Albanese government must ban dynamic pricing and prosecute scalpers, local ticketing agency says
The government must ban dynamic pricing and banish scalpers if consumers are to pay fair prices for concerts, the head of Australia’s largest locally owned ticketing platform says.Last month the Albanese government said it planned to change consumer laws to address the practice of inflating tickets while customers wait in online queues, known as dynamic pricing, after tickets for the US rock band Green Day’s Australian tour rose to up to $500.While the details of the reforms are yet to be released, the Humanitix co-chief executive officer, Joshua Ross, said the government and ticketing companies could do more to prevent people and online sites from buying tickets for the sole purpose of reselling them at huge markups.“They need to create examples of it with proper prosecution,” Ross said.“And if they can clean up the scalping world by making the disincentive strong enough, then it makes sense to ban dynamic pricing.
”Anti-scalping laws vary from state to state.For example, in New South Wales and South Australia, it is illegal to resell a ticket for more than 10% of the original price.In Victoria, this rule only applies to concerts the government deems “major events”.Ross said these laws did nothing to limit fees for selling tickets on third-party reselling platforms from being “exorbitant”.“That should be tightened up,” he said.
“I’m waiting for Albanese’s call because I’m happy to chat about this.”Get our weekend culture and lifestyle emailMany ticketing companies have been resistant to reforms that would outlaw dynamic pricing, although extreme ticket price increases have outraged concert goers, putting the issue on the public agenda.In the UK the Competition and Markets Authority is examining whether Ticketmaster engaged in “unfair commercial practices” in selling tickets for the Oasis reunion concert.Some people waited for hours in the online queue only to find the price had jumped by more than £200 by the time it came to pay.Ticketmaster – owned by Live Nation – and its main competitor Ticketek, have defended dynamic pricing by saying demand-driven pricing mitigates the problem of ticket scalping.
Humanitix, which Ross founded with Adam McCurdie, donates all profits from booking fees to charity,Ross said the ticketing giants could do more to prevent scalping by not releasing purchased tickets until an hour before a concert, or facilitating their resale for people who could no longer attend,“The question is, do they make a lot of money from dynamic pricing? And if the answer is yes, do you think they’d ever say publicly that dynamic pricing should be banned?” he said,“There’s so much to block scalping that’s not being done so that we shouldn’t need dynamic pricing, because fans should be getting a real chance at a real price and at a fair price,”A spokesperson for Ticketek said Ross’s comments were “misinformed” as the company did “deploy a range of technologies” to limit scalping “including but not limited to, unlocking barcodes hours before concerts”.
“Pricing of tickets and the use of dynamic pricing is a decision made by the artist, management or rights holder with the promoter, and not by the ticketing agency,” they said,“Once a customer has added a ticket or any other items to their basket, the base price of the ticket (excluding fees) will not change throughout the course of the transaction,”A spokesperson for Ticketmaster said pricing tickets “closer to demand” helped artists fighting scalping and they did not change prices “during the purchase process”,Sign up to Saved for LaterCatch up on the fun stuff with Guardian Australia's culture and lifestyle rundown of pop culture, trends and tipsafter newsletter promotion“When tickets are priced according to market demand, event organisers and artists – not scalpers – retain the value,” they said,“Ticketmaster invests more than the rest of the industry combined in technology and innovation to protect fans from online scalpers.
”The proposed government reforms are part of a broader package of measures designed to increase consumer protections by addressing everything from so-called subscription traps to deceptive online selling tactics.Australia’s consumer protections lag the US, UK and EU when it comes to banning unfair trade practices, according to consumer advocates.The proposed changes to dynamic pricing target those companies that change prices during a transaction, as opposed to more acceptable practices such as lifting the price of short-stay accommodation during peak periods, which customers are aware of when they start the booking process.The chief executive of the Consumer Policy Research Centre, Erin Turner, said dynamic pricing became a problem when businesses charged wildly different prices for factors outside the customer’s control.“Dynamic pricing isn’t fair when prices change while you’re trying to purchase a ticket,” Turner said.
“So you go in with one price, you get to the end of the process, and it’s suddenly much higher.“We’ve heard of examples where someone will start with one price and they’re lucky enough to be allocated a ticket and suddenly it costs hundreds of dollars more than what they were expecting.“That bait and switch is deeply unfair in a high-demand situation.If you’re going to charge someone a higher price because of demand, it needs to be crystal clear upfront.”Problems with dynamic pricing extend outside the ticketing industry given companies now access large amounts of customer data that can be used to price items differently, according to what the business believes an individual consumer will pay.
Consumer advocates have raised concerns over how some shoppers are being forced to hand over personal data to access the best prices for healthy foods such as vegetables, creating an unfair market.Turner says ticketing companies that defend dynamic pricing are acting like scalpers, because they both end up charging consumers excessive amounts.“Anytime someone charges hundreds of extra dollars for a ticket is a problem, whether that’s the ticketing company or an informal scalper,” Turner said.
Liz Kendall says there is ‘no tension’ in government over winter fuel payments
Liz Kendall has said she sees “no tension” in government over plans to make savings from restricting winter fuel payments to vulnerable pensioners and an increase in people securing pension credit.The work and pensions secretary stressed she wanted all people eligible for pension credit to have the benefit, regardless of whether it could limit the government’s attempt to repair the “dire state” of public finances.Ministers launched a pension credit publicity campaign in August, yet Kendall told the Commons work and pensions select committee 800,000 eligible pensioners had still not applied for it.Winter fuel payments have been restricted so only those claiming pension credit from this winter are eligible to receive the benefit worth up to £300.The government made the decision in the hope of saving £1
Nine hours and 52 minutes: did Dave Strachan’s ambulance wait cost him his life?
When he woke up with chest pains, his wife, Lucille, called 999, expecting help to arrive in minutes. But as he drifted in and out of consciousness, their wait continued ...On the evening of 15 March 2022, Lucille and Dave Strachan had supper in their north Wales home, watched their favourite TV show, Dogs Behaving (Very) Badly, then went upstairs to bed
Less than half of eligible people received NHS ‘midlife MOT’ since 2019, says watchdog
Less than half of people over the age of 40 in England are getting the heart health checks they are entitled to, according to the government’s spending watchdog.The National Audit Office called for a review of how NHS health checks are provided in England, after it found that only 44% of eligible adults had attended one in the past five years.The checks, known as a midlife MOT, were introduced in 2009, to help identify those at higher risk of developing heart disease, stroke, kidney disease and diabetes and offer tailored advice and treatment to help them manage their risk more effectively.Heart disease is estimated to affect 6.4 million people in England, costing the healthcare system £7
Streeting’s hospital league table plan riles NHS medics and bosses
Wes Streeting plans to publish a football-style league table of the best- and worst-performing hospitals in England, prompting fury from NHS bosses and staff at the prospect of struggling trusts being “named and shamed”.The health secretary will announce the controversial move on Wednesday to an audience of health service leaders and defend it as a “tough” but necessary way of raising care standards.“There will be no more turning a blind eye to failure. We will drive the health service to improve, so patients get more out of it for what taxpayers put in,” he will say at the annual conference of NHS Providers, which represents England’s 220 NHS trusts.The league table will be based on metrics such as how long patients have to wait for A&E treatment, surgery and other care, the state of the trust’s finances and also how good its leadership is judged to be
Sex worker allegedly assaulted in Sydney brothel as women strike for better pay
Sex workers striking for better pay, a cleaner workplace and the right to decide which services they provide to clients at an upmarket inner Sydney brothel have been met with an alleged aggressive response, according to protesters.Seven of the Penthouse club’s sex workers picketed and delivered signed letters to the business late on Friday night, demanding fairer workplace conditions. One, a 21-year-old, was allegedly assaulted inside the venue while carrying a placard.Penthouse bills itself as “the only 6 star brothel located in Sydney CBD”.Sex worker and former Penthouse contractor Iris Hues said the club changed its pricing structure and service menu at the beginning of the month, raising rates without increasing workers’ earnings, as well as penalising workers with hidden fees and fines
Under 1,000 patients a year may opt for assisted dying if bill passes, MP says
Fewer than 1,000 patients a year in England and Wales are expected to choose assisted dying should the law pass, the Labour MP Kim Leadbeater said, as she outlined her bill setting out the change.But MPs opposed to the measure said they were deeply concerned by several components, including that the proposed legislation did not bar doctors from suggesting assisted dying as an option to patients.MPs who spoke on the panel expressed significant doubts about whether the legislation would pass the first parliamentary stage in the Commons on 29 November. Leadbeater said she would make the case “literally every day” but that there were strong views on all sides.“This is potentially one of the biggest things we will do as members of parliament in our careers,” Leadbeater said
Lewis Hamilton unlikely to drive for Ferrari in F1 post-season testing
Carlos Alcaraz beats Andrey Rublev 6-3, 7-6: ATP Finals tennis – as it happened
From Ali v Inoki to Mayweather v McGregor: five bizarre boxing bouts
Rory McIlroy admits painful memory of failure to win the US Open still ‘stings’
The Spin | Keeping cricket societies buoyant through winter is vital for future of the sport
‘This is the time for women’s sports’: investor Deb Henretta backs US rugby