Unions call for £200m from government to keep two Scunthorpe steel furnaces open

A picture


British Steel should get an extra £200m from the government to support it in keeping the UK’s two remaining blast furnaces open until electric replacements are built, according to a proposal put forward by unions.Chinese-owned British Steel has said it will replace its polluting blast furnaces at Scunthorpe with electric arc furnaces, which can be used to make much cleaner, recycled steel.However, unions are concerned that a rapid closure of the blast furnaces will result in the loss of nearly 2,000 jobs within months.The loss of as many as 1,900 of Scunthorpe’s 4,000 jobs could cause “severe socioeconomic consequences” for Lincolnshire, according to a report, seen by the Guardian, from Syndex, a consultancy commissioned by the Community, GMB and Unite unions.The British steel industry must switch away from coal-driven blast furnaces in order to meet net zero carbon targets.

The switch has already cost 2,500 jobs at Port Talbot, south Wales, where Indian-owned Tata Steel shut down its blast furnaces in September.British Steel has faced financial struggles that led it to the brink of closure before Christmas.Ministers have considered nationalising the company if it would save jobs.The unions’ proposals, which are aimed at preventing the thousands of Scunthorpe job losses happening immediately, would require an extra £200m to cover carbon costs charged to large polluters.Syndex argued that the government would have to step in to cover the costs to make retaining both blast furnaces “financially viable”, returning the steelworks to profit by 2027.

It said that was a better option than retaining just one blast furnace, because of high fixed costs, or closing both blast furnaces, because the company might lose access to raw materials.Roy Rickhuss, Community’s general secretary, said the proposals were a “roadmap towards a just transition for British Steel” without a “destructive cliff-edge”.The government has discussed offering British Steel £500m or more to match the support given to Tata for its upgrade.Ministers have committed up to £2.5bn to the industry on top of the Tata aid, but it is unclear how much of that could be given to British Steel.

The business secretary, Jonathan Reynolds, this week said the government would “champion decarbonisation without deindustrialisation”, as he launched a consultation on its steel plans.It comes as the industry around the world scrambles to work out the impact of 25% tariffs on all steel and aluminium imports to the US imposed last week by Donald Trump’s administration.Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionThe tariffs add to the difficulties for companies in countries such as the UK that were already having to cope with a global glut of steel amid a years-long crisis for China’s property industry.The head of UK Steel, a lobby group, said the tariffs were “a sledgehammer to free trade”, and the industry is bracing for producers in China and elsewhere to divert steel to the UK and Europe.That could put further downward pressure on prices.

The steel market turmoil could make it more difficult for British Steel, owned by China’s Jingye, to fund a switch to the cleaner technology.Paul Nowak, general secretary of the Trades Union Congress said: “It’s vital we have a plan to continue to produce steel in the UK.To do that we need to modernise it and to decarbonise it – so we can compete with the countries who are already investing in modern steel making.”Electric arc furnaces are cleaner but they need extra facilities – which do not yet exist in the UK – to produce steel from iron ore.That has raised concerns among some politicians and defence officials that the closure of Scunthorpe could leave the UK without a key capability for a military nation.

A British Steel spokesperson said: “British Steel is in active discussions with the UK government about the future of our steelmaking operations.Our trade union partners will be an important part of that future, and we welcome their contribution to the debate in the Syndex report.”
politicsSee all
A picture

The cameras weren’t rolling, so no one saw Lammy neglect to tackle Dictators United | John Crace

If a tree falls in the forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound? If the foreign secretary makes a speech to the G20 in South Africa and someone forgot to switch on the televised stream, did it really happen?This was meant to be David Lammy’s big day out. His Foreign Office team had briefed in advance that this was to be his most forceful intervention on Ukraine yet. No more Mr Nice Guy. No more couching his words in the language of twisted diplomacy. Just shooting from the hip

A picture

‘Russia has learned nothing’ over Ukraine war, says David Lammy – as it happened

Foreign secretary David Lammy has been speaking at the G20 foreign ministerial meeting in South Africa.Referring to the Ukraine war, he criticised Russia for having “learned nothing”, adding: “we are at a crucial juncture in this conflict, and Russia faces a test”.He said that the only “just and lasting peace” will be a peace “consistent with the UN charter” which “rejects Tsarist imperialism”.Lammy was also critical of Russian minister for foreign affairs [Sergei] Lavrov for his “logic of imperialism dressed up as realpolitik”.He said:You know, mature countries learn from their colonial failures and their wars, and Europeans have had much to learn over the generations and the centuries

A picture

Priest insulted by Andrew Gwynne in WhatsApp group calls for him to resign

A serving Anglican priest has called for Andrew Gwynne to resign after new WhatsApp messages emerged in which the member of parliament suggested she should be “burned on a bonfire”.She described the chat involving two Labour MPs, as well as several other Labour party members, as “reminiscent of playground bullying and name-calling”.The vicar is mentioned more than 100 times in the chat, with the group, which also includes several sitting councillors from two local authorities, making repeated jibes about her weight.“Imagine [her] in a bike,” one says.“Haven’t you seen her pootling round Reddish

A picture

We need a debate on defence spending as Nato unravels, putting Europe at risk | Letters

With current and past leaders of the armed services joining the Americans in calling for ever greater percentages of national income to be devoted to defence, some hardheaded thinking is going to be needed (Starmer will go in ‘bin of history’ if he fails to raise defence budget, says ex-army chief, 15 February).Unless defence spending contributes to growth, we could have the absurd situation of increasing the proportion of GDP spent on defence without any material increase in the actual amount available; 2.5% of substantial growth is better than 3% of an economy flatlining.We must also surely want a national debate on the kind of defence spending we want – matching a very different threat to that experienced in the 20th century and requiring not necessarily more personnel, but greater creativity and skill in combating the threat of the future.Above all, however, we should have a national debate about what other key services are going to be denied investment as a consequence of the ever-increasing demand to combat a real or perceived threat from the Russian federation

A picture

Lisa Nandy announces £270m fund for England’s ‘crumbling’ cultural infrastructure

Culture has been “erased” from communities and curriculums, according to the culture secretary, Lisa Nandy who vowed to make the arts more accessible by announcing new funding for England’s “crumbling” cultural infrastructure.The £270m fund will support attractions “in urgent need of financial support to keep them up and running, helping to carry out vital infrastructure work and improve long-term financial resilience”, according to the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS).Nandy said: “For too many young people in this country, culture hasn’t just been erased from the curriculum, it’s been erased from our communities as well.“The Arts Everywhere Fund is designed specifically to address that, to make sure that communities who value their heritage and the contribution that they’ve made to this country can still continue to open those institutions to communities and tell that story as part of our national story.”The money includes £120m, which will be available to 17 leading institutions such as the British Museum, National Gallery and National Museums Liverpool, which all get money directly from the DCMS

A picture

Chief whip’s diaries reveal rescue of Tory MP from ‘KGB agent’ in London brothel

They say that to govern is to choose, but for one former chief whip it meant rescuing a Conservative MP from a suspected “KGB agent” in a London brothel.The story of said MP is one of many colourful anecdotes in Simon Hart’s political diaries, which have become the talk of Westminster this week.Hart, who served as Rishi Sunak’s chief whip for nearly two years, offers a rare glimpse behind the scenes of his government — including the sexual misadventures of members of the whips’ office.He also lifts the lid on Sunak’s troubled premiership, including the tensions between ministers and how whips grappled with a series of misconduct allegations involving Tory MPs.On 24 November 2022, Hart recalls getting a phone call at 2