Fraud trial of Forbes ‘30 Under 30’ honoree set to lift lid on startup culture

A picture


Charlie Javice has joined an undesirable club struck by the “Forbes 30 Under 30 curse”, a term for the high-flyers identified by the business title as up-and-comers who ended up in legal trouble.The entrepreneur has joined a list that includes the pharmaceuticals fraudster Martin Shkreli and FTX’s Sam Bankman-Fried and Caroline Ellison.The strength of the Forbes “curse” will be tested this week in New York as Javice, 31, goes on trial on four counts of fraud relating to the $175m (£141m) sale of Frank, a student financial aid application assistance company she founded aged 24, to JP Morgan Chase.The deal quickly soured, and has descended into a legal wrangle that has been compared to the case of Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes.Frank’s premise was simple – to help steer students through the complexity of applying for student loans.

In 2021, four years after the New Yorker started the business, she sold up to JP Morgan,She was installed as JP Morgan’s head of student solutions, was paid a $300,000 annual salary and pocketed $21m in stock proceeds, and was awarded a $20m retention bonus,Just over a year later, the banking company sued her, claiming that the database of users reported by Frank was largely a fabrication,In 2023, federal prosecutors filed criminal charges accusing Javice of repeatedly making up claims that Frank had lined up 4,25 million student customers, when in fact she had data for only about 300,000, to “fraudulently induce” the bank to buy the company.

The government contends that Javice had first asked Frank’s director of engineering to create an artificially generated, or synthetic, dataset of the company’s users,When the director questioned the legality of the request, her co-defendant Olivier Amar said: “Yes, it’s legal,We don’t want to end up in orange jumpsuits,”According to the indictment, JP Morgan discovered the alleged fraud after receiving only a few responses when it emailed out new customer marketing materials to Frank’s list of names,After Javice was fired she sued JP Morgan for legal expenses related to an internal investigation and for letting her go soon before she was eligible for the $20m retention bonus.

Jamie Dimon, the JP Morgan chief executive and one of the world’s most powerful bankers, later described the acquisition of the financial wellness platform as a “huge mistake”.In early 2023, JP Morgan shut Frank down.The criminal case now coming before a jury carries echoes of the prosecution of Holmes, whose Silicon Valley startup claimed to perform hundreds of blood tests using a pinprick of blood.Holmes is serving an 11-year prison sentence for defrauding investors.Javice’s case is also reminiscent of the failed prosecution of the British tech tycoon Mike Lynch – who died along with his daughter Hannah and four other passengers, in a tragic boating accident last summer – on fraud charges in connection with the $11.

1bn acquisition of Autonomy by Hewlett-Packard in 2011.HP is continuing the lawsuit against Lynch’s estate.In all three cases, competing claims of fraud and buyers’ remorse run alongside civil and criminal actions.But last week, the US district trial judge, Alvin Hellerstein, ruled that prosecutors could not introduce a pair of WhatsApp messages between Javice and Amar, in which Javice described Holmes’s defrauded investors as “sophisticated assholes”, and that “investors should be blamed”.“Investors should be blamed on letting a 19-year-old go rogue,” Javice commiserated with Amar in the messages, referring to Holmes.

Juda Engelmayer, a spokesperson for Javice, said the only similarities with Holmes are that both are “young, good-looking and savvy, and that’s the only comparison”,“This is a case of due diligence,JP Morgan knew what they were getting into and buyer’s remorse once they got into it,There was no misrepresentation because there’s a difference between people who passed through the website and people who actually signed on to the website to get information,Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotion“JP Morgan was interested in this [Frank] because it got them in touch with the younger generation that they could tap into for financial planning.

They weren’t going into [it] for altruistic reasons to help young people get student loans,” Engelmayer added.According to the governance expert Charles Elson, JP Morgan had a due diligence obligation to look before leaping into the deal.“Either they did their due diligence and the truth was hidden from them, or they may have done their due diligence, and were given full access to the open and honest books but interpreted the results wrong,” he said.At a pretrial hearing, prosecutors revealed that Amar plans to testify against Javice at trial and will argue that she “concealed information and deceived him”.According to prosecutors, Javice contends that this turns Amar into a “second prosecutor”, and requested that the trials be separated.

Javice’s attorneys have also petitioned against a pause in a separate Securities and Exchange Commission’s civil lawsuit, claiming that a delay deprives her of “exculpatory evidence”.Outside the legal framework, the trial may provide, as the FTX case did, further insights into the go-go nature of tech entrepreneurship which had emerged when the business was founded.Javice and Amar had raised $20m from investors including Marc Rowan, a co-founder and the chief executive of Apollo Global Management and Gingerbread Capital, a firm specialising in female-led businesses.Javice told Business Insider in 2021 that she divided her time between Miami and New York, starting her days with a run and a pilates class and ending them with sunset yoga and a swim.She would often take a mid-afternoon screen break to “go out into the wild” to ask people about their student loans, she said.

“If you see an opportunity, don’t be afraid to jump,” she said.“My impatience to achieve my goals helped me see past that ‘conventional wisdom’ to take a risk that landed me where I am today.”In November 2022, Javice was on the Forbes 30 Under 30 list, and a year later, the magazine placed her into its “Hall of Shame”.
A picture

Gordon Ramsay reaches boiling point in Chelsea, 1999

Gordon Ramsay is in the kitchen of Restaurant Gordon Ramsay in Chelsea, and it’s hot, intense and frenzied, wrote fly-on-the-wall reporter Nicci Gerard in the Observer on 24 January 1999.‘Over everyone towers Ramsay, barking orders, spraying expletives across the room… tasting, shouting (“Fucking unbelievable!”), calming (“Guys, guys, guys!”).’ Ramsay, 32, the ‘wunderkind of the cooking world’, is running what is ‘not a democracy but a dictatorship’. Channel 4 was filming the kitchen for Ramsay’s Boiling Point, a five-part documentary.It was a bad week: his father had just died, aged 54

A picture

The Great Indian, London: ‘A thoroughly delightful food pub’ – restaurant review

An old north London boozer has found new life as an Indian restaurant, and redefined ‘gastropub’ along the wayThe Great Indian, 139 Marlborough Road, London N19 4NU. Small plates £7.50-£11.50, large dishes £9.50-£23

A picture

Save our cider: apple growers and producers call on government to protect traditional ‘native wine of England’

They are a symbol of the bucolic English countryside and a staple of the West Country landscape, but since the second world war, 90% of traditional orchards have disappeared.Defined as a collection of five or more fruit trees planted in permanent grassland and managed in a non-intensive way, traditional orchards have suffered from neglect, been razed for development and converted to intensive bush orchards or alternative crops.Now cider makers are calling on the government to protect what they say is one of the country’s most environmentally friendly farming systems. Traditional orchards are often wildlife havens with rare birds and insects, and allow silvopasture – where livestock grazes on a variety of plants in forests and tree-filled pastureland, eliciting multiple uses from one field. Older orchards, proponents say, are excellent carbon storers

A picture

How to turn eggs into a traditional British pub snack – recipe

Pickling is a good way to lengthen the life of your eggs, and a chance to use up herbs and spices, tooThe Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.At Yeo Valley’s Good Food and Eating Well conference last year, Christine Storry of the Dynamic Food Board, a UK body that promotes sustainable, local food procurement, estimated that “more than 700 million eggs are wasted in the UK each year”; that’s roughly 45,000 tonnes, or almost equivalent to the weight of the Titanic. She also noted that only 22% of us know how to test if an egg is fresh and safe to eat

A picture

Benjamina Ebuehi’s recipe for orange and cardamom muffins | The sweet spot

Give me a muffin over a cupcake any day. They’re less faffy to make, don’t need much when it comes to decorations, and I’m a big fan of the way the domed tops spill over the cases, giving a crisp shell that contrasts with the fluffy insides. Orange and cardamom feel bright and fresh, so are ideal for cold, grey afternoons.Prep 10 minRest 15 min Cook 40 min Makes 6Zest of 1 orange Seeds from 6 green cardamom pods, crushed100g caster sugar190g plain flour 1½ tsp baking powder ¼ tsp bicarbonate of soda 1 large egg 80g plain yoghurt 40ml milk 80g unsalted butter, melted20g oil 2-3 tbsp pearl sugar (optional)Heat the oven to 220C (200C fan)/425F/gas 7 and line a six-hole muffin tray with paper cases.In a bowl, use your fingertips to rub the orange zest and cardamom into the sugar until well combined and smelling nice and fragrant

A picture

Seven kitchen gadgets I can’t live without: ‘How does anyone make a salad without one?’

Keen cook Elizabeth Quinn opens her drawer to share the culinary tools that save her time, sanity and fingertipsThe Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.What makes a kitchen gadget a culinary gamechanger? An indispensable item of the kitchen toolkit doesn’t have to be hi-tech or fancy – my most prized tool is a 50 cent plastic spatula – but it does have to earn its place in the cutlery drawer.The Guardian’s journalism is independent