Politics about class, not identity, are better for the young adults I teach | Letters
Ash Sarkar is right to point out that the left’s sanctimony has alienated sections of the working class (The left keeps getting identity politics wrong – and the right is benefiting from that, 3 March).The young adults I teach include white working- and middle-class boys, and also girls, who struggle to find purpose, place and pride in their identity.In this increasingly atomised society, many of us have lost our allegiances to broad groups and seek to define our identities in ever-shrinking niches.And in unsafe times, belonging becomes so high-stakes that to be cast from the group for some perceived infringement is terrifying.The need we all have to feel a sense of belonging battles with the desire to be seen for “who you really are”.
But the truth is that knowing “who you really are” is your life’s work, and to solidify that in your young adult phase is restrictive and damaging.We have lost the broad and safe spaces in which we can explore, listen, grow, play with ideas and change our minds.Now, with the well-meant support of our peers and carers, we declare our team, nail our colours to the mast and unfortunately paint ourselves into corners.When a question can lead to expulsion from the group, we lose our own viewpoints.The only way to counter disagreement is to ridicule and shut down others.
How do we form broad, inclusive and safe alliances to replicate those we have lost? We need alliances where we share values but can tolerate a range of views that we may sometimes find uncomfortable, where we can explore challenging ideas and develop true resilience, rather than groups that exclude, cancel, reduce and alienate – ironically and tragically in the name of inclusion,Deborah O’ConnorLondon Thank you, Ash Sarkar, for such a timely analysis,Focusing on identity politics only benefits the right, as all it does is set us against each other,Rather than help us discover our shared interests and concerns, it atomises us into competing groups,Identity politics is a trap set by the right, and the left walked straight into it.
It’s time to focus on what we have in common and forge a new class politics,Francis HanlyLondon Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section,
UK Treasury ‘weighs up funding cuts at GB Energy’ in blow to Ed Miliband
The UK government is reportedly weighing up the possibility of cutting planned funding for GB Energy, the state-owned company set up by Labour to drive renewable energy and cut household bills, in June’s spending review.Cuts to the £8.3bn of taxpayer money promised over the five-year parliament would be another blow for Ed Miliband, the energy secretary, after he was overruled by the government when the chancellor, Rachel Reeves, backed the expansion of Heathrow’s third runway.GB Energy, a vital cog in Keir Starmer’s plans to “supercharge” Britain’s clean energy revolution, was only given an initial £100m in October’s budget to cover its first two years.Ministers are carrying out a “zero-based review” of all government spending, which has been given additional impetus after Starmer’s pledge to boost investment in defence
Andrew Bailey was accused by Barclays chair of having ‘destroyed’ Jes Staley, court hears
The Bank of England governor, Andrew Bailey, was accused by the Barclays chair of having “destroyed” Jes Staley, a court heard on Friday, after the City watchdog led by Bailey at the time launched an investigation into the banker’s ties to the convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.Nigel Higgins, who made the accusations and is still the Barclays chair, also asked in 2019 whether the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) would be willing to drop its investigation if Staley resigned.“We discussed whether there was a way for Mr Staley to step down from his position in order to avoid the investigation, which may have had some attraction for Barclays and Mr Staley,” Bailey said in a witness statement.However, he told Higgins it would be “impossible” to ignore a cache of emails from JP Morgan, which included a notorious exchange discussing Disney princess characters.“I explained that there was no way that we could avoid asking Mr Staley about the “Snow White” email,” Bailey, who was then running the FCA, said
‘Major brand worries’: Just how toxic is Elon Musk for Tesla?
Globally renowned brands would not, ordinarily, want to be associated with Germany’s far-right opposition. But Tesla, one of the world’s biggest corporate names, does not have a conventional chief executive.After Elon Musk backed Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) – calling the party Germany’s “only hope” – voters are considering an alternative to Tesla. Data released on Thursday showed that registrations of the company’s electric cars in Germany fell 76% to 1,429 last month. Overall, electric vehicle registrations rose by 31%
Crypto giant Tether CEO on cooperating with Trump administration: ‘We’ve never been shady’
Paolo Ardoino – head of the world’s most traded cryptocurrency, which is backed by Trump aide Howard Lutnick – claims Tether is benefiting the USPaolo Ardoino, CEO of the cryptocurrency company Tether, was flying over Switzerland last week as he contemplated the changing regulatory landscape.Tether used to be at war with the establishment. Now it is the establishment.The crypto giant – tether is the most traded cryptocurrency in the world – has had a strange trip. Four years ago, banks were dropping Tether as a client, and regulators in New York had the company against the wall over questions about commingled client and corporate funds
‘We can’t wait’: Scotland’s Townsend relishing France test after win over Wales
After dominating yet another match without maximising the return on the scoreboard, Scotland now face the daunting prospect of a trip to Paris to take on high-flying France, the one team scoring even more freely than Scotland. They will probably thrive on it.Gregor Townsend acknowledged that Scotland face the toughest assignment of all on Saturday night. “France scored 70 points against a very good Italian team,” he said. “They got 40 points against Wales, 40 points against Ireland
Coe targets Musk and Zuckerberg talks over ‘pond life’ abuse of female athletes
Sebastian Coe will demand urgent talks with Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg to stop “pond life” abusing female sports stars with impunity if he becomes International Olympic Committee president.Speaking after a week in which Emma Raducanu spoke about not being able “see the ball through tears” after being approached by a stalker, and Eilish McColgan faced a blizzard of hate after posting a video of her running on social media, Lord Coe pledged to create a taskforce to find better ways to protect female athletes.“It is vital that women feel that sport is a safe space,” he said. “You cannot have young athletes thinking the second you get public exposure that this comes at you like a waterfall of horror.”Asked what he made of comments posted on Facebook, Instagram and X attacking women, the World Athletics president, who is among the favourites for the IOC presidential election on 20 March, replied: “It’s pond life
Galthié’s gamble with lopsided bench pays off for France as Ireland unravel | Andy Bull
Fabien Galthié fears Antoine Dupont suffered ‘serious’ injury against Ireland
Scotland produce performance of extremes but survive Wales fightback
All the ingredients but no signature dish: England’s attack seeks sizzle
France take Six Nations title race to the wire with thumping win over Ireland
Cheltenham festival at crossroads five years after infamous Covid meeting