When it comes to Le Crunch, England don’t seem to know what their best XV is | Ugo Monye

A picture


When it comes to team selection, it’s important to remember that everything is subjective,Different coaches, five million different fans and the 80,000 people in the stadium will all have different views, different affiliations and different opinions about who should be playing for England,It plays a large part of every Test week and it’s fantastic because it creates debate, it gets people talking,It is not specific to England either but the problem with Steve Borthwick’s recent team selections is that I just wish it felt like it was coming from a place of understanding exactly what his best team is and precisely how to deliver their best gameplan,I’m not sure we have clarity on either of those things yet and as much as I understand the notion of horses for courses, I would much prefer to have a sense that selection is first and foremost about yourselves rather than the opposition.

In Dublin last weekend, Borthwick picked both Currys in the back row and as effective as it was for the first 50 minutes, as much as it was on task, the way that we out-enthused the opposition, displayed more energy, it was a selection based on negating what the opposition was going to do.This week, it’s a similar story.The back row has changed with Tom Willis coming in to add more weight.I just wish the selections that England make are primarily about themselves first rather than reacting to what the opposition may or may not do and the threats that they have.This England team should always be competitive because we have a lot of depth, but I don’t know what the clarity is in terms of what their best team is and we’ve had a lot of games to at least answer that question.

In the case of France, Ireland, Scotland, South Africa and even New Zealand, even though they’ve had a period of transition of late, you can pick their best team.They can tweak things but the foundation is there and I’m not sure England have that yet but the best teams in any sport know what their best side is when everyone is fit.I think England are about 80% of the way there but in key positions, and fly-half is without doubt one of those, there is uncertainty.Is Marcus Smith considered the best fly-half to take England forward? He was their best player in the autumn and I understand the temptation to move him to full‑back given France kicking longer than anyone else, but again it is the result of thinking about what the opposition is going to do.From full-back we’re going to expect Marcus to counterattack from deep because he is electric one-on-one but that completely changes England’s attacking philosophy from week one to week two.

How does this England side want to set up tactically? I believe I have a fairly good idea.Borthwick has said of late that he wants to be a ball-movement side and I agree to a certain extent but until we get clarity in certain areas we will be a team who reacts to the opponent first and foremost.The knock-on effect is being seen in England’s last-quarter collapses.Borthwick is evidently a good coach, coming up with a gameplan for each match and England are starting positively, on the front foot as a result.They have scored the first try in their last four matches but they are tailing off because their opponents are growing into games and working out ways to counter England’s plan.

In response, England haven’t really had an answer because they can’t really deviate or adapt.Allianz Stadium, 4.45pm GMT, Saturday 8 FebruaryEngland M Smith; Freeman, Lawrence, Slade, Sleightholme; F Smith, Mitchell; Genge, Cowan-Dickie, Stuart, Itoje (capt), Martin, T Curry, Earl, Willis.Replacements: George, Baxter, Heyes, Chessum, Cunningham-South, B Curry, Randall, Daly.France Ramos; Penaud, Barassi, Moefana, Bielle-Biarrey; Jalibert, Dupont (capt); Gros, Mauvaka, Atonio, Roumat, Meafou, Cros, Boudehent, Alldritt.

Replacements: Marchand, Baille, Colombe, Auradou, Guillard, Jegou, Le Garrec, Gailleton,England have got such a wealth of personnel and analysts as well as access to so much live data and the players couldn’t be better prepared for what is coming but there is a trend because all of the defeats in this unwanted run have been by a margin of nine points or fewer,You can bank on France having a conversation about how they can break England in the final 20 minutes on Saturday,Sign up to The BreakdownThe latest rugby union news and analysis, plus all the week's action reviewedafter newsletter promotionA coach can only really change the game through their replacements,I don’t really buy the excuse that England were lacking experience because last weekend was Simon Easterby’s first match in charge of Ireland and his proactive changes swung the game in his side’s favour.

They certainly weren’t panicking in the dressing room at half-time but history shows that Borthwick has a habit of being reactive with his replacements because only once, in all his games in charge of England, has he made a tactical change before the opposition,I understand that there is a reluctance to change a winning formula but there has to be a realisation that the opposition will always respond and that England have to be proactive in order to stay on the front foot,You cannot sit and wait for things to happen,Having said all that, ultimately it was individual errors that cost England against Ireland,They missed crucial one-on-one tackles and that proved fatal.

In this defensive system, they are robust through the middle – one poor misread by Chandler Cunningham-South aside – but that leaves the No 9 and No 10 defending in the wide channels and ultimately that turned out to be a problem in Dublin.Perhaps it was inevitable given how much time Ireland spent in England’s red zone but if they can tighten up n that area they can be competitive on Saturday.We’ve seen that England have not been getting blown away in recent defeats and I don’t expect that they will be against a phenomenal French side.But they have to find a way to adapt in the final quarter if they are to achieve the win they so desperately need.
societySee all
A picture

‘It infuriates me’: why the ‘wages for housework’ movement is still controversial 40 years on

The 1970s campaign aimed to smash capitalism by recognising the value of childcare and chores. A new book looks back on how it fell apart – and how it’s relevant today Emily Callaci is at home in Wisconsin, surrounded by the usual debris of family life. The bed behind her is unmade, she confesses, and there’s “a bunch of marbles and blocks on the floor” left by her sons, now seven and three. But on Zoom she has blurred her background so none of this is visible on screen, just as here, on the other side of the Atlantic, I’ve angled my laptop camera away from the mess on my kitchen worktop. We’ve both automatically hidden the domestic for the sake of looking professional, ironically given this interview is about making unseen, unpaid labour in the home visible

A picture

Calls for UK government to tackle alcohol-related deaths in older people

Health experts are demanding tough action to tackle the record number of older people dying because of heavy drinking, amid a historic shift away from alcohol by younger generations.The UK is undergoing a major generational shift in its drinking habits, with many over-55s consuming dangerous amounts at the same time as under-35s embrace teetotal lifestyles.Many older people who began drinking more heavily when Covid struck in 2020 have continued doing so, while those under 55 have reverted to pre-pandemic consumption levels.Britain’s relationship with alcohol is back in the spotlight after the Office for National Statistics (ONS) revealed on Thursday that alcohol-related deaths had hit a record high of 10,473 in 2023.However, alcohol experts claim the real death toll is three times higher, once deaths from diseases closely associated with drinking, including heart disease and many cancers, are included

A picture

Anger as council prioritises London hotel view over playground plan

Parents at a central London primary school say they feel let down and angry after local planning officers advised against a new playground, in part because it would “harm the view” of a nearby five-star hotel.St Peter’s school in Belgravia has only a small, 170 sq metre strip of play space for 200 pupils, and sits minutes from Victoria station in one of the densest corners of London.Rebecca Bryant has led a two-year process to build the playground, resulting in a design that would incorporate part of the road outside and close it to through traffic. The road is quiet, with busy traffic passing by at both ends but not cutting through, according to some parents, who said that even during rush-hour and school dropoff hardly any cars drove up the road. The children desperately needed the playground as many lived in flats, Bryant said

A picture

Watchdog to investigate two former figures at bankrupt Woking council

Two former senior figures at bankrupt Woking council are to be investigated by the UK’s accounting watchdog after it racked up more than £2bn in debt on a failed investment spree.The Surrey council declared itself effectively bankrupt in 2023 after ploughing vast sums of borrowed money into skyscrapers, a luxury hotel and other risky commercial investments, in what was one of the biggest financial failures in local government history.Sources said an investigation into the individuals involved in the former Conservative-run council’s investment activities was being prepared by the Financial Reporting Council (FRC), the independent regulator that oversees the UK accountancy profession.The watchdog is expected not to name the individuals, and will only refer to two former accountants. However, the Guardian understands the people are Woking’s former chief executive Ray Morgan and ex-finance director Leigh Clarke

A picture

Delay to ‘Awaab’s law’ risks lives of social housing tenants in England, Shelter says

The housing charity Shelter has criticised the government for putting lives at risk by delaying a law to make social landlords in England fix dangerous hazards quickly.Angela Rayner, the housing secretary, and Matthew Pennycook, her housing minister, announced on Thursday they were giving landlords in the social rented sector until 2027 before they have to start fixing all dangerous hazards within a set timeframe.The law, known as Awaab’s law, is designed to prevent a repeat of the events of 2020, when two-year-old Awaab Ishak was killed by mould in a social housing flat in Rochdale.Announcing the bill’s implementation, Rayner said: “We have a moral duty to ensure tragedies like the death of Awaab Ishak never happen again. Landlords cannot be allowed to rent out dangerous homes and shamelessly put the lives of their tenants at risk

A picture

Labour MPs criticise Kim Leadbeater over posts on assisted dying evidence

Four Labour MPs have sent a mass email to colleagues with a stinging rebuke of the assisted dying bill’s sponsor, accusing her of portraying a one-sided view of expert evidence.In a significant escalation of the “red-on-red” dispute over the legislation, the MPs emailed all their Labour colleagues with a lengthy critique of Kim Leadbeater’s social media posts in which she highlighted key moments of evidence given to the committee scrutinising the bill.In the email, seen by the Guardian, the MPs said the committee’s evidence was “weighted towards voices that were known to be supportive of the bill” and criticised the lack of expert witnesses on several subjects, including coercive control.It was signed by the Treasury select committee chair, Meg Hillier, and her fellow MPs Antonia Bance, James Frith and Jess Asato, all of whom voted against the bill in November.It came as pro-assisted dying MPs from across the house privately raised concerns about the number of colleagues reconsidering their support amid growing splits on the committee