Home secretary rejects call for inquiry by family of murdered MP David Amess

A picture


The family of murdered MP Sir David Amess have criticised an “insulting” rejection by the home secretary of their calls for a public inquiry into his death, accusing the government of “adding salt on an open wound”,The home secretary said in a letter to Julia and Katie Amess that it was “hard to see how an inquiry would be able to go beyond” terrorist killer Ali Harbi Ali’s trial and the recently published Prevent learning review,In an emotional press conference, the MP’s daughter, Katie Amess, said she was “so, so angry that this was how they felt this should be dealt with and such sadness at the betrayal of people that are claiming to be my dad’s friends just fobbing us off again and again and brushing us under the carpet”,Amess’s family had hoped a public inquiry would identify previous Tory government failures in the run-up to his murder,Ali had been referred to Prevent seven years before he killed Amess on 15 October 2021, but his case was closed in 2016.

Cooper will instead appoint an independent external reviewer to look across the findings of the investigative work and scrutiny that has already been completed.In a statement from the family, Lady Amess said Keir Starmer should “go away and reconsider the government’s position” before the family’s meeting with the prime minister and Cooper on Wednesday.The late MP’s daughter said she was feeling “sadness, betrayal, pain and just heartbreak really” at the government’s response.The killer, who was inspired by Islamic State, stabbed the veteran MP at his constituency surgery in Essex and was sentenced to a whole-life order in 2022.In her letter to the family, Cooper said she could not interfere with a coroner’s decision and so could not officially support the resumption of the coronial inquest that the family had called for.

Cooper said she had to reject the request for a full public inquiry because the coroner had concluded there were “no additional questions that could be answered through an investigation of this kind, that had not already been considered as part of the trial”.She wrote: “In the circumstances it is therefore hard to see how an inquiry would be able to go beyond what has been reviewed in the trial, Prevent learning review, coroner’s report, as well as [David] Anderson and Essex police’s forthcoming conclusions.“I realise this is not the answer you were looking for.I remain keen to discuss this with you in the forthcoming meeting with the prime minister.”Lady Amess said the government should reconsider its position for the “security of all public servants, and for every citizen who deserves to know that when the state fails”.

She said: “Despite our repeated calls, we have been denied the one thing that can provide real answers – a full public inquiry.To pour salt on the wound, Yvette Cooper has now written us a totally unacceptable and quite frankly insulting letter confirming that the government will not order an inquiry, and that all the investigations to date should satisfy us.Well, I can tell her they most certainly do not.”Addressing what she expected from the prime minister, Lady Amess said: “He must go away and reconsider the government’s position and call us back in to confirm that an inquiry will be granted.“Not just for our family, but for the security of all public servants, and for every citizen who deserves to know that when the state fails, it will be held accountable and that steps will be taken to ensure there is no repeat.

”Katie Amess said Cooper’s letter had left her in “complete and utter disbelief”,She said: “I felt so sad on my dad’s behalf – he isn’t here any more to stick up for himself so I am trying to do that as much as I can, but I’m just absolutely heartbroken that Yvette Cooper could write this letter to my mother and I and think that we’re just going to go away and accept this,“It’s adding salt on to an open wound – that’s how I see it,Sadness, betrayal, pain and just heartbreak really,”Questioned on what she would say to the prime minister and the home secretary on Wednesday, she added: “I’m just going to plead my case and pray to God they’ll have a change of heart and realise that my dad was a human being.

He isn’t just a political figure in a game of chess, he’s a human being … he should still be here with us now if it wasn’t for completely preventable actions or the actions that weren’t taken.”Asked on Monday why the government had rejected the request, Starmer’s spokesperson said: “We understand that the Amess family is still looking for answers.Following the Southport tragedy, the government and counter-terrorism policing jointly commissioned an immediate Prevent learning review during the summer.That review identified that Prevent had significantly changed and improved in the decade since the attacker’s referral.“But in addition to the action already taken, we asked Lord Anderson, the interim Prevent commissioner, to examine whether the recommendations from the reviewer to Sir David’s death have been fully implemented.

cultureSee all
A picture

Womadelaide 2025: Róisín Murphy, Khruangbin and others lead a blissful, sweltering weekend

Botanic Park, AdelaideDespite the heat, this year’s festival was full of magical moments and big sounds, with musicians making fascinating genre connectionsAs the sun set on day three of Womadelaide, under the bat colony at Tainmuntilla (Botanic Park), the audience were in a trance. The Brooklyn-based Colombian musician Ela Minus mixed her voice with synthesisers, prompting a roar from the crowd; strobe lighting pulsed over the moving mass of bodies. The surrounding pine trees somehow seemed to make the reverb echo even stronger, lifting us up through the canopy to the open stars above.Minus’s music is complex and expansive, pop music meets house. We were all hypnotised, dancing as one, slick with a day’s worth of sunblock and sweat

A picture

Art with Cantona and puppet animals lined up for Manchester international festival

A giant herd of puppet animals raising awareness of the climate crisis and artwork inspired by footballers including Eric Cantona are part of the 10th edition of the Manchester international festival (MIF), whose organisers want visitors to have “a moment to reflect”.The former Manchester United footballer Juan Mata, the art curator Hans Ulrich Obrist and the writer, filmmaker and curator Josh Willdigg have put together the event’s “set piece”, a celebration of the beautiful game where artists and footballers collaborated on purpose-made artworks.The England Lionesses midfielder Ella Toone, the former Netherlands and Juventus enforcer Edgar Davids, and the Manchester United great Cantona are among the footballers taking part in Football City, Art United, which will take place in Aviva Studios and include sculpture, sound installations and animation.It was inspired after a conversation between MIF’s artistic director, John McGrath, the poet Lemn Sissay, Obrist and Mata, who saw MIF’s Poets Slash Artist show, where visual artists and poets collaborated, and asked if something similar could be done with footballers. Mata also featured in 2023’s edition of the festival, working with Obrist and Tino Sehgal

A picture

#MeToo movement ‘began to catch up’ with Noel Clarke, court hears

Women began discussing Noel Clarke’s past sexual misconduct in response to the #MeToo movement, the high court in London has heard, as he began giving evidence in his libel claim against the Guardian.Cross-examining Clarke for the Guardian, Gavin Millar KC told the actor he had begun to panic because the movement “began to catch up with you”.But during often combative cross-examination on Monday, the former Doctor Who star, said his female accusers were variously “lying”, “seeking attention” and had “jumped on the bandwagon”.He said the Guardian had “smashed my life for four years with this rubbish, this nonsense … I did not do this, I would not do this. I have got children, this is not true

A picture

‘It sounds terrible but I listen to it 30 times a day’: how the Lumineers made Ho Hey

‘We were moving away from bar band covers to doing our own songs. So shouting “Ho hey!” from the stage got people’s attention. We were doing it to be heard. Then suddenly everyone started listening’After growing up in Ramsey, a small town in New Jersey, we moved to New York to try to make it in music but found it a very difficult circuit to break into. Bars would let you play because they wanted your friends to buy drinks, but then they’d kick everybody out to get the next group in

A picture

Long live Joyce Carol Oates’ Twitter account: the only pure space left on this hell site

The 86-year-old author’s social feed might be her greatest contribution to literature – with philosophical musings on everything from US politics to an infected footAt the centre of most things is a skeleton. So it is for the online infamy of Joyce Carol Oates. In 2021, the award-winning novelist delivered her most significant contribution to literature: a diabolical tweet ruminating on the existentialism of Halloween.(you can always recognize a place in which no one is feeling much or any grief for a lost loved one & death, dying, & everyone you love decomposing to bones is just a joke.) https://t

A picture

Flamboyance, creativity, club culture – and no smart phones: why the 1980s are all the rage again

A series of major exhibitions focusing on the era has unleashed a wave of nostalgia for those who were there and curiosity from the young who envy its freedomIn the future everyone will blame the eighties for all societal ills, in the same way that people have previously blamed the sixties,” Peter York, the quintessential observer of 1980s’ style and cultural trends, said recently. He was referring to what he called the “big bangs” of monetarism, deregulation and libertarianism which “have been working their way through the culture ever since”.Curiously, he did not mention one of the eighties’ equally enduring, but more positive “big bangs” – the “style culture”, which began in that much-maligned decade and continues to echo through contemporary culture in an altogether less malign way. It is currently being celebrated in three exhibitions across London.At the National Portrait Gallery, the walls of several rooms are filled floor to ceiling with bright, glossy images from the Face magazine, which its press release describes as “a trailblazing youth culture and style magazine that has shaped the creative and cultural landscape in Britain and beyond”