Record losses and bumper bonuses – the pay row tearing apart English rugby

about 21 hours ago

When the Rugby Football Union published its annual report at the end of November, on the back of a lacklustre autumn campaign for England, it emerged the chief executive, Bill Sweeney, was paid £1.1m for the year ending June 2024, which included a one-off £358,000 bonus as part of a long-term incentive plan (LTIP) scheme.It also emerged five other executive directors shared a bonus of close to £1m while the annual report showed record losses to reserves of £42m.In the ensuing weeks the calls for the chairman, Tom Ilube, and Sweeney to go have grown louder across all levels of the English game.Put simply, because it made Sweeney the best paid chief executive at a British sports governing body – excluding payouts – at a time when the union announced record losses and 42 redundancies.

While the RFU council was well briefed on the losses – expected in a World Cup year – they were given scant warning about the pay hikes.There are those who sympathise with Sweeney insofar as he was offered the terms of the LTIP and understandably accepted it but why it was instigated in the first place has united the game in anger.The RFU’s justification for the scheme is that executives took a pay cut during the pandemic and this is the reward for steering the union through it.That has gone down badly with England players who also took a Covid pay cut while Championship clubs have seen their funding slashed repeatedly.The metrics against which the LTIP has been judged have also caused consternation, not least the decision to combine the results of the men’s and women’s teams when gauging England’s winning percentage.

Sign up to The BreakdownThe latest rugby union news and analysis, plus all the week's action reviewedafter newsletter promotionThe pay scandal – and the manner in which it has been handled – has proved the catalyst for a full-blown rebellion.The 62-strong RFU council can call an emergency meeting and table a vote of no confidence in the board of directors if 20 members agree.The RFU president, Rob Udwin, got wind that was imminent and called an emergency meeting on Wednesday – at which neither Ilube nor Sweeney were present – in an attempt to quell the particular revolt, inviting the former chairman Andy Cosslett to attend and explain the context of the LTIP scheme.Even before that meeting, however, the council had formally requested an emergency meeting on 10 January – at which a vote of no confidence could theoretically be held – to review the RFU’s governance.After Wednesday’s meeting – which lasted more than four hours and was described by one member as “the night of the long knives” – it was determined an independent review into the pay bonuses would be commissioned.

The RFU also finally acknowledged the reputational damage the scandal had done but the writing was on the wall when Udwin summoned Ilube and Sweeney for urgent talks on Thursday.Not least because, in addition to the council’s rebellion, a grassroots campaign to remove Ilube and Sweeney has been taking shape.If 100 of the RFU’s member clubs request a special general meeting (SGM), Sweeney must call it within 45 days and, as of earlier this week, the rebels had comfortably met the numbers.Against that backdrop, Ilube has stepped down because “recent events have become a distraction from the game”.The rebels have one head on a spike but bloodlust for a second remains.

That Sweeney has overseen a series of crises in the three years for which he was so handsomely rewarded has rankled,Worcester, London Irish, Wasps and Jersey went to the wall, Eddie Jones was sacked and the lowering of the tackle height in the amateur game was handled abysmally,More recently, under Steve Borthwick, England have slumped to seventh in the world rankings,Ultimately though, it is the board who decide Sweeney’s fate so whoever replaces Ilube when he eventually departs as chair of it will be key,Bill Beaumont, who held the role between 2012 and 2016 and stepped down as World Rugby chairman in November, is the best possible appointment for Sweeney.

Beaumont is well respected across the game; having taken on the role on an interim basis he is considered a safe pair of hands and someone who may be able to temper some of the outcry with his well-refined snug bar charm.At 72, he hardly screams “new broom”, however, and rebels want complete regime change.As such, an SGM remains a likely proposition.

businessSee all

Reeves may have to U-turn over no more tax rises, warn economists

A dramatic slowdown in economic growth and rising borrowing costs since the budget could undermine the government’s finances and force the chancellor, Rachel Reeves, to U-turn on pledges not to further increase taxes, analysts have said.With inflation on the rise again, the London stock market at its lowest point for more than a month and the Bank of England forecasting economic stagnation in the final three months of 2024, the government heads into the Christmas break weighed down by a gloomy outlook for the new year.The prospect of a trade war with the US after Donald Trump is inaugurated in January has also weighed on markets. In statements on social media on Friday, the president-elect threatened the EU with tariffs on exports to the US, which could be extended to include the UK.City economists said the rise in inflation over the past three months would force the Bank to maintain high interest rates, which would weigh on household spending and dent Reeves’s plans to grow the economy

about 23 hours ago

EU should spare carmakers from ‘punitive’ emissions fines, says Scholz

The EU should refrain from “punitive” fines on carmakers that fail to meet emissions standards, the German chancellor has said, adding to the heated debate on the future of the key European industry.Olaf Scholz, who is running for re-election in February at a time when Germany’s biggest carmaker, Volkswagen, is planning unprecedented plant closures in its home market, made the comments after meeting fellow EU leaders in Brussels.His intervention comes days before the sector faces stricter standards on cutting carbon emissions from their new cars. From 2025 until 2029 the average new car in Europe should emit no more than 93.6 grams of CO2 for each kilometre, to get the industry on track for the phase-out of petrol and diesel vehicles from 2035

1 day ago

Boohoo shareholders vote to block Mike Ashley from joining board

Boohoo shareholders have blocked Mike Ashley and an associate from joining its board in a blow to the Sports Direct founder’s attempt to control the struggling online fashion retailer.Investors representing 64% of Bohoo’s stock voted against appointing Ashley and Mike Lennon at a special meeting on Friday morning called by Ashley’s Frasers Group.The chair of Boohoo, Tim Morris, said shareholders had given “a resounding vote of confidence in our board” at the meeting.He said 99% of those that voted – excluding the 27% stake in Boohoo controlled by Ashley’s Frasers Group – had chosen to block Ashley’s appointment.Morris said Boohoo would now “like to get on with running our business”, although it is not clear how Frasers will respond to the vote

1 day ago

Starbucks workers’ strike could reach hundreds of stores by Christmas Eve

Workers at Starbucks stores in three cities plan to go on strike on Friday after a union representing more than 11,000 baristas in the US said it was making little progress with the giant coffee chain’s owners over pay and conditions.The walkouts will start in Los Angeles, Chicago and Seattle, with strike action set to spread each day and, subject to a deal, reach hundreds of stores by Christmas Eve.The strike comes as workers at the online giant Amazon was also hit by a worker’s walkout.Starbucks Workers United, the union that has organized workers at 535 company-owned US stores since 2021, said Starbucks has failed to honor a pledge to meet to reach an agreement this year.“Union baristas know their value, and they’re not going to accept a proposal that doesn’t treat them as true partners,” said Lynne Fox, president of Workers United

1 day ago

Donald Trump tells EU to buy more US oil and gas or face tariffs

The US president-elect, Donald Trump, has warned the EU that it will face trade tariffs on its exports to the US unless its member states buy more American oil and gas.Trump reignited fears of a looming trade war between the US and the EU in his first public statement regarding trade since he was elected president in November.“I told the European Union that they must make up their tremendous deficit with the United States by the large scale purchase of our oil and gas. Otherwise, it is TARIFFS all the way!!!,” he said in a post on his social media site Truth Social.The US is the world’s largest producer of oil and has also emerged as the biggest supplier of liquefied natural gas (LNG) to the bloc since Russian supplies of pipeline gas to its European customers petered out after the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in early 2022

1 day ago

Lift for Rachel Reeves as UK borrowing hits three-year low

The UK’s debt bill fell last month as government borrowing dropped to just over £11bn, giving Rachel Reeves an early Christmas present after a furious backlash from business leaders to her budget.Official figures showed the interest payable on central government debt was £3bn, much lower than analysts expected and a decrease of £4.7bn from the same month in 2023, to give the lowest November figure since 2019.The Office for National Statistics said borrowing in November was £11.2bn, based on the longstanding measure of public sector net borrowing (PSNB), well below the £13bn City economists had forecast, and the lowest November borrowing in three years

1 day ago

politicsSee all

;