Steve Borthwick may focus on results but England fans want to see an identity

Steve Borthwick may focus on results but England fans want to see an identity | Gerard Meagher

about 17 hours ago

About an hour after the final whistle on Saturday, England’s victorious players still swigging from the Calcutta Cup, Steve Borthwick was deep inside Twickenham discussing how his players finally got their hands back on the trophy.He was justifying their route-one tactics, explaining why England showcased so little with ball in hand; essentially, why they seemed to revert to a tactical approach that wins matches but few admirers.Borthwick was asked a perfectly reasonable question – was it the coaches’ decision to do so or the players adapting on the hoof in response to Scotland’s gameplan? – and he did not answer it properly.He was bristling, looking for hidden meaning in the question that just wasn’t there.He was asked it again and once more failed to provide an answer.

Make no mistake, Borthwick cares a great deal about how his team are perceived.The boos sting, the derogatory implications of “Borthball” bother him.About an hour and a half earlier, the old stadium was groaning again.The Twickenham faithful can be notoriously hard to please – it costs a pretty penny to be there, after all – and as Alex Mitchell and Fin Smith hoisted the ball to the skies, boos and jeers rang out.Borthwick must feel as if he cannot win at times.

There was no such booing two weeks earlier during another one-point victory, against France, yet the post-match statistics tell you Smith made more passes against Scotland than he did two weeks earlier.Statistics can always be manipulated and by most metrics England were significantly less effective in attack against Scotland than they were against France.Just 79 carries for 474 metres on Saturday compared with 95 for 700m against Les Bleus, two line‑breaks compared with eight a fortnight previous and – of course – one try that arguably should not have been awarded, compared with four scored against France.Which brings us back to the question Borthwick wouldn’t answer.Was it the intention to kick possession away from the outset, was it the coaches who decided to do so as the match was going on, or was it the players? “Under those circumstances where you spend a week prepping for something and scrapping to be in it at half‑time, then come in and have the messages change, it was good,” the prop Will Stuart said, hinting at the answer.

The closest Borthwick came to answering was to justify the approach rather than explain how it came about,“I’ve been very clear that I want the team to play with ball in hand, to attack with it, to be brave, aggressive with the ball, there is another team trying to stop you and they’re pretty good at it,” the head coach said,“Ultimately they’re strong in defence, strong at the breakdown, and take the game to this kicking game,That leads to slow ball, and effectively they’re waiting for you to run the ball against their high double tackles, and then attack the breakdown,You’ve got to be very good and very judicious about when you go, and I thought the players did it well.

It’s not necessarily how we want to play, but there were two teams out there and we found a way to win.”It may not be pretty, but this has to be deemed a degree of progress.England have been accused regularly of lacking a plan B over the past 12 months, so successfully adapting to their opponents is a step forward.They have also been accused of defensive frailties and, while Scotland enjoyed plenty of joy out wide – Duhan van der Merwe running riot down the left in the first half – England’s scrambling was again impressive on Saturday.They made 187 tackles and it was their determination to work for each other that had Borthwick most pleased.

“I’d point out how hard the team run for each other, which is definitely something that’s developed,” he said.“I am a believer that you get back what you put in.I’m a believer that if you keep trying to do the right things, if you keep working hard you will get rewarded.It’s the way I was brought up, it’s the way I believe in.So that’s what we will continue to do.

That’s part of my roots, part of my make-up.I’ve always believed in it.If you put in the hard work, you’ll get the reward.”Sign up to The BreakdownThe latest rugby union news and analysis, plus all the week's action reviewedafter newsletter promotionEvidently, it is an area of the game the players relish.Listen to Ben Curry, who came on after 36 minutes and made a significant impact.

“My personal view on defence is that it’s got to mean more than just tackling,” he said.“You’ve got to want to hit people.It’s an unnatural thing to put yourself in a dark place where it shouldn’t be.You’ve got to have a deeper reason to do that, especially in our defence.“We want to try and tackle in twos – so it requires you to be on the same page as your mates.

You don’t want to go in half-heartedly because you know your mate’s going in 100%, it’s like guilt.You know he’s flying in, I’m not going to let him down.”That togetherness is, at present, the foundation of this England side but maybe what riles supporters is that they still do not know the team’s identity.Are they a side who, as Borthwick promises, want to be brave and attack with ball in hand? Are they a team who grind out results? Ultimately, fans are crying out for England to impose their gameplan emphatically on their opponents rather than hang in the fight and squeeze over the line and – though it seems unfair after two hard‑fought, overdue victories – they are growing impatient waiting for it.

technologySee all

Don’t gift our work to AI billionaires: Mark Haddon, Michael Rosen and other creatives urge government

Original British art and creative skill is in peril thanks to the rise of AI and the government’s plans to loosen copyright rules, some of the UK’s leading cultural figures have said.More than 2,000 people, including leading creative names such as Mark Haddon, Axel Scheffler, Benji Davies and Michael Rosen, have signed a letter published in the Observer today calling on the government to keep the legal safeguards that offer artists and writers the prospect of a sustainable income.The urgent plea, highlighting the impact on books, comes after stars including Sir Elton John, Joan Armatrading and Simon Cowell sounded the alarm about the effect on the music industry of the impending copyright exemption. John predicted the proposal “would devastate our creative community”, while helping “powerful foreign technology companies”.The letter specifically targets a clause of the government’s upcoming AI Opportunity Action Plan, which argues that an end to copyright restrictions and intellectual property law is needed to allow greater data-mining of artwork and writing

1 day ago

Crypto and big tech’s backing pays off as Trump makes tech-friendly moves

The millions that US tech companies invested in currying favor with Donald Trump seemed to pay off this week as the new administration issued a flurry of directives that relaxed regulations and dropped lawsuits previously aimed at holding the industry to account. Crypto, AI and social media companies, many of which made donations to Trump, are all expecting to benefit.At the center of the administration’s moves is Elon Musk, the world’s richest man. Over the past week, federal agencies under the president’s authority dropped legal fights against his rocket company and the US’s biggest cryptocurrency exchange. The White House also issued a “deregulatory initiative” aimed at loosening tech-sector regulation by empowering Musk’s Doge

2 days ago

Elton John calls for UK copyright rules rethink to protect creators from AI

Sir Elton John has called on the government to rethink proposals involving the relaxation of copyright rules in the hope of protecting creative talent from AI.The singer and songwriter is among a growing list of public figures to express concerns about plans that would allow tech firms to use online material, including creative work, for AI without permission.Under current government proposals, creators would need to opt out of their work being used, however some of the campaign’s advocates, including Simon Cowell and the author Kate Mosse, have called for an opt-in system to be put in place.“We only achieved that success with the backing of our longstanding copyright protection – the world’s gold standard,” John told the Daily Mail, while highlighting the industry’s impact on creating jobs and economic growth.“The music community has always been quick to adopt new technologies … but adoption of this copyright exception would destroy the UK’s leadership that has been hard won, and what’s worse, it would give it all away

2 days ago

How to navigate apps, from checking safety to remembering passwords

With more and more organisations asking you to download an app to access the best deals, or even use their services at all, you may be wondering how to deal with the technical side of all of this technology. Fear not, our consumer technology editor, Samuel Gibbs, has some tips.Delete unused apps and games.Move photos and videos to iCloud, Google Photos or similar.Clear out your WhatsApp photos, videos and gifs

2 days ago

How poignant to see loved ones frozen in time on Google Street View | Letters

All the overwhelming opposing emotions that Adrian Chiles went through happened to me too when I casually looked at our street on Google Maps (My dad died a year ago – and a photo of him on Google Street View brought me up short, 19 February). There was the palliative care nurse at our front door waiting to be let in, standing by our small red car. My husband had terminal cancer and this amazing nurse was incredibly supportive to all of us. The car was his little runaround while he was still able to drive. The picture must have been taken in 2017, not long before he died

3 days ago

Quantum computing is already here, sort of | Brief letters

Your article (Microsoft unveils chip it says could bring quantum computing within years, 19 February) said that this new class of computers, unlike current machines, will be “based on quantum mechanics rather than classical physics”. While the Babbage machines might be described as using classical physics, I firmly believe there are elements of quantum physics involved in the tablet on which I am writing this.Prof Stephen HollowayLiverpool Even better than Clare Finney’s suggestions (‘The classiest gift I’ve heard of’: what to bring to a dinner party (that isn’t wine or chocolates), 19 February), I think, is to arrange for flowers to be delivered two days earlier so the host has time to arrange them before the day of the dinner party. Arriving with a bunch clutched in your hot little hand and giving the host yet another task is not classy at all.Heather ParryWatford, Hertfordshire It isn’t going to bed that is the problem, Emma Beddington (Why is it so hard to go to bed? Maybe science has the answer, 16 February), but getting up in the mornings – any ideas?Carolyn MartinMawnan Smith, Cornwall Given that the KGB ceased to exist in 1991, it is a testament to its resourcefulness that one of its agents targeted a Tory MP in 2022 (Report, 20 February)

3 days ago

societySee all

;