Why is Elon Musk attacking Keir Starmer over the grooming scandal?

A picture


Elon Musk has reignited a political row about gangs of men who groomed and raped girls in England over several decades.In the past week the tech billionaire has shared a flurry of posts on his social media platform X accusing Keir Starmer and other senior politicians of covering up the scandal.It is the latest intervention by the SpaceX founder in UK political affairs, and his most incendiary yet – even triggering calls for Starmer to sue for defamation.On Monday the prime minister hit back at those “spreading lies and misinformation” and said “they’re not interested in victims, they’re interested in themselves”.Prosecutions for grooming and sexual abuse of young girls in England began in 2010, and the number of known victims is in the thousands.

The northern towns of Rochdale, Oldham and Rotherham were at the centre of the scandal,In 2014, a landmark inquiry into the abuse in Rotherham by Prof Alexis Jay came to the “conservative” estimate that 1,400 children had been exploited there between 1997 and 2013, predominantly by men of Pakistani heritage,In 2022, Jay concluded a prolonged national inquiry into child sexual abuse which warned it was “endemic” across England and Wales,Musk has made a number of unsubstantiated claims about the scandal on X, claiming that Starmer is “complicit” and should go to prison,He has also taken aim at Gordon Brown on the basis of a supposed Home Office memo sent to police forces during his premiership, telling them not to investigate alleged abuse because young girls had made a choice about their sexual behaviour.

The basis for this claim appears to be a BBC radio interview in 2018 with Nazir Afzal, the former chief prosecutor for north-west England who brought nine of the perpetrators to justice in 2012,Afzal clarified on X that he had been referring to some officers incorrectly interpreting part of a Home Office circular in 2008, which was drafted by officials not ministers, “as permitting them to allow a child, past the age of puberty, to continue engaging in sexual activity where the officer perceived them to understand dangers”,In a separate post Afzal stressed that “there was NEVER any circular or guidance specifically on ‘child rape gangs’ or ‘grooming gangs’”,Musk and the Conservative leader, Kemi Badenoch, have called for a fresh national inquiry, but Afzal and Jay have both said ministers should implement the recommendations of the 2022 inquiry instead,Starmer ran the Crown Prosecution Service between 2008 and 2013, meaning he was responsible for bringing charges for alleged crimes in England and Wales.

In 2009, nine months after Starmer took up the role, a decision was taken not to prosecute alleged perpetrators in Rochdale.CPS lawyers argued that the victim would not come across as reliable or credible.There is no evidence that Starmer was made aware of the details of the case, but nonetheless Musk has claimed that “Starmer must go and he must face charges for his complicity in the worst mass crime in the history of Britain”.In 2011, Afzal, the then new chief prosecutor for north-west England, overturned the 2009 CPS decision.Nine men were ultimately convicted and jailed in 2012 for the sexual exploitation of 47 girls.

Afzal said in 2022: “The only way we could bring that case was to admit that we had failed these victims when they had first made a complaint in 2008,Keir was 100% behind the decision to publicly admit that we had got it wrong in the past,”In 2013, Starmer revised CPS procedures on how prosecutors should deal with grooming cases in an effort to ensure that victims would not be dismissed in the future,Afzal later said: “Keir left in 2013, the CPS having gone from being dire at doing sex-abuse cases to having the highest conviction rate in our history,That wouldn’t have been possible without the support, resources and the protection I was given by Keir, at a time when it would have been easier to give up.

”Musk claimed on Monday that Starmer “repeatedly ignored the pleas of vast numbers of little girls and their parents, in order to secure political support”, even though he did not become a politician until 2015.Successive inquiries have concluded that police officers, social services and councils failed victims, but there is no evidence of any organised cover-up.Jay’s landmark report on Rotherham found “blatant” collective failures by the police and council.One of the later trials in 2016 found four men, three brothers Arshid, Basharat and Bannaras Hussain and their uncle Qurban Ali, guilty of 48 offences.The court heard about the failure by the local authority in Rotherham tasked with child safeguarding and police to act on detailed information passed to them.

One of the victims in the trial had testified that her parents had constantly made complaints to the police about the man who groomed her but “they did nothing” because she would not give a statement.“They even caught me in bed with him,” but let the perpetrator go, she told the court.Whistleblower Adele Gladman, a solicitor who worked with a youth project, pinpointed what was happening as far back as 2001, but said her concerns were repeatedly dismissed by police as anecdotal.When she submitted her report to South Yorkshire police, the feedback she got was that it was unhelpful.Musk, who is lined up for a senior role in Donald Trump’s administration and has been described by Nigel Farage as a “free speech absolutist”, has pursued something of a vendetta against Starmer since the start of his premiership in the summer.

The SpaceX founder took a dim view of Starmer’s robust response to the riots that broke out in response to a stabbing attack against young girls in Southport in late July.In the last week, Musk has shared posts claiming people convicted of sharing extreme rightwing material online have been given harsher sentences than perpetrators of the grooming scandal.
cultureSee all
A picture

‘They wanted a host without much personality’: Evan Davis and Peter Jones on Dragons’ Den

‘The left-hand driving glove was madness – while the baby dream machine and the armchair that converted into a gym for older people made me laugh’I was running a fairly successful telecoms business and had a phone call from the BBC saying that they’d like to come and chat. I was intrigued enough to say yes. I was late for our meeting and while he was waiting for me, Martyn Smith, the BBC’s producer, was watching people coming into my office saying: “What do you think of that? Should we do this?” He asked me, “What were those people doing?” I said: “Coming in and pitching ideas.” He said: “You’re not going to believe it …”He explained that Dragons’ Den was a format in Japan and they were thinking of putting together a UK version. He said: “All you have to do is sit in a chair as people come in and pitch you ideas

A picture

RuPaul’s Drag Race UK winner The Vivienne dies aged 32

James Lee Williams, known as drag artist The Vivienne, has died at the age of 32, their public relations representative announced on Sunday.Simon Jones posted on Instagram: “It is with immense sadness that we let you know our beloved James Lee Williams – The Vivienne, has passed this weekend.“James was an incredibly loved, warm-hearted and amazing person. Their family are heartbroken at the loss of their son, brother and uncle. They are so proud of the wonderful things James achieved in their life and career

A picture

‘Our thighs are aquiver!’ Inside the Siegfried and Roy opera with magic, tiger puppets and ‘hysterical sex’

Siegfried & Roy: The Unauthorised Opera tells the incredible story of the tiger-loving partners, from traumatic childhoods to their shocking career-ending showMagic doesn’t just happen. Opera singers Kanen Breen and Christopher Tonkin are learning that the hard way. Making magic is key to their onstage partnership as the stars of a new Australian opera about one of the most successful stage partnerships of all time – that of Siegfried Fischbacher and Roy Horn: two boys raised in postwar Germany with violent, alcoholic fathers, who became life and stage partners, created a celebrated magic and animal act in Europe in the 1960s, and then went on to become the highest-paid act in Las Vegas – until, in 2003, the duo’s beloved white tiger, Mantacore, put an end to their career in spectacularly bloody fashion.Siegfried & Roy: The Unauthorised Opera, co-written by director Constantine Costi and composer Luke Di Somma, is one of the centrepieces of this year’s Sydney festival.The first day of rehearsals with the production’s stage illusion consultant, Adam Mada, included the most important lesson in stage magic, says Breen: you never talk about how a trick is done

A picture

Director of Edinburgh international festival warns cuts put its status at risk

The director of the Edinburgh international festival has warned it could lose its status as one of the world’s greatest arts events without significant increases in public and philanthropic support.Nicola Benedetti, a Grammy-winning classical violinist who became the festival’s director in 2022, said in an interview with the Guardian she feared the creative arts that underpinned it were at risk of stagnating because of repeated funding cuts.She said an increase in Scottish government arts spending announced four weeks ago, while “a very welcome step in the right direction”, had come too late to prevent this year’s international festival being smaller.“It’s too close to impact our 25 festival in any significant way,” she said. “There are one or two late levers we’d be able to potentially pull [to stage extra events], but even that will be down to late availability

A picture

From Edvard Munch to Central Cee: Observer critics choose their cultural highlights for 2025

From Thom Yorke’s Shakespearean score to 25 years of Tate Modern, Bridget Jones to Leigh Bowery, our writers anticipate the most exciting shows, releases and events of the yearAmerican auteurs returnA new film from one of the heavy hitters of US cinema is always cause for celebration, and with projects from Kathryn Bigelow, Noah Baumbach and Paul Thomas Anderson on the horizon, there’s plenty to whet cineaste appetites in the coming year. Details on all three are scant at the moment. Kathryn Bigelow’s film, her first since Detroit in 2017, is a political thriller set in the White House, following staffers as they scramble to respond to an imminent missile strike on America. The cast includes Idris Elba, Rebecca Ferguson and Jared Harris.Even less is known about Noah Baumbach’s new film, which, like Bigelow’s, is a Netflix production

A picture

The big chill: warming, nourishing culture to help you hibernate until spring

Wolf Hall: The Mirror and the Light iPlayer Period dramas are traditionally rather cosy, but from the very first scenes – a stark restaging of Anne Boleyn’s beheading – it’s clear this adaptation of the final book in Hilary Mantel’s epic Thomas Cromwell trilogy will be a bracing immersion into the gruesome reality of these well-worn Tudor tales. Even so, the lavish production, exquisite performances and sheer beauty of the script itself are all things to luxuriate in during cold, dark winter nights. For newcomers, the original Wolf Hall series is also on iPlayer.Am I Being Unreasonable? iPlayer A magical romcom-style flashback – two lovers bidding farewell at a train station as snowflakes drift down – initially lends Daisy May Cooper’s hilarious and enthralling 2022 dramedy a winter wonderland vibe. The reality, however, is far less lovely