Remember the global financial crisis? Well, high-risk securities are back
When Margot Robbie made a surprise cameo in the 2015 film adaptation of Michael Lewis’s book The Big Short, she did more to educate the general population about the risks of securitisation than most financial experts.The Australian actor’s brief monologue, notoriously delivered from a champagne bubble bath, explained how banks were bundling up their growing cache of risky sub-prime mortgages into investable bonds, before slicing them up and selling them off for profit.But the proliferation of these mortgage-backed securities in the early 2000s meant there was a catastrophic ripple effect across the global financial system when borrowers started to default on their home loans.The resulting crisis in 2008 triggered a crackdown by regulators.They introduced new rules that could help ensure that asset-backed securities – once allegedly referred to as “crack cocaine of the financial services industry” by the billionaire Guy Hands – would never again spark such a massive meltdown.
But, 16 years later, some experts believe new risks are emerging,And this time, they are linked to highly indebted companies backed by private equity firms, which are part of the growing but opaque portion of the financial system known as the shadow banking sector,Shadow banking refers to financial firms that face little to no regulation compared with traditional lenders, and includes businesses such as hedge funds, private credit and private equity funds,While the use of securitisation dipped in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis, as a result of a tarnished reputation and regulatory backlash, its popularity has subsequently risen,Today, the global securitisation market covers about £4.
7tn of assets, according to estimates by analysts at RBC Capital.The UK accounts for about £300bn of that total, but more than half – about £180bn – is part of the so-called public securitisation market.In this public market, bundled loans are rated by credit rating agencies and sold on to a broad range of investors, and their terms, structure and sales are openly disclosed.These are the routes typically taken by traditional banks, which face far more stringent regulation.The remaining £120bn is made up of securitised loans bundled up by the shadow banking sector.
Private securities are sold directly to a limited pool of sophisticated investors.They are less regulated, need not be reviewed by ratings agencies, and are far more opaque.Some believe that the growth of the private market, and its lack of transparency, could pose a problem.“It probably is an under-appreciated risk, given the lack of regulation in that space and the complexities of the instruments that are being held there,” Benjamin Toms, an analyst at RBC Capital, said.But even the public securities market warrants close review, according to Natacha Postel-Vinay, an assistant professor at the London School of Economics and expert in regulation and financial history.
That includes risks related to collateralised loan obligations (CLOs),These are types of securities that are backed by a pool of debt, including loans to companies with low credit ratings, or struggling businesses that have been snapped up by private equity firms with the help of big loans, in what are known as leveraged buyouts,“The private equity firms invest in companies that are almost failing, and in order to make these companies survive, they load them up with debt,” said Postel-Vinay,“These loans end up being repackaged as well, a little bit like the junk mortgages before the 2008 crisis,”Sign up to ObservedAnalysis and opinion on the week's news and culture brought to you by the best Observer writers after newsletter promotionAnd although CLOs are usually made up of different kinds of loans to businesses in a variety of sectors, this does not entirely eradicate risk.
“It’s a game of whack-a-mole.You regulate stuff, but then the financial system finds ways around the regulation very quickly,” Postel-Vinay said.The Bank of England is in the midst of compiling the results of its first stress test involving the shadow banking sector, the results of which are expected to be released at the end of next week.Although it will not focus directly on securitisation, the Bank has not been shy in flagging its concerns.It warned last December that, while UK banks were partly shielded from losses on CLOs by generally holding the highest-quality slices of the securities, the UK financial system was indirectly at risk through its connection to foreign banks and insurers that have a high and growing exposure to the loans held by already highly indebted companies.
And in June, the financial policy committee highlighted risks related to the private equity industry more broadly: “Vulnerabilities from high leverage, opacity around valuations, variable risk management practices and strong interconnections with riskier credit markets mean the sector has the potential to generate losses for banks and institutional investors,”Postel-Vinay said it was important to determine who should be held responsible before things go wrong,“We want to make sure that we don’t repeat the mistakes [of the 2000s] and that it’s super, super clear who is responsible for the underlying credit risk in these loans,“There are underlying loans that need to be repaid, and they need to be screened, and they need to be monitored … And in these cases, I have to say, there is a lack of transparency,I think a lot of people don’t know exactly what’s going on.
”
Retailers prepare for cautious Christmas as a chill settles on consumers
Shoppers may be preparing to swoop for Black Friday bargains this week, but retailers are expecting a “cautious Christmas”, with households concerned about high energy and housing costs, as well as the potential impact of the recent budget.Trade has been slow in the run-up to the US-inspired promotional spree, which is a week later than last year, as shoppers held off buying presents in the hope they can snap up a bargain.Figures from the e-commerce trade body IMRG, which tracks the performance of more than 200 retailers who trade online, indicate that sales continued to fall this month after a disappointing October – down 11.7% for the week from 10 November, the worst weekly performance of the year so far.Andy Mulcahy, insight director at IMRG, says the latest figures mean online sales are down 2
Passwords are giving way to better security methods – until those are hacked too, that is
We humans are simply too dumb to use passwords. A recent study from password manager NordPass found that “secret” was the most commonly used password in 2024. That was followed by “123456” and “password”. So let’s all give praise that the password is dying.Yes, we know that we should be using 20-letter passwords with weird symbols and numbers, but our minds can’t cope
‘We live in a climate of fear’: graphic novelist’s Elon Musk book can’t find UK or US publisher
A biography by a British graphic novelist of Elon Musk is struggling to find an English-language publisher due to feared “legal consequences”.Elon Musk: Investigation into a New Master of the World is the latest graphic novel by Darryl Cunningham, from West Yorkshire. Cunningham, 64, has written and illustrated seven nonfiction books on topics ranging from the 2008 global economic meltdown (Supercrash), to Russian leader Vladimir Putin (subtitled The Rise of a Dictator).His first book, Psychiatric Tales, which drew on his time working on an acute psychiatric ward, was called an “unsettling but rewarding experience” in an Observer review in 2010.Although his previous books have all found publishers in the UK and America, there has been silence on the Elon Musk project, despite the fact that it has already been translated into French and published in France to positive reviews
I’ve joined Bluesky and it feels like a breath of fresh air – in some ways… | John Naughton
As I write, there’s a window on my laptop screen that is providing a live view of a stampede. It’s logging the numbers of people joining the social network Bluesky. At the moment, the number of registered users is 20.5 million. By the time you read this there will be more than 30 million of them, judging by the rate that people are currently joining
Kohli and Jaiswal put ruthless India on verge of crushing victory over Australia
Cricket probably doesn’t owe Virat Kohli anything. It has given him riches beyond imagination, influence beyond reason, recognition that has built into idolatry. But then, he has given cricket riches, both in the literal cash churned from his name and the intangible of what his story has added to the game. So if the game owed him anything, perhaps it was a lucky break, one generous chance at a century to ease the tension of a lean 18 months without one. Walking out with India two wickets down, 321 runs ahead, with Yashasvi Jaiswal immaculately set on 141 and Australia already wheezing, the game delivered one
Australia v India: first men’s Test, day three – as it happened
Here’s Geoff’s report from Perth:Australia has suffered an extraordinary day of punishment with bat and ball in Perth are now on the brink of a heavy and humiliating defeat.Despite being without several of their key stars, India have been superb, recovering from their early skittling for 150 in the first innings on day one to dominate every session of the Test thereafter. Australia briefly revived after lunch to pinch four wickets but that was as good as it got for them.India’s dominant display was led by a magnificent 161 by Yashasvi Jaiswal and a return to form for Virat Kohli who was unbeaten on 100. Wonderful support innings from KL Rahul (77), Devdutt Padikkal (25), Washington Sundar (25) and Nitish Kumar Reddy (38) took them to 487 for 6 – a record total against Australia in Australia
How to make pecan pie – recipe | Felicity Cloake's Masterclass
KFC drops pledge to stop using ‘Frankenchickens’ in the UK
Cocktails, kebabs and instant gravy – what 10 top chefs really eat in a day
Dua Lipa’s pickle drink is latest twist in growing appreciation for ‘dirty’ cocktails
How to use old cornflakes to make fried chicken – recipe | Waste not
Ravneet Gill’s recipe for quince and hazelnut tart | The sweet spot