Animal spirits: Labour want to unleash them – but what do they actually mean?
‘We’re all sick of Britain being in the slow lane … we want to see a revival of those animal spirits so that we can grow the economy and bring investment here,” said Rachel Reeves on her return from Davos last week,Plainly a memo has gone round: in a radio interview this morning, business secretary Jonathan Reynolds claimed Labour’s willingness to take bold decisions “unleashes the animal spirit, the sense of something exciting happening”,When Reeves set out her plan for growth this afternoon, she reprised many of her Davos themes,She’s on a strange crusade against newts and bats, holding wildlife concerns responsible for Britain’s anti-growth mindset; she thinks bringing down net migration and fearlessly growing the economy are compatible and equal priorities; she’s putting a hell of a lot of faith in extra airport runways,But at least this time she wasn’t saying we should be more like Trump.
But what does “animal spirits” mean? Does it mean what Reeves thinks it means? Is it a useful concept? And how do we get hold of some of these spirits?The phrase is first found in a 16th-century medical tract (and you should feel free to go back to Bartholomew Traheron if you want to lol at early surgery), but in its economic sense it was coined by John Maynard Keynes in his 1936 key text, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money.“A large proportion of our positive activities depend on spontaneous optimism rather than on a mathematical expectation,” Keynes wrote, elegantly answering the eternal question about economists: if they’re so smart, how come they’re always wrong? Because human psychology, singly and in herds, is much more powerful than maths.Depressions happen when business investment and consumer spending get into a doom loop, and no formula can explain this; it’s simply driven by pessimism.I’m making it sound baggy (“just vibes!”) but it was precisely this quality in Keynes – his willingness to be mystified, his refusal to stop at the hard edge of what reason and groupthink dictated, but rather, to test it against observable realities – that made him such an enduring and original theorist.Two American professors, George Akerlof and Robert J Shiller, the first an economics Nobel prize-winner, took up the idea in 2009, when global depression was again at the forefront of everyone’s minds.
They dug deeper into optimism, and what conditions might create it: trust in one another, in government, in institutions and in corporations; storytelling, specifically narratives of plenty rather than scarcity; faith in justice; the absence of corruption,Their book, Animal Spirits: How Human Psychology Drives the Economy, and Why it Matters for Global Capitalism, is a really good read for non-economists,Its conclusion was more profound than “mood matters”,It basically called out neoliberalism from inside the house,If people perceive unfairness, mendacity, scarcity, bad faith, it will quell their optimism and economies will suffer.
Markets need rules, in other words.Unfettered capitalism seeds its own undoing.This isn’t at all what Rachel Reeves is talking about.Her ideas centre on the removal of regulation.She wants a more permissive planning approach, less environmental claptrap (see runways, bats).
But it’s a mixed picture – she also cheered on a proposed £250m magnet factory in Oxfordshire, whose combination of job creation (1,000 skilled posts) and state-endorsed research and development would be exactly what Keynes had in mind for a mood-boost, and Akerlof and Shiller would call great storytelling,Reeves wants to halt the talk of decline, while clinging to the declinist narrative that migrants are the problem,Her theory of growth seems to be basically Beetlejuice (say it three times and it will magically appear),And her call to action is that we all just cheer the hell up,To be honest, the speech did cheer me up a little bit.
However bad things are, at least I’m not chancellor.
Eurozone economy stagnated ahead of European Central Bank interest rate decision – business live
The eurozone economy did not grow in the final three months of 2024, adding weight to the argument that the European Central Bank will ease interest rates further this year.Eurozone GDP growth came in at 0% quarter-on-quarter for the fourth quarter of 2024, according to the European Commission. That was a steep drop from the 0.4% growth rate in the previous quarter.It was also unexpected: a poll of economists by Reuters found that the consensus expectation was for growth of 0
Meta posts robust fourth-quarter earnings amid DeepSeek mania
After an unprecedented delay, Meta reported earnings more than half an hour after market close on Wednesday. The company posted $48.39bn in fourth-quarter revenue and earnings per share of $8.02, handily beating Wall Street projections of $46.9bn and $6
Sri Lanka v Australia: first men’s cricket Test, day two – live
14th over: Sri Lanka 44-3 (Chandimal 9, Mendis 13) Lyon is round the wicket to Chandimal who gets off strike with a poke into the off side. Mendis blocks out the rest. Todd Murphy is coming on to replace Kuhnemann, we’ve ten minutes or so to the close of play – Sri Lanka really can’t afford to lose another wicket before then.13th over: Sri Lanka 43-3 (Chandimal 8, Mendis 13) Kamindu Mendis decides he isn’t going to revert completely into his shell, a length ball from Kuhnemann is slapped high and long over midwicket for SIX. The left-handed (but both really) batter sweeps fine to pick up four off the final ball of the over
Evil toilets, terror food and billionaire Squishmallows: my eye-popping day at the UK’s giant toy fair
With the UK toy market now worth £3.4bn, we storm the high-security world of fun – and find possessed loos, creepy-crawlies in sushi rolls and more plastic than a petrochemical conventionThe Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.A chubby baby dinosaur waddles down a pink carpeted aisle, narrowly avoiding an army of Care Bears tramping in the other direction
Shell investors in line for multibillion-dollar windfall despite weak profits
Shell has given its investors a multibillion-dollar windfall despite reporting weaker-than-expected profits of $23.7bn (£19bn) for last year as global oil and gas prices tumbled.Shareholders of Europe’s biggest oil company are in line for a 4% dividend increase alongside share buybacks of $3.5bn for the last three months of the year.This marks the 13th consecutive quarter in which Shell has given its investors buybacks of more than $3bn, despite falling earnings from its oil and gas
People in England with severe dust mite allergy to be offered daily pill on NHS
Thousands of people in England who live with severe dust mite allergy are to be offered a first-of-its-kind daily pill to treat the condition on the NHS.In final draft guidance published on Thursday, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice) has given the green light to a drug shown to reduce symptoms and improve quality of life.The tablet – 12 SQ-HDM SLIT, also known as Acarizax and made by ALK-Abelló – works by increasing the body’s resistance to house dust mites and is of particular benefit to people whose symptoms do not respond enough to treatment such as steroid nasal sprays and antihistamines.By taking a regular fixed amount of house dust mite allergy extract every day, the body can become less sensitive to the effect of dust mites, cutting the symptoms of the allergic reaction over time.The treatment is taken for three years at home to build up the body’s resistance
‘It was triggered by a Fellini-esque woman who pulled a knife on someone’: how the Only Ones made Another Girl, Another Planet
A wholesome escape from the housing crisis: the Facebook group dedicated to retro Australian homes
‘I was 25 and done with playing a teenager’: Asa Butterfield on Sex Education, stage fright and his ‘terrifying’ one-man play
Post your questions for Mike Scott of the Waterboys
TV tonight: Reese Witherspoon and Will Ferrell introduce their new wedding comedy
‘We won’t come again’: dazed visitors fed up with overcrowded Louvre