Timid FCA has retreated too far on its ‘name and shame’ proposals
Lobbying victories for the City do not come much more comprehensive,Last year, the Financial Conduct Authority, the industry regulator, put forward a proposal that it should be able to name firms under investigation more frequently,Greater openness at an earlier stage, argued the FCA, could deter bad behaviour and protect consumers,A “public interest” test on disclosure would be better than the existing “exceptional circumstances” rule that was so stifling that the FCA was silent even as British Steel pensioners, in a well-publicised scandal in 2017, were fleeced by unscrupulous financial advisers who gave them terrible advice,But the uproar from City firms and lawyers over the FCA’s proposals was loud and persistent.
They painted the plans as an offence against natural justice,Mere disclosure of an investigation could harm a company’s reputation even if it was found eventually to be innocent – and 65% of FCA’s cases, they noted, have historically resulted in no further action,The “name and shame” shorthand for the proposals stuck,The lobbyists’ trump card was the familiar one that the FCA would damage the City’s competitiveness and UK growth,Ministers, under the last Tory government and today’s Labour one, adopted the line.
Thus the outcome on Tuesday of the FCA’s review of “transparency around enforcement investigations” was expected: reform is scrapped.The only surviving elements are ones nobody could possibly have regarded as objectionable, such as ending the absurdity whereby the FCA could not confirm the fact of an investigation even when the corporate subject of the inquiry had itself revealed the news in a public filing to an overseas regulator.Otherwise, it’s a full retreat by the FCA.“Given the lack of consensus,” said its chief executive, Nikhil Rathi, the regulator will stick to its old “exceptional circumstances” test.Some of the City’s criticisms were reasonable, it should be said.
The FCA’s initial proposals were vague on how the “public interest” bar would be applied.While the regulator obviously wasn’t going to risk a run on a bank, there wasn’t much else to go on.And it was true that few other jurisdictions had attempted anything similar, which left the door open to the grumble about London imposing anti-competitive rules on itself.Yet one still comes back to cases such as the British Steel pension scheme.Even City opponents of the FCA’s proposal tended to concede it was a nonsense that the regulator felt it couldn’t intervene to prevent a small scandal becoming a big one.
Is the FCA seriously saying it would have to do the same again in a similar case? It seems it is.Rathi confirmed that “our current interpretation” is that a British Steel-like example still wouldn’t qualify under the “exceptional circumstance” bar.The reason is that poor financial advice doesn’t count as “exceptional”.That is a depressing outcome to this consultation.Even an uncontentious, minor consumer-friendly improvement has been lost for the sake of protecting City competitiveness.
No wonder consumer and whistleblowing groups are dismayed.The only token tilt in their direction is the FCA’s idea of publishing occasional thoughts on “issues” under investigation without naming names.But that reads as a formula for talking in code.It is all a very long way from the original intention to use greater transparency to “support public confidence” and “reassure consumers”.Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionThe FCA’s hand, one can agree, was forced if the government of the day is opposed.
And, yes, growth obviously matters: in another corner of its patch, the FCA’s reforms to listing rules for public companies have generally been pragmatic.But consumer protections are also important.A watered-down compromise version of the transparency proposals should have been possible.Instead, there’s nothing left.
John Lewis staff miss out on bonus despite profits jump; Britain’s housing market loses steam – business live
Donald Trump’s trade policies could tip Germany, Europe’s largest economy, into another recession, the president of the country’s central bank warns.The Germany economy has shrunk in the past two years and with US tariffs, the country “could expect a recession for this year” too, Joachim Nagel, the head of the Deutsche Bundesbank, told the BBC World Service.Without the impact of tariffs, the bank forecasts the German economy will grow moderately, by about 0.2%, he said.Nagel said “there are only losers” when it comes to tariffs, and backed the EU’s countermeasures against Trump’s 25% levy on all steel and aluminium imports from overseas imposed yesterday
John Lewis profits triple to £126m but hopes for staff bonus dashed again
The owner of John Lewis and Waitrose has tripled profits to £126m but workers at the staff-owned retail group have missed out on a bonus for a third year in a row.The John Lewis Partnership (JLP) said sales rose 3% to £12.8bn in the 12 months to 25 January 2025, as underlying profit rose from £42m. However, the company said it was prioritising investment over the bonus with plans to spend £600m on transforming the business.Jason Tarry, the chair of the John Lewis Partnership, said: “These are solid results, which show that our customers are responding well to our investments in quality products, value and service
AI should replace some work of civil servants, Starmer to announce
AI should replace the work of government officials where it can be done to the same standard, under new rules that have prompted unions to warn Keir Starmer to stop blaming problems on civil servants.As part of his plans for reshaping the state, the prime minister will on Thursday outline how a digital revolution will bring billions of pounds in savings to the government.Officials will be told to abide by a mantra that says: “No person’s substantive time should be spent on a task where digital or AI can do it better, quicker and to the same high quality and standard.”In his speech, Starmer will claim that more than £45bn can be saved by greater use of digital methods in Whitehall, even before AI is deployed, with 2,000 new tech apprentices to be recruited to the civil service.However, with bruising cuts on the way at this spring’s spending review, Dave Penman, the general secretary of the FDA union for senior civil servants, said: “Mantras that look like they’ve been written by ChatGPT are fine for setting out a mission, but spending rounds are about reality
Apple to appeal against UK government data demand at secret high court hearing
Apple’s appeal against a UK government demand to access its customers’ highly encrypted data will be the subject of a secret high court hearing, the Guardian understands.The appeal on Friday will be considered by the investigatory powers tribunal, an independent court that has the power to investigate claims that the UK intelligence services have acted unlawfully.It is against an order served by the Home Office in February under the Investigatory Powers Act, which compels companies to provide information to law enforcement agencies.The Home Office asked for the right to see users’ encrypted data in the event of a national security risk. Currently, not even Apple can access data and documents protected by its advanced data protection (ADP) programme
Lewis Hamilton says outside pressure ‘non-existent’ ahead of F1 Ferrari debut at Melbourne
Lewis Hamilton has insisted he has nothing to prove and feels no pressure going into his first race for Ferrari at the Formula One season opener in Melbourne this weekend, with the seven-time champion simply revelling in what he described as the most exciting period of an already long and storied career.Hamilton, who made his F1 debut in 2007 and is now entering his 19th season in the sport, will make his debut with Ferrari at Albert Park after six years at McLaren and then 12 at Mercedes.Driving for the Scuderia had long been a childhood dream for the British driver and the interest in his switch to racing for the sport’s most famous and most successful marque has already been intense, reaching an apogee in the buildup to the opening meeting in Albert Park.Hamilton, speaking before the teams take to the track for the first time on Friday in Melbourne, conceded he was aware the task facing him of adapting to a new team, based in Italy at 40 years old and coming up to speed in no short order was considerable. But he felt confident in his ability to deliver
‘I enjoy being the hunted’: Oscar Piastri takes his place among Formula One title contenders | Jack Snape
He has the face of a child and the nutritional preferences to match, but nobody doubts Oscar Piastri deserves his place at the Formula One grown-ups’ table. The 23-year-old helped McLaren to the constructors’ championship with two race victories last year, and has emerged as a genuine contender for the driver’s crown in 2025.Days before this week’s first race of the season in Melbourne, the chocolate milk-loving, chicken parmigiana-ordering Victorian isn’t tempering expectations. “It’s hard to not be confident when you’ve got the championship-winning team around you,” Piastri said at his latest sponsor’s engagement on Wednesday evening, for McLaren partner Airwallex.“This year, I think we’re as confident as we have been since I’ve joined the team, that we can start the year off on a good note
Nearly one in four Britons have witnessed shoplifting, study shows
Trump’s senseless tariffs will extend the economic malaise felt by so many in Australia – and around the world | Nicki Hutley
ChatGPT firm reveals AI model that is ‘good at creative writing’
iPhone 16e review: Apple’s cheapest new phone
Warner joins London Spirit in men’s Hundred but Anderson unsold in draft
Borthwick deserves credit after bold selection for England’s Wales test