Australia to ban under-16s from social media – but can’t say how TikTok, Instagram and others will enforce it

A picture


The Australian government has pledged to legislate an age limit of 16 years for social media access, with penalties for online platforms that do not comply.But the Labor government has not spelled out how it expects Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and others to actually enforce that age limit.Anthony Albanese is facing pressure from the Coalition opposition to rush the bill through parliament in the next three weeks, although a federal trial into age assurance technology has not yet commenced.Albanese and the communications minister, Michelle Rowland, did not rule out the potential for social media users to have their faces subject to biometric scanning, for online platforms to verify users’ ages using a government database, or for all social media users – regardless of age – being subject to age checks, only saying it would be up to tech companies to set their own processes.The prime minister confirmed the age limit at a press conference on Thursday, in the latest step of the government’s increasing scrutiny on major tech platforms, with plans to introduce legislation into parliament this month.

His government had announced its plan to legislate an age limit but had been deliberating on where to set that threshold, with expectations it would be between 14 and 16.But questions have been raised, and remain unanswered, about how it could be effectively enforced.The onus would be on social media platforms to “demonstrate they are taking reasonable steps to prevent access” for young people, Albanese said.There would be no penalties for users who managed to access social media under the age of 16, or their parents, but Rowland said there would be penalties for platforms that did not heed the new laws.Sign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news email“The eSafety commissioner will have responsibility for enforcement and there needs to be enhanced penalties to ensure compliance,” she said, saying current penalties below $1m in existing legislation were not sufficient.

Albanese raised concern about the effect of social media on young people, including the potential for content related to misogyny or body image, as his reasoning for the new laws.He said he had spoken to “thousands” of parents and other adults about the issue.“They, like me, are worried sick about the safety of our kids online,” he said.“I want Australian parents and families to know that government has your back.I want parents to be able to say, ‘Sorry, mate, that’s against the law.

’”Rowland said platforms would “need to take reasonable steps” to assure themselves of a user’s age.The government is still conducting a trial, funded in the May budget, of potential age-assurance technology options.The UK, which has implemented age-assurance legislation, outlined potential options including allowing banks or mobile providers to confirm a user is over 18, credit checks, use of facial estimation technology and asking users to upload a photo to the site that is then matched with photo ID.Advice provided to the Australian government stated “no countries have implemented an age verification mandate without issue”.A roadmap for age verification, released last year by the eSafety commissioner – to be tasked with enforcing the new age limit – recommended a “double-blind tokenised approach” where a third-party provider would transfer information between sites and age-assurance providers to protect user privacy.

The roadmap found the age-assurance market was “immature but developing”.The shadow communications minister, David Coleman, said the issue was “urgent” and called for the bill to be rushed through by the end of November – even before the age assurance trial reports on what options exist to enforce that law.The government has not put a timeline on when it wants the bill passed, but has not ruled out legislating before the trial gives its findings.Albanese and Rowland did not answer directly when asked if Australians should prepare for having their faces scanned or their identity documents verified to access social media.Sign up to Breaking News AustraliaGet the most important news as it breaksafter newsletter promotionRowland said such questions would be answered by the age-assurance trial but added: “These platforms know their users better than anyone.

”Albanese cited the example of some young people managing to access alcohol, despite an age limit of 18, in conceding that the laws would not stop all social media access.“What we are wanting to state upfront, from the very beginning, is we don’t pretend that you can get a 100% outcome here,” he said.“We don’t argue that the changes that we will be legislating will fix everything immediately … But those laws set what the parameters are for our society and they assist in ensuring the right outcomes.”Asked if all social media users, regardless of age, would need to verify they were over 18, Rowland said that would be up to the tech companies.The parent company of Facebook and Instagram, Meta, said it would comply with the legislation if required, but questioned whether the technology was ready.

“The idea that somehow you can sort of force the industry to be in a technological place that it isn’t, is probably a bit misunderstood in terms of where the industry is,” Meta’s global head of safety, Antigone Davis, told reporters on Thursday.Meta has argued that app stores such as those run by Apple and Google should bear the burden of enforcement, pointing out teens can use up to 40 different apps which would all require age checks.Davis said requiring age assurance for each app would be complicated, time-consuming and presented a privacy risk.“The current state of age-assurance technology … requires a level of personally identified information to be shared,” she said.“It’s usually in the form of an ID or document ID, documentation or biometric type data, facial feature data for young people, and if it’s parental consent, the data that will be involved there to verify the parent is just another additional layer of data to establish.

”Snapchat and Google were also approached for comment.TikTok declined to comment.
businessSee all
A picture

AstraZeneca says it takes China investigation ‘very seriously’

AstraZeneca’s chief executive has said it is taking investigations by Chinese authorities into its business in the country “very seriously” and insisted it is committed to China in the long run.Authorities are thought to be investigating the importation of two cancer treatments manufactured by Britain’s biggest pharmaceutical company into China.Pascal Soriot, the AstraZeneca chief executive, said: “We take the matters in China very seriously. If requested, we will fully cooperate with the authorities.”Soriot, Britain’s best-paid boss of a FTSE 100 company, who is in line for an £18

A picture

UK jobs market cools as businesses warn over budget hit to hiring and prices

The UK’s jobs market has shown further signs of cooling after a rise in unemployment in September while pay growth slowed, as business leaders said the budget could hit hiring demand and lead to higher prices.Figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS) show the rate of unemployment rose to 4.3% in the three months to September, up from 4% the previous quarter, amid broader signs of a slowdown in the jobs market.While the ONS said its jobs market figures should be treated with caution amid data collection issues, separate figures showed the number of employees on company payrolls fell by 9,000 over the quarter and vacancies fell for a 28th consecutive month to the lowest level since May 2021.The government has come under pressure from businesses after outlining tax increases in the budget, including a rise in the national minimum wage and employer national insurance contributions (NICs) that bosses have said could lead to job cuts

A picture

‘We need to show what we’re trying to do is worth it’: voice of the UK energy industry steps down

After five years making Energy UK ‘noisier’ on green issues, Emma Pinchbeck has been picked to lead the UK’s fight against global heating‘I was a risk when they hired me,” smiles Emma Pinchbeck. The chief executive of Energy UK, the voice of the industry, is hours away from a black-tie awards event that will serve as her unofficial leaving do. After almost five years in the role, she will join the government’s climate watchdog, the Climate Change Committee, in a matter of days.“It’s pretty funny to remind people of this now, but I was an untested risk. I don’t think back in 2019 if you’d said to the energy industry, ‘who would you want as a spokesperson for the sector in a time of crisis?’ that they’d necessarily have chosen someone like me

A picture

Shoppers bemoan UK taramasalata shortage as strike leads to dip in supply

When some UK supermarkets removed the lids from tubs of hummus, there were complaints from shoppers. But for many, the latest dip problem is arguably worse – a nationwide shortage of taramasalata.Industrial action at Bakkavor, a large supplier of the fish roe dip, has caused a “short disruption” to the supply and availability of taramasalata at supermarkets across the country.Employees at Bakkavor’s Spalding site in the Midlands launched strike action about six weeks ago over pay.Tubs of own-brand taramasalata were out of stock online at Waitrose, Sainbury’s and Tesco, the UK’s largest grocer

A picture

Metro Bank fined nearly £17m for failure to monitor potential money laundering

Metro Bank has been fined nearly £17m by the UK’s financial watchdog for failings in its money-laundering controls over four years, in a fresh blow to the lender a year on from its near-collapse.In a surprise announcement that also triggered the early release of Metro’s third-quarter results on Tuesday morning, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said it had found shortfalls in the bank’s financial crime checks between 2016 and 2020.The FCA said that while Metro started automating the monitoring of customer transactions for potential financial crime in 2016, the system did not work as intended. It found that any transactions which took place on the day a new account was opened, or until the account record was updated, were able to pass through the system unchecked.Junior staff raised the alarm in 2017 and 2018, but Metro failed to identify and fix the problem until July 2019

A picture

Signs of cooling UK jobs market could be a headache for Reeves

For the past few years only cursory attention has been paid to the UK unemployment figures because the jobless rate has been low and there have been plenty of unfilled vacancies for those seeking work. But, thanks to a slowing economy and decisions made by Rachel Reeves in last month’s budget, that could be about to change.For the next few months, every release on the state of the labour market will be scrutinised to see what impact two announcements made by Reeves last month are having on jobs.Inevitably, the chancellor’s decision to increase the national minimum wage by 6.7% and increase employer national insurance contributions will have some effect but it will take months to assess how big those effects will be