Normal man, not flash Harry: why Brook is the right choice to lead England | Barney Ronay

September202024
A picture


Even a stopped clock tells the right time once a day, or twice depending on how you interpret analogue time devices.In this same encouraging spirit I am happy to report that English cricket has accidentally made a good decision, one that will play out, for better or worse, over the next week.This is something we should all be grateful for, even if it is only temporary, even if it begins to look a bit iffy as early as this weekend and Saturday’s second one-day international against Australia.But it does involve Harry Brook and that is generally a good thing.Frankly, any kind of good thing is worth celebrating as the domestic cricket season retreats towards October, nourished only by autumnal clips of people in jumpers doing end-of-days stuff, village batting, bowling impressions, chilly fingered double-bouncers that people in Australia can laugh at and say: “See, I told you.

”It seems safe to say it now.The summer of 2024 has been the bleakest, most essentially irrelevant English cricket season of the modern age; to the extent it feels like a step change, the moment when this thing really did become obviously beta.There has been a Weekend at Bernie’s air to it all at times.Here comes the English summer again, the corpse by the swimming pool, carted about the place just to keep the show going, feet dragging along the floor, shades falling off its face, Ian Ward and Nick Knight at each elbow, still talking a great game, still offering a cadaverous thumbs-up.Cricket? Cricket’s fine.

Can’t you see its hand waving?The most notable part has been the completely random series of events.Suddenly it’s T20 finals day.Remember when that was good and vital, before it was decided it just couldn’t be any more? Over to you, 50-over Cup, now excitingly rebranded as farmers v teenagers.Before that we have two no-jeopardy Test series against the undercooked teams of economically marginalised nations, the last outing of the summer basically a beer match at the Oval.Again the most notable part is how tedious it feels to restate all this, the sense that even tales of decline no longer have any retail value.

Earlier this week the big county cricket story was Essex being fined £100,000 for decades of aggressive institutional racism,If that seems low, well, here’s the thing,It is probably the limit of what Essex can absorb without actually going bust,Take that in,Here we have a sport so diminished it can’t even afford to pay for its own racism.

And yet there is always life and heat.In the middle of all this England have, almost incidentally, appointed Brook as temporary ODI captain.And while this will change the sum total of zero actual things in the short term, it does also feel, not just fun and intriguing, but salutary, a pointer towards some small part of the bigger picture.Nobody really knows how Brook as captain will work out.His only senior experience is in the Hundred, and before that an Under-19 World Cup where he made a golden duck in the key collapse against Australia and was then dropped for the seventh-place playoff against New Zealand for disciplinary reasons.

So, a start there then.But it is still a good thing, so much so that in my opinion Brook would be much better off just replacing Jos Buttler outright, given Buttler has had a long go at it and just turned out not to be very good.He also hasn’t played a domestic 50-over game since 2016, which is fair enough, we all have to make a living.But while Buttler is both a celebrity and brilliant cricketer, it is probably time for English cricket to value itself a little more and apply some less indulgent standards.Either way, Brook gets to lead England at his home ground, Headingley, on Saturday, and there are so many good things about this.

Most obviously he’s a brilliant player, with an elegance and clarity about his movements that is so immediately striking.Australia will of course pepper him with the short ball next winter, which is likely to be utterly absorbing given his natural aggression.Brook’s talent is all about the purity of the contact between bat and ball, the simplicity of his movements that make him seem still even when he isn’t.He is also totally committed to England, loves it, has turned down the Indian Premier League and Big Bash League already, which should be a factor in the planning of the embattled England franchise.But the main thing about Brook, as we reach the end of a column that really should have started with this point, but there’s just so much stuff to get out of the way, is that he’s a normal person.

Sign up to The SpinSubscribe to our cricket newsletter for our writers' thoughts on the biggest stories and a review of the week’s actionafter newsletter promotionAnd this also matters.Brook is a non-posh, unaffected, non-corporate-speak England captain.Here we have a captain who is likable and everyday, who walks a bit like Liam Gallagher (as all mid-20s northern blokes must at some stage), who, my close sources tell me, came into his first England captain press conference and said: “All right?” then seemed surprised everyone didn’t say: “All right?” back.It should be said the cliche of England cricket captains as born-to-rule Lord Harris types has never been the whole story.The team that reached two losing World Cup finals in 1987 and 1992 were notably state school.

Nasser Hussain was a normal man,Alec Stewart: normal man,Michael Vaughan: normal man (right up to the #justsaying Twitter era),It is the last 20 years that have really crystallised this as the Age of the Jazzers, the Strauss-Cook red-trouser optics, the talk from Giles Clark of an England captain from “the right kind of family”,This is not by chance.

It is instead an accurate reflection of English cricket’s retreat from popular sport to pastime of the privileged, the Waitrose Years when cricket set its price point high on the demand curve, milking the pay-TV pound and making itself, at least in the south, a hidden garden accessible only to those who already know it’s there.Brook’s life has involved obstacles.It has involved breaking into this world.This is not Ollie Pope, the Surrey pathway made flesh.Clarke’s nauseating gush about families seems quite funny in this context.

Famously, Brook’s dad once had to apply to court to get a curfew lifted so he could watch his son play for England Under-19s, the result of a community order for causing criminal damage to a caravan.Giles? Giles! Come back!A new temporary captain will, of course, do nothing in itself to change English cricket’s basic sense of isolation.Brook’s presence in front of a board covered with adverts isn’t going to shift the feeling the summer sport has become a frightening image from a TS Eliot poem, the eyeless corpse clutching your wrist, bones poking through its chest, just really eager to talk about sponsorship and media rights opportunities.But here at least is a person who has come into this world from outside.Someone is going to have to lead England’s Test team when Stokes limps off, to become its public face and its vibe.

Brook hopefully has the staying power to make a case.Score lots of runs.Don’t get clanged by Josh Hazlewood.Help carry this doddery old cadaver forward just a little longer.No pressure then, Harry.

recentSee all
A picture

Labour’s tax red lines have left Reeves with ‘one hand tied’ for budget, says IFS

Rachel Reeves has “one hand tied behind her back” as she considers how to balance the books next month in her first budget, a leading economic thinktank has said, after she ruled out increases to the four main taxes that account for 75% of all revenues.The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said Labour had promised not to raise income tax, national insurance, VAT or corporation tax before the budget, heightening speculation that Reeves will seek to increase revenues from rises in capital gains tax, inheritance tax and stamp duty on property sales.The IFS said there was a danger the chancellor would seek extra revenues from “economically damaging” tax rises that only bring short-term relief to the government’s spending deficit.The IFS said Labour entered office faced with “unenviable arithmetic” given that the previous government had pushed tax revenues to the highest level since the 1940s, while also imposing “big cuts to public investment and some public services”.“Merely avoiding spending cuts would – if debt is to fall – likely require raising tens of billions of additional revenue by 2028-29,” the report said

September202024
A picture

Rupert Murdoch’s REA group ups offer for Rightmove to £5.9bn

The Rupert Murdoch-controlled Australian property group REA has upped its proposed offer for Rightmove, the UK’s biggest online property portal, to £5.9bn.REA, in which Murdoch’s News Corporation has a 61% stake, has sweetened its initial proposal by about £300m after Rightmove’s board last week unanimously rejected the first offer as “fundamentally undervaluing” the company.The initial cash and stock offer, which valued the business at 705p a share – giving Rightmove shareholders 18.6% of the enlarged REA group post-deal, has now been upped to about 750p

September202024
A picture

Labelling Trump’s lies as ‘disputed’ on X makes supporters believe them more, study finds

Labelling tweets featuring false claims about election fraud as “disputed” does little to nothing to change Trump voters’ pre-existing beliefs, and it may make them more likely to believe the lies, according to a new study.The study, authored by John Blanchard, an assistant professor from the University of Minnesota, Duluth, and Catherine Norris, an associate professor from Swarthmore College, looked at data from a sampling of 1,072 Americans surveyed in December of 2020. The researchers published a peer-reviewed paper on their findings this month in the Harvard Kennedy School’s Misinformation Review.“These ‘disputed’ tags are meant to alert a reader to false/misinformation, so it’s shocking to find that they may have the opposite effect,” Norris said.Participants were shown four tweets from Donald Trump that made false claims about election fraud and told to rank them from one to seven based on their truthfulness

September202024
A picture

Social media and online video firms are conducting ‘vast surveillance’ on users, FTC finds

Social media and online video companies are collecting huge troves of your personal information on and off their websites or apps and sharing it with a wide range of third-party entities, a new Federal Trade Commission (FTC) staff report on nine tech companies confirms.The FTC report published on Thursday looked at the data-gathering practices of Facebook, WhatsApp, YouTube, Discord, Reddit, Amazon, Snap, TikTok and Twitter/X between January 2019 and 31 December 2020. The majority of the companies’ business models incentivized tracking how people engaged with their platforms, collecting their personal data and using it to determine what content and ads users see on their feeds, the report states.The FTC’s findings validate years of reporting on the depth and breadth of these companies’ tracking practices and call out the tech firms for “vast surveillance of users”. The agency is recommending Congress pass federal privacy regulations based on what it has documented

September192024
A picture

Ben Spencer inspires Bath’s fast start to get revenge over champions Saints

Bath would have preferred to win last season’s Premiership final but maybe now this is destined to be their time. This bonus-point ­victory over the reigning champions, Northampton, gave an early glimpse of their capabilities and first-half tries from Joe Cokanasiga, Ted Hill and Ben Spencer paved the way for a strong performance that lays down a marker to all their rivals.If it helped that Bath kept 15 players on the field this time, unlike at Twickenham last June, they showed more than enough composure with and without the ball to suggest they will be a tough nut to crack this time around. A near faultless goalkicking display from Finn Russell, who supplied 13 points, was another plus and even an improved second half from Northampton failed to turn the tide.The duel of the two international fly-halves, Russell and Fin Smith, was another fascinating subplot on an opening night which, for the most part, made for an absorbing first-weekend aperitif

September202024
A picture

Charnley helps clinch playoff spot for Leigh with win against St Helens

Momentum heading into a Super League playoff campaign is certainly not the be all and end all: but the reactions of both these sides at the finish of a thrilling night in Leigh underlined how crucial it could be, as well as the different trajectories the Leopards and St Helens are on as the business end of the year begins.This was a night of huge significance for both. Leigh, who were ninth as recently as July, knew only victory here would ensure they guaranteed a spot in the playoffs. In the end, a 10th win from 12 games cemented fifth and a trip to Salford in the opening round next week.But that only tells half the story of a dramatic and compelling evening

September202024