Ford announced this week that it was cutting 800 jobs in the UK, the US carmaker also had stern words for the government. It has joined in a chorus of criticism of rules that force car companies to sell more electric vehicles each year. The rules, known as the zero-emission vehicle (ZEV) mandate, are simply “unworkable”, Ford said.Someone should have told Ford back in 2022, when the carmaker strongly backed the policy. In fact, it went further, calling for the British government to force carmakers to sell even more electric cars each year
UK private sector is contracting as firms give ‘thumbs down’ to the budget, hitting pound – as it happened
Time for a recap.Evidence is growing that the UK economy is weakening, while the eurozone is also lurching deeper into trouble … as the US pushes ahead.UK business activity shrank for the first time in over a year this month, according to the latest poll of purchasing managers, in a sign that corporate confidence has been hit by last month’s budget.Chris Williamson, chief business economist at S&P Global Market Intelligence, says:Business optimism has slumped sharply since the General Election, dropping further in November to hit the lowest since late 2022.Companies are giving a clear ‘thumbs down’ to the policies announced in the Budget, especially the planned increase in employers’ National Insurance contributions
Spain fines budget airlines including Ryanair total of €179m
Spain has fined five budget airlines, including Ryanair, a total of €179m (£150m) for charging passengers for hand luggage and seat reservations, prompting the Irish carrier to say banning the practices would “destroy” the ability to offer cheap tickets.Spain’s Consumer Rights Ministry announced the sanctions on Friday, with Ryanair given the biggest fine, of €108m, and easyJet a penalty of €29m.Vueling, the low-cost operation of the British Airways owner IAG, has been fined €39m, and Norwegian Airlines and Volotea have been fined €1.6m and €1.2m
Budget blamed for first contraction in private sector for a year
Labour’s first budget in 14 years has been given the “thumbs down” by private sector businesses as it was blamed for the end to a 12-month run of expansion and a fall in retail sales.Many businesses said the first fall in business activity in November since the same month last year was a result of tax rises announced by the chancellor, Rachel Reeves, while official figures showed retail sales had dropped in October, the first month of the “golden quarter” for retailers that includes the Christmas rush.Manufacturers registered “a solid decline” in new work, and the rate of contraction accelerated to the fastest since February, according to a closely watched survey by S&P Global Market Intelligence.Chris Williamson, the firm’s chief business economist, said the contraction in November was only marginal but reflected deeper concern about the prospects for the year ahead.The S&P Global Flash purchasing managers’ index (PMI) fell from 51
Bitcoin rises after SEC chair says he is to step down when Trump is inaugurated
Cryptocurrencies have risen sharply after one of the industry’s biggest critics, Gary Gensler, said he would stand down as the head of the US financial regulator when president-elect Donald Trump was inaugurated in January.In a post on X, Gensler confirmed he would resign from the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on 20 January.Trump had previously said he intended to fire Gensler on “day one” of his presidency after the chair of the SEC took legal action against cryptocurrency trading and platforms.“I thank President Biden for entrusting me with this incredible responsibility,” Gensler wrote in the post on X.Gensler was appointed chair of the SEC in 2021 and immediately called on Congress to give him more powers to regulate the “wild west” crypto-sector, saying that it was “rife with fraud, scams and abuse”
The fierce reaction to Australia’s new Future Fund mandate reflects how much has changed since 2006 | John Quiggin
The announcement by the treasurer, Jim Chalmers, that Australia’s Future Fund would be directed to invest in areas of national priority, rather than pursuing a purely commercial investment strategy, has drawn a strong reaction from Peter Costello and John Howard who established the fund in 2006. The ferocity of this reaction is a reminder of how much the world has changed since that time.The fund was established at the high point of neoliberalism, initially using the proceeds of the privatisation of Telstra. The worship of financial markets, and the disdain for public ownership of any kind was at its peak. The guiding principle was the “efficient markets hypothesis” which, in its strongest form, states that the asset prices prevailing in financial markets are the best guide to the returns available to any investment, public or private
Spain’s floods force some UK sellers to buy oranges from southern hemisphere
Trump’s picks of loyalists for financial posts ensures his economic agenda is unimpeded
What does the US Department of Justice want Google to do?
Deus in machina: Swiss church installs AI-powered Jesus
Russell claims Las Vegas F1 GP pole with Verstappen just ahead of Norris
The challenge for England is clear: they have to shut Japan out | Ugo Monye