A prize worth pursuing: has Elizabeth line shown what rail investment can achieve?
Halfway to a billion journeys, and it’s only just begun,Amid the recent gloom, struggles and doubts besetting Britain’s railway there is a bright beacon of hope: the Elizabeth line,Now accounting for one in seven national rail journeys, the east-west cross-London railway has smashed forecasts and remoulded the travel habits and urban geography of the south-east,So far, so good for the lucky Londoners upgraded from the tube to a far quicker, cleaner and quieter ride,But beyond, with the north of England still waiting for promised better railways, and a chancellor beating the drum for infrastructure investment, the line serves to demonstrate that the nation can indeed still build things, and that the people will absolutely come.
Last month the Elizabeth line reached a milestone of 500 million passengers since it opened in May 2022.That figure has all but restored rail’s official passenger numbers to pre-Covid levels, fuelling the belief of those in the industry who forecast usage would boom again.The well-heeled commuters from the stockbroker belt who once poured into London are yet, if ever, to return in pre-pandemic numbers, but the Elizabeth-line stations of Liverpool Street and Paddington have overtaken Waterloo in the list of Britain’s busiest.From Paddington’s smart office development in west London, to houses, jobs and conferences landing near new stations at points east, such as Woolwich and Thamesmead, regeneration has been the story of the line.In recent reports published by Transport for London (TfL) and the engineering consultancy Arup analysing the line’s impact – based on data that was yet to capture the full swell of passengers – more than 90% of customers said it had changed their area for the better.
Nearly two-thirds said it had also made it easier to access jobs and employment,TfL’s analysis shows that within a kilometre of an Elizabeth line station in London, the number of new houses is 8-14% higher, and nearly 400,000 jobs have been created since 2015,House prices around the stations have also increased sharply,Launching the report, London’s mayor, Sadiq Khan, concluded: “When you invest in high-quality transport infrastructure it can provide huge benefits for increased jobs, growth and the new housing we need in London and across the country,”The latest TfL figures show that Elizabeth line growth continues to outstrip its budgeted increase: a 16% rise in traffic in the first quarter of 2024-25.
The line’s director, Howard Smith, director of the Elizabeth line, also said it had not just improved links and capacity but “transformed accessibility”, with level boarding and lifts throughout, and “had vital economic impact across the whole country via a UK-wide supply chain”, including more trains being built in Alstom’s factory in Derby,“We will continue to focus on improving … and look forward to introducing ten additional Elizabeth line trains to support passenger demand, including at Old Oak Common when it opens as the initial terminus for HS2 services,” he said,Confidence in infrastructure building has been dented, at the very least, by the HS2 high-speed rail project’s experience of ripped-up plans and blown budgets, but the intersection at Old Oak Common ploughs ahead,The Elizabeth line was similarly plagued by delays and indecision, with construction eventually finished three years late and £3,5bn over budget – which perhaps demonstrates how soon the issues are forgotten once construction is done.
“It’s a step change up in technology and I think that’s what makes it so attractive, really unlike any underground railway in any city,” said Christian Wolmar, the author of The Story of Crossrail, as the project was originally known.“When you get off the cramped tube, at somewhere like Tottenham Court Road, and emerge into these huge platforms and 250-metre long trains, this completely different world … If only we could have three or four lines like that the whole city would be transformed.We don’t quite have the imagination or the money to make it happen.”The comparatively swish functioning – from the back-end control and operations to the wide platforms, safety doors and spacious carriages – does not make it immune from all of rail’s problems.In the coming weeks it faces four days of drivers’ strikes called by Aslef over pay.
Sharing a railway with the national network has made parts of the line to the west, in particular, as susceptible as any to delay.And being unequipped with toilets its trains are potentially far worse places to be stuck, as when the overhead cables came down in December 2023.But latest performance figures – well over 90% of trains on time with less than 2% cancelled, and customer satisfaction scores comfortably exceeding the rest of the TfL network – show clear improvement along with booming ridership.About 35% of its passengers come from pure “abstraction”, in Department for Transport parlance: luring customers in from other lines, who might otherwise have commuted in on a Great Western train from Maidenhead, chugged through the West End on the Central line, or taken the far pricier Heathrow Express train to the airport.Another third of the passengers were already on TfL Rail, the outer London precursor subsumed into the Elizabeth line.
But almost 30% are people who would have driven or previously decided that the journey was not worth the effort,This matters significantly for rail because investment decisions have been torn between two camps: the traditional Treasury benefit-cost ratios, which critics saw as unduly leaning towards building more infrastructure or improving connections that people already used; or the faith that better public transport will inevitably stimulate new houses, jobs and journeys,Given its location in the most populated corner of Britain, the Elizabeth line, with a guaranteed market, might never sway the first camp,Nonetheless, the appeal of better links throughout the country is visible in the success of 10 years of Borders Rail, the 30-mile Edinburgh-Tweedbank line, and the instant appeal of the new Northumberland Line, which carried 50,000 passengers in its first month,Henri Murison, the chief executive of the Northern Powerhouse Partnership, said: “The assumptions on benefits are always wildly lower … they underestimate how transformational the projects will be.
”Despite the strength of feeling on relative underinvestment in the north, Murison stressed the importance of focusing on the Elizabeth line’s success: “It gives an informed discussion on what’s genuinely possible: it’s generated huge opportunities in London and that’s exactly what we could generate in Northern cities with the line – you’d get significant wider investment as well.”Rachel Reeves has loosened the fiscal rules and committed to fuelling infrastructure investment, but expectations for public spending on rail are muted since the cancellation of HS2’s northern leg.Stung by a decade of inaction since what Murison terms the “grandiose commitments” of more than one Conservative leader to a high-speed line across the north, steadily securing the pieces of the jigsaw – the TransPennine upgrade, a Bradford station, Manchester’s airport link – is now seen as the surer path.However long that infrastructure takes, the Elizabeth line should demonstrate that it is a prize worth pursuing.As Wolmar put it: “It shows very strongly that if you spend a little bit of extra money making the tunnels bigger and design something attractive, that brings people to it.
It justifies public investment, and doing it to a decent standard.”
‘My paedophile letters’: French surgeon to stand trial accused of abusing 299 child patients
When two gendarmes knocked on her door in 2019, Marie had no idea that she was about to find herself at the dark heart of one of the world’s biggest child abuse cases.The French mother of three, now 38, was shocked when the officers told her she had been the victim of Joël Le Scouarnec, a surgeon and an alleged serial paedophile accused of raping and sexually abusing hundreds of children.She recalled asking them: “Was I touched?”“No, madame. Raped,” they replied.“I couldn’t think they were talking about me
NHS facing ‘crisis of public trust’ as most people fear being failed by A&E services
Three in four people in the UK fear getting stuck on a trolley in a hospital corridor or an ambulance not arriving after dialling 999, prompting claims that the NHS is facing “a crisis of public trust”.Huge numbers also worry about their local A&E not having enough beds (77%) and not being able to get care at their GP surgery (70%), research also found.Public concern about the parlous state of the health service is so acute that one in three people (34%) are reluctant to seek help at A&E because they think it will be overwhelmed.Even greater numbers – 43% – are so concerned about slow 999 response times that they would be likely to take a taxi to hospital rather than wait for an ambulance.The results, in a survey by the polling company Ipsos, are “worrying and frightening in equal measure”, said Dr Adrian Boyle, the president of the Royal College of Emergency Medicine
New laws to protect children exploited by gangs in England and Wales ‘will save lives’
Long-overdue laws to protect children forced into selling drugs across county lines will save lives and block a “brutal and lucrative criminal business”, the former children’s commissioner has said.In a series of new measures aimed at cracking down on exploitative gangs and antisocial behaviour, criminals using children to run county lines or commit other crimes will face up to a decade in prison.The new law, which campaigners have long called for, will make it a specific offence in England and Wales to use a child to commit criminal activity, while new child criminal exploitation prevention orders will also restrict criminals’ ability to operate, said the home secretary, Yvette Cooper.“The exploitation of children and vulnerable people for criminal gain is sickening and it is vital we do everything in our power to eradicate it from our streets,” Cooper said.The orders will limit suspected groomers by preventing them working with children, contacting specific people or going to a certain area, with breaches resulting in up to five years in prison
NHS failings and lawyers have destroyed memories of our baby, say parents
Losing Ben at the age of eight weeks in the paediatric intensive care unit of the Bristol Royal hospital for children in the spring of 2015 was traumatic and heartbreaking for Jenny and Allyn Condon.In the 10 years since, they say their pain has not eased but, if anything, has been made more acute by the way they have been treated by a health trust as they campaigned to find out why Ben died.“It has destroyed me,” said Jenny, who tried to kill herself and has post-traumatic stress syndrome. “I’m a broken woman. I’m in constant fight or flight
Caps unlock: a short history of writing in lower case | Letters
This is a welcome development, but far from new (The death of capital letters: why gen Z loves lowercase, 18 February). The case for lower case has been made for over 200 years, at least here in germany, where its most vocal proponents were the brothers grimm of fairytale fame: “Whoever uses capitals at the beginning of nouns is a pedant!” (I paraphrase). At the beginning of the 20th century, aesthetes and modernists like stefan george did it almost religiously. In the 60s and 70s, leftist iconoclasts again used the kleinschreibung (small-letter writing) to signal non‑conformity and progressiveness, and some of my friends are doing it to this day. As these trends have a habit of catching on internationally, I’m hoping for some cool grandpa vibes any day now
Every hour children spend on screens raises chance of myopia, study finds
Every hour young people spend in front of screens increases their chance of being shortsighted, researchers have found, with experts warning young children should have limited use of devices and spend more time outdoors.Myopia is caused by having an over elongated eyeball and is a growing problem, with research suggesting about 40% of children and adolescents worldwide could have the condition by 2050.While genetics play a role in who develops myopia, other factors that increase risk include not spending enough time outdoors and focusing on things that are close up for prolonged periods, which could explain why screen time has been associated with a higher risk and severity of myopia.Now, researchers in Korea say they have shed fresh light on this relationship in an analysis of 45 studies, involving 335,524 participants, that looked at the use of digital screen devices such as mobile phones, game consoles and television.The results, largely based on data from children, adolescents and young adults, reveal that an additional hour of daily screen time is, on average, associated with 21% higher odds of having myopia
Who is ‘working class’ and why does it matter in the arts?
Noel Clarke loses appeal court challenge that could have delayed Guardian libel trial
Stephen Colbert on Trump: ‘With this guy, every troll is a trial balloon’
The Sims at 25: a terrifying facsimile of life, death and the endless cycle of work
Stephen Colbert on Elon Musk: ‘An unelected donor running an unauthorized employee kill squad’
Indie legend Miki Berenyi: ‘There was a falling out in Lush. And, if I’m honest, it still hurts’