Better care for mental health patients will hinge on funding | Letters
I read your editorial on the proposed reforms to the Mental Health Act with interest (6 November).The act serves as the balancing point between the state’s negative duty not to interfere with individual liberty without good reason and its positive duties to prevent harm to vulnerable people and the wider public.The criteria for detention represent the threshold at which both of those duties are triggered: detention under the MHA is also a gateway to rights to proactive care and support both during and after detention.We may argue about whether the existing criteria for detention strike the right balance between the state’s positive and negative duties, but it is at least the same balance for everyone.The draft bill sets a much higher threshold for detention unless a person has committed a crime, and while this will lead to fewer people suffering the trauma and indignity of being detained, it will also mean fewer people receiving the positive support and protection of the state – that is unless they commit a crime.
Even leaving aside the unexplored equalities implications of such a perverse incentive, it can surely be neither less restrictive of the individual nor more caring of the state to force people into the criminal justice system in order to receive the help they need.Michael Chalmers Associate director of mental health law, North London NHS foundation trust As a social worker, I couldn’t agree more that the outcome of the proposed reforms to the Mental Health Act will depend on resources.I am employed by an NHS trust to work with people for three years after they experience a first episode of psychosis.If staff in my trust did everything that we are already supposed to, it would be a fantastic place to receive care.We cannot.
There are not enough beds, caseloads are too high, staff retention is too low, advertised posts often remain unoccupied and well-meaning but misguided attempts at system reform create administrative burdens without improving the quality of care.Small pockets of the system receive higher levels of funding.These teams tend to deliver better quality care as a result.The staff are not more skilled, they simply have been given adequate resources.There is no point banning the use of police cells as a place of safety unless additional assessment suites are provided in hospital settings to meet that need.
Staff who are rushed off their feet cannot build the kind of relationships with patients that make family involvement or collaborative care planning meaningful.It is one thing to legislate for higher standards, another to secure the resources to meet those standards.Richard BrahamIlminster, Somerset Your editorial is full of the hope and values that we need to offer positive and effective mental health services to people with serious mental illness, as are the amendments in the bill.So it pains me to call out the naivety of these changes being sought at a time when services are so deteriorated that it takes the horror of the Nottingham attacks to begin the process (NHS England’s review of assertive outreach provision 2024) of recognising the vast hole.If we are to move towards a more humane Mental Health Act, we first need to provide full community provision for the people whose lives are lived in and out of psychiatric wards.
Dr William HallNHS consultant psychiatrist in rehabilitation, Bristol As a parent of adults with severe mental illness, I would like to see easier access to treatment and care,Already, most people with severe illness are left to live, at best, impoverished lives in the “community”,I don’t recognise the narrative of people’s rights being removed by hospital admissions,Already, people’s rights are removed by not having access to good, timely treatment and care, under section if necessary,If the threshold for admission rises even further, I can only see this leading to more misery, deaths and criminalisation.
Name and address supplied The National Autistic Society has campaigned on this for many years now,The Tories pledged to reduce the number of autistic people in mental health wards back in 2015 when they made up 38% of patients,The latest figure is 68% of patients,This is shocking and needs to change,Placing people with autism on such wards is so harmful, due to patients being prescribed medications and being subjected to restraint.
As an autistic adult, it is frightening to think I could be sectioned for a lack of understanding about my behaviour – especially during a meltdown, when I lose control.Nick PrinceWaterhouses, Staffordshire Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Owner of Aberdeen, Southampton and Glasgow airports sold in £1.53bn deal
The owner of Aberdeen, Glasgow and Southampton airports is being sold in a deal worth more than £1.5bn.The Spanish construction company Ferrovial and its partner Macquarie have agreed to offload the AGS Airports joint venture to AviAlliance, a German-headquartered airport operator.As part of the deal, which is expected to complete early next year, AviAlliance will pay £900m for the business and take on £653m in debt.Ferrovial and Macquarie’s 50/50 AGS joint venture was established in 2014 after their £1
Homebase collapses into administration with thousands of jobs at risk
The struggling DIY chain Homebase has collapsed into administration, leaving thousands of workers facing an uncertain future, despite the purchase of the bulk of its stores by the owner of The Range homeware retailer.Gavin Park, Gavin Maher and Adele Macleod from the financial advisory firm Teneo were appointed as joint administrators of Homebase’s owners, HHGL Limited and Hampden Group Limited.The owner of The Range and Wilko, CDS Superstores, has bought 70 of Homebase’s stores, saving up to 1,600 jobs, as well as the brand and intellectual property.The Homebase brand will continue to trade online, while the stores bought by CDS will continue to trade until they are handed over, at which point they will be rebranded as The Range superstores.Homebase had recently completed a sale of 11 of its UK stores to Sainsbury’s, and has exchanged on a further three locations
Cryptocurrency traders: share what got you into crypto, and how you feel about recent developments
It’s been an eventful few days for the cryptocurrency market, with the price of bitcoin having risen above $87,000 for the first time amid traders’ hopes that cryptocurrencies will boom in a favourable regulatory environment when Donald Trump returns to the White House.Bitcoin reached a record high of $87,198, before slipping back slightly on Monday. The price more than doubled from about $37,000 12 months ago.Other cryptos such as Dogecoin also experienced a “Trump pump” surge.We’d like to hear from retail investors who have bought crypto and how they have fared since they entered the market
Genetic testing firm 23andMe cuts 40% of its workforce amid financial struggles
The genetic testing firm 23andMe said on Monday it would cut about 40%, or 200 employees, from its workforce and discontinue further development of all its therapies as part of a restructuring program.“We are taking these difficult but necessary actions as we restructure 23andMe and focus on the long-term success of our core consumer business and research partnerships,” said the company’s CEO, Anne Wojcicki.The company said it was evaluating strategic alternatives, including licensing agreements and asset sales, for its therapies in development.The company has been left with few options as its value has plummeted in the aftermath of a massive data breach. The DNA testing company is being investigated by British and Canadian authorities over the 2023 breach that exposed 6
Sebastian Coe pledges ‘clearcut policy’ on women’s sport in IOC pitch
Sebastian Coe has promised to introduce an “uncompromising and clearcut” policy to protect women’s sport and to look into awarding prize money to all Olympic medallists if he is elected International Olympic Committee (IOC) president.In a clear sign that Coe intends to be the change candidate in next March’s election, the World Athletics president also promised to make the IOC more open and democratic, and to do more to harness the talents of the organisation’s membership.Coe, who ran the London 2012 Games and is a double gold medallist, has the deepest CV of the seven candidates for the biggest job in global sports politics. However no Briton has held the presidency since the IOC was formed in 1894 and his candidacy is opposed by the current leader, Thomas Bach, who he fell out with after World Athletics banned Russian athletes.But in his first major interview since declaring his candidacy, Coe said he would not be a “vanilla” candidate and protecting the integrity of sport would be a key plank of his manifesto
England will not ‘shut up shop’ against South Africa, insists Henry Slade
England are looking to banish their autumn frustrations at South Africa’s expense this Saturday and have vowed “not to shut up shop” against the reigning world champions. Successive defeats by New Zealand and Australia have dropped Steve Borthwick’s side to seventh in the world rankings but the players insist they can confound expectations and turn their month around.Rather than ditching the high-risk defensive system that has so far conceded eight tries in two games this month, England intend to double down and be even more aggressive with and without the ball in their first rematch against the Springboks since last year’s agonising World Cup semi-final defeat.In Paris just over a year ago England adhered to a strictly limited kicking-based gameplan against the Boks which came close to paying spectacular dividends. This time, however, they intend to stick to their recently embraced blitz defensive system and take South Africa on in attack as well
Reeves to announce ‘megafunds’ shake-up of local government pension scheme
Thames Water should explain its murky logic on fundraising
FBI raids home and seizes phone of Polymarket founder
Bitcoin clears $93,000 and Dogecoin soars amid Trump-fueled crypto rally
‘Salads don’t win scrums’: Ox Nché is icing on Springboks’ front-row cake
‘I couldn’t be bullied’: Danny Cipriani joins criticism of Eddie Jones’s style