‘Ridiculous’ cuts to AI cancer tech funding in England could cost lives, experts warn
Ministers have cut millions of pounds of funding for potentially life saving AI cancer technology in England, which cancer experts warn will increase waiting times and could cause more patients to die.Contouring is used in radiotherapy to ensure treatment is as effective and safe as possible.The tumour and normal tissue is “mapped” or contoured on to medical scans, to ensure the radiation targets the cancer while minimising damage to healthy tissues and organs.Normally, this is a slow, manual process that can take doctors between 20 and 150 minutes to complete.AI auto-contouring takes less than five minutes and costs around £10-£15 per patient.
Research shows that AI contouring can cut waits for radiotherapy by more than five days for breast cancer patients, up to nine days for prostate cancer patients and three days for lung cancer patients,In May 2024, the Conservative government announced £15,5m over three years to fund AI auto-contouring for all hospitals providing radiotherapy,Work continued on the scheme after the general election, with online webinars and follow-up calls for radiotherapy departments held in September,The 51 trusts offering radiotherapy continued to work on installing the cloud-based technology, with a number using it early, in the belief the funding was secured.
But in February, in an email seen by the Guardian, Nicola McCulloch, the deputy director of specialised commissioning at NHS England, said the funding had been cancelled “due to a need to further prioritise limited investment”.There would no longer be a centrally funded programme to support implementation of the technology, she said.The decision means many radiotherapy departments face a return to manual contouring, prompting accusations that the government is ditching digital and going back to analogue cancer care.Analysis by Radiotherapy UK has calculated that removing funding for AI contouring in England will add up to 500,000 extra days to waiting lists for breast, prostate and lung cancer alone and leave each of the 51 trusts with a £300,000 shortfall.Waiting lists for radiotherapy are already long.
Figures show that in January, 60% of cancer patients waiting to begin radiation treatment, nearly 1,000 people, waited longer than two months, and 23% waited more than 104 days,The chair of Radiotherapy UK, Prof Pat Price, said: “The government cannot laud the advent of AI in one breath, and allow this to happen,Far from moving from an analogue to digital NHS, when it comes to radiotherapy it feels like the opposite is happening,This wrong-footed decision will exacerbate the impact of severe staff shortages,”The leading oncologist urged ministers to intervene.
“Some departments are so short-handed that they’re shutting machines down because no one is there to operate them and nationally, radiotherapy vacancy rates are running at 8%.This investment in AI could have alleviated some of these pressures.Without it, cancer patients will wait longer than necessary for treatment, potentially costing their lives.”Clive Peedell, a consultant clinical oncologist at South Tees Hospitals NHS foundation trust, said: “This is a really catastrophic mistake.Half of all cancer patients will need radiotherapy at some point during the course of their treatment.
Labour is supposed to be the party of the NHS, but instead it is going against innovation in cancer care.“To just turn the tap off is ridiculous.We’ve had a big increase in cases, but we are managing our workloads because AI is helping us.If we can’t get the funding to keep using it, we’ll have to go back to planning treatment by hand.So we’ll probably have to employ more staff or have much longer waiting lists because of this terrible decision.
”Jane Richards (not her real name), a manager working in radiotherapy services, said the decision to pull funding for AI contouring felt like a betrayal.Her area had implemented the technology already, believing the funding from NHS England was assured.“Every time I see Keir Starmer or Wes Streeting talking about the importance of AI, I get frustrated,” she said.“We’re not talking about the future of a technology, we’re talking about something that we are making use of in the here and now and we are demonstrating has an impact, yet we don’t have central funding for it.“So I feel incredibly angry.
If you can only fit two patients into one manual radiotherapy planning clinic instead of four using AI contouring, and you’ve got four patients coming in each week, waiting lists are going to grow exponentially.And if they face longer waits, their prognosis will be worse.”Spencer Goodman, a professional officer for radiotherapy at the Society of Radiographers, said: “Radiographers recognise AI’s potential to improve patient care efficiency.Withdrawing funding for AI technologies that help define radiation fields in radiotherapy is a step backward.Given the current workforce shortage, proven AI tools can help streamline processes and enable faster, more accurate patient treatment, benefiting both providers and patients.
”A spokesperson for the Department of Health said “funding has not been cut”, but did not refer directly to the AI contouring funding decision.“This government is investing £70m in radiotherapy over the next year to replace old machines, so that patients can access the latest technology available.”They said AI was already being used in various areas of healthcare, including breast cancer diagnosis, and that the government’s national cancer plan was aimed at improving prevention, diagnosis, treatment and research.
Heathrow should not mark its own homework on energy resilience | Nils Pratley
“We purchase and pay for a resilient setup from our suppliers,” Thomas Woldbye, Heathrow’s under-pressure chief executive, told the transport select committee, adding that the airport racked up energy costs of £135m a year. “Are we then also supposed to have a setup next to it? And then we would have to have a whole power station at the cost of billions to the airlines.”So runs Heathrow’s case that there was no alternative to closing the airport for a full day last month after a fire knocked out a nearby National Grid substation, one of three serving the airport.Heathrow’s engineers had to reconfigure an internal grid to take electricity solely from the other two substations. The reconfiguration involved shutting down and restarting 1,000 systems and could not be done in less than 10 hours
Ex-Barclays boss ‘took a chance’ in lying about his links to Jeffrey Epstein, court hears
The former chief executive of Barclays Jes Staley took a “chance” in lying to the UK regulator about his relationship with Jeffrey Epstein amid fears that being truthful could end his career and fuel potential lawsuits by victims of the jailed child sex offender, a court has heard.The allegations were made by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) during closing statements for the high-profile case at the upper tribunal in London on Wednesday.The case is part of Staley’s efforts to overturn a lifetime ban from the UK’s financial sector, prompted by the FCA’s claims that he lied about the depth of his ties to the now-deceased sex offender in 2019.The FCA’s lawyer, Leigh-Ann Mulcahy, told the court on Wednesday that Staley had a “clear motive to mislead” the regulator about the relationship, which he “had been mischaracterising since 2015”. This was, in part, to protect his career, she said
UK government tries to placate opponents of AI copyright bill
The UK government is trying to placate peer and Labour backbencher concerns about copyright proposals by pledging to assess the economic impact of its plans.Creative professionals including Sir Paul McCartney, Sir Tom Stoppard and Kate Bush have strongly criticised ministers’ proposals to let artificial intelligence companies train their models on copyright-protected work without permission, unless the rights holder opts out.Their stance has been supported by peers, who have passed amendments pushing back on the proposals, and by some backbench MPs.It is understood that concessions offered to MPs and peers this week include an economic impact assessment, with a report that could address issues such as how AI developers access data to train their models and transparency around use of copyright-protected works.Ministers are hoping the concessions will allow thethe data (use and access) bill to pass
Italian police increase security at Tesla dealerships after 17 cars destroyed in Rome fire
Italy’s interior ministry has written to police forces across the country to increase security at Tesla dealerships after 17 of the electric cars made by Elon Musk’s company were destroyed in a fire in Rome.Italy’s state police anti-terrorism unit, Digos, is investigating whether the fire at the Tesla dealership in Torre Angela, a suburb in the east of the capital, was started by anarchists.Firefighters worked for hours to put out the blaze in the early hours of Monday. Drone images showed a row of the burnt-out remains of the vehicles in a parking area of the dealership. Using his social media platform, X, Musk referred to it as “terrorism”
Emma Raducanu withdraws from Great Britain squad for BJK Cup qualifiers
Emma Raducanu has pulled out of Great Britain’s squad for next week’s Billie Jean King Cup qualifiers against Germany and the Netherlands.The British No 2 reached the quarter-finals of the Miami Open last week, her deepest run at a WTA 1000 event and best tournament performance since her stunning US Open triumph in 2021.Raducanu has featured at seven tournaments in a busy first three months of the year and it is thought she is planning to take a short break from competitive action, using the next two to three weeks as a training block before returning to action at an as-yet unspecified date.Raducanu’s representatives told BBC Sport that pulling out of the British squad for the matches in The Hague was a “difficult decision,” adding: “She needs a little space in the calendar to best look after her body.” Raducanu took a medical timeout during the second set of her three-set defeat to Jessica Pegula in the Miami quarter-finals
Charlotte Edwards to make England players ‘accountable for their fitness’
Charlotte Edwards has promised to make England’s players “more accountable for their fitness” as she seeks to improve the team’s fortunes after her appointment as women’s head coach.The 45-year-old insisted that despite England women’s recent troubles against Australia they were capable of winning this year’s 50-over World Cup in India, saying she was “really confident we can turn things around very quickly”. Jon Lewis was sacked as coach last month after a miserable winter in which group-stage elimination at the T20 World Cup was followed by a 16-0 rout in the Ashes.Clare Connor, the England and Wales Cricket Board’s managing director of England women, led a “very thorough, comprehensive and honest” review of that series which “told us that we did need a significant reset in terms of leadership and the environment”.The ECB chose to abandon its normal open recruitment process once it became clear that Edwards, who since retiring as a player had enjoyed success as a coach with Hampshire, Mumbai Indians and Sydney Sixers, would accept the job
Gold rises as markets await US tariffs; Heathrow airport was warned about power supply in days before closure – as it happened
You never know what you’re gonna get: Australians will have to wait until after the election to see if there’s an interest rate cut | Greg Jericho
Roblox gives parents more power over children’s activity on gaming platform
UK needs to relax AI laws or risk transatlantic ties, thinktank warns
Lions set to face Japan-based All Blacks in Anzac clash but Folau’s hopes over
Grand National gets taps turned on to ensure safe ground after long dry spell