No room for reality as Yvette Cooper takes Nick Ferrari’s phone-in in her stride | John Crace

A picture


This was more like it.The kind of slow day when the government more or less looked like it was going to set the news agenda.Not be derailed by some catastrophe or cock-up.Or Donald Trump declaring war on Greenland and turning Gaza into a Middle East Riviera of golf courses and casinos.The world as one large real-estate deal.

These are the days that governments live for,A rare moment of stability,Nothing going visibly wrong,Or more wrong that it already was,A day when ministers have the illusion of being in control.

When their delusions were more or less aligned with reality.When Rachel Reeves could say the interest rate cut was all down to her.When Keir Starmer could go out and about and talk about his plans to build mini-nuclear reactors on every street corner and be guaranteed that a few people were actually listening.For Yvette Cooper, the morning started with a half-hour phone-in slot on LBC’s Nick Ferrari at Breakfast show.In times past, this could have been fraught with danger.

Nick is not known for being gentle with politicians, and most cabinet ministers look on his show as an endurance test.A necessary rite of passage.Something that can’t be avoided.Their goal? To get out alive having taken as little damage as possible.To bask in the absence of pain when it’s over.

But the home secretary is an experienced performer these days.Confident in her ability to play the game.On top of her brief.Certain she can fend off whatever comes her way.Yet still somehow guarded.

She doesn’t really do compassion.Or listening.She’s nobody’s first choice for a shoulder to cry on.Not the person to go running to if you’re in trouble.The opening question came from a woman whose son had been stabbed to death three years ago.

What was she doing about knife crime? Cooper leafed through her notes.Halve it in 10 years.Install scanners and arches in some schools.Stop kids buying knives online.Could she be certain this would be effective? Yes, she said.

Hmm.We all remember previous home secretaries saying much the same and look where we are.What no minister will admit is that no one can guarantee our safety.If a child is determined enough to carry a knife then no one can stop them.There are knives in every kitchen drawer.

Nor can you make sure that atrocities such as the Southport killings never happen again.Some people are so mad, so bad, that they are going to do horrific things.The mental health services and Prevent are never going to be entirely foolproof.They are going to make mistakes.Bad judgment calls.

Some bad people are inevitably going to slip through the net,We live in an imperfect world,We can learn lessons from every killing, every failure of the system,But we can’t stop some people from doing bad things,If history can teach us anything, it’s that we don’t have that much control.

But all that goes in the box of things that a home secretary and a radio interviewer can’t admit.It’s an affront to their sensibilities.An admission of their own limitations.So Ferrari asked Cooper what she could do to make sure young people stopped carrying knives and that there would never be another Southport attack.Cooper thought a moment.

“I would tell them to stop,” she said.Now why hadn’t the rest of us thought of that? If only we had realised it was that simple.Nick then played a recording of an interview with Katy, the daughter of the murdered MP David Amess.She wanted an inquiry into his killing.Just like there was going to be an inquiry into Southport.

Yvette prevaricated slightly,She would be releasing more details,Though she couldn’t say if it would be an inquiry inquiry,There were all sorts of inquiries and she wasn’t yet sure whether the inquiry she had in mind could in fact be called an inquiry,Weirdly, this made perfect sense to Ferrari.

Maybe he and Cooper have their own private language which is separate to ours.They operate in a meta-sphere where soon there will be an inquiry into everything.Our lives will all be put on pause while we all hold inquiries into everything that has gone wrong.Maybe there will be an over-arching inquiry into all the ongoing inquiries.Just to make sure they were functioning properly.

And why stop there? Why not have an inquiry into the over-arching inquiry? We could all slide into a parallel universe.Either way, Louise Casey is going to be one busy woman.We then moved on to a call from David.He was concerned that people were being showered with £3K of free clobber when they arrived in small boats.Yvette muttered something about criminal gangs.

Nick intervened.Were we really going to give hats and puffer jackets to new arrivals? He seemed to think we would be better off letting children freeze to death.If they hadn’t bothered to pick up clothes in Calais then they deserved hypothermia.For a moment it seemed that the “tough on gangs” home secretary might agree, but she demurred.She had done her 30 minutes.

All was well.She could leave the studio and get on with her day.Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotionAlso out on the airwaves was the shadow home secretary, Chris Philp.Always good for a laugh.He was out and about trying to convince himself that Kemi Badenoch’s new immigration ideas were properly thought through and not just some kneejerk response to the popularity of Reform.

On the Today programme, Nick Robinson made the fatal mistake that so many journalists make with Chris.He tried to take him seriously.A category error.Rather, he is a role model for halfwits everywhere.Within seconds of opening his mouth, Philp was out of his depth.

He clearly had no idea about who would be refused leave to remain and who wouldn’t.Robinson suggested the example of a Nigerian woman called Kemi working in McDonald’s.Would she be kicked out? What if she claimed benefits for a while? What if she got ill and needed the NHS? How low-paid was low-paid? Did people working in care homes count as making a contribution to society?The Philpster had no idea.Out of his depth in a sink.The David Cameron government had only promised to keep immigration down because we were in the EU then.

Er … Whatever happened to taking back control of our borders after Brexit.Poor Chris.He wasn’t even aware that he had been part of a government that had overseen record levels of legal migration.He sounded on the verge of tears.More in pity than despair, Nick sent him on his way.

Suddenly everything made sense,“I’ve been looking at an idiot,” he said to himself,
recentSee all
A picture

Rothschild braces for more ‘skeletons in the cupboard’ over conduct of late chair

Senior bankers at Rothschild & Co gathered on Tuesday in a meeting room at its St Swithin’s Lane headquarters in the heart of the City of London to discuss a memo that would shake the storied financial group to its foundations.The memo, to be sent to staff on Wednesday morning, would admit for the first time that their celebrated former leader, Sir Evelyn de Rothschild, had left the bank in 2004 after an allegation of sexual misconduct.There would be “more to come”, one person at the meeting said, shaking their head. Without question, there are “skeletons in every cupboard”, they said, as others expressed concerns that this could be the start of a wave of allegations putting the bank and its former chair in the spotlight.The attender was right to be worried

A picture

What do Trump’s tariffs mean for US-China trade?

Donald Trump postponed his threat to tax all imports from Mexico and Canada this week, citing action by those countries against migration and drug smuggling; but it was telling that tariffs on China went ahead.When it comes to the US’s neighbours, Trump’s Treasury secretary, the hedge fund manager Scott Bessent, made clear in a Fox News interview that tariffs are essentially a negotiating tool – partly aimed at achieving non-economic goals.But Trump’s beef with China is a much more longstanding and more widely shared one, that can be traced back to the deep imbalances between the two economic superpowers.“The grievances with China are far more genuine than grievances with Mexico, or with Canada,” says Neil Shearing, the chief economist at the consultancy Capital Economics, who is now writing a book about the clash between the rival economies.So it should not have been a surprise that Trump pressed ahead with promised 10% tariffs on China, which rapidly hit back with levies on a range of US goods

A picture

AI is developing fast, but regulators must be faster | Letters

The recent open letter regarding AI consciousness on which you report (AI systems could be ‘caused to suffer’ if consciousness achieved, says research, 3 February) highlights a genuine moral problem: if we create conscious AI (whether deliberately or inadvertently) then we would have a duty not to cause it to suffer. What the letter fails to do, however, is to capture what a big “if” this is.Some promising theories of consciousness do indeed open the door to AI consciousness. But other equally promising theories suggest that being conscious requires being an organism. Although we can look for indicators of consciousness in AI, it is very difficult – perhaps impossible – to know whether an AI is actually conscious or merely presenting the outward signs of consciousness

A picture

How some objects can have a mind of their own | Brief letters

I have great empathy with Adrian Chiles’ protectiveness of inanimate objects (Why am I so sad about seeing a robot get beaten up?, 5 February), but these objects can exercise tyranny, so we should beware the jacket that won’t let you put it on, the paper serviette that it is impervious to fluid and, of course, any self-hiding object.Jonathan HauxwellCrosshills, North Yorkshire If President Trump thinks that it is reasonable to relocate 2 million people from the Gaza Strip in the interests of peace (Report, 6 February), presumably the same logic should apply to the 500,000 Jewish settlers illegally occupying lands in the Palestinian West Bank.Ian MartinFalmouth, Cornwall If Donald Trump Jr decided to eat the rare duck he’s alleged to have shot in the Venice lagoon (Report, 5 February), would he get the orange sauce from his dad?David ProtheroHarlington, Bedfordshire When did laundry become the word for getting clothes at home clean (Pass notes, 5 February)? I still do the washing.Janet MansfieldAspatria, Cumbria A case of cutting his nose off despite his face (Makeup artist tried to remove Adrien Brody’s nose by mistake on set of The Brutalist, 6 February).Steve BarnesLondon Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section

A picture

Sri Lanka v Australia: second men’s cricket Test, day three – live

BIG WICKET! Chandimal is gone and so might the match be now for Sri Lanka. The batter used his feet and hit a powerfully struck drive but it was in the air and plucked by the bucket hands of Beau Webster at mid-off. That’s 550 Test wickets for Nathan Lyon too. He’ll have his eyes on a few more this afternoon.13th over: Sri Lanka 37-2 (Chandimal 11, Mathews 4) Angelo Mathews is the new man, he flicks over midwicket for four but did not look anywhere near in control

A picture

Hundred auction leaves counties feeling flush but no longer calling the shots | Ali Martin

Nine years ago one county chair revealed their club’s finances were so stretched that they were quite literally counting the loo rolls. Even the arrival of the Hundred in its first iteration – bringing an extra £1.3m per county per year – barely made a dent in some cases, the additional income swallowed up by rising costs, inflation, and the servicing of longstanding, significant debts.But over the past 10 days the outlook in the shires has changed considerably (perhaps even to the point of said club eyeing the quilted variety). At the time of writing, the England and Wales Cricket Board has raised around £400m by selling 49% stakes in six of the Hundred’s eight teams