Labour MPs urge Starmer to ‘get out there’ with Trump-style media strategy

A picture


Senior Labour figures are urging Keir Starmer to take a leaf out of Donald Trump’s book and make more frequent media appearances in an attempt to dominate the political agenda as the US president does,MPs told the Guardian they want the prime minister to act more like Trump, who has upended political convention by televising large parts of his cabinet, holding long bilateral meetings on camera and calling in to live television shows,The strategy is very different from that employed by the prime minister, who has said he wants politics to intrude less in people’s lives, and sometimes goes several days without doing a public appearance,Some in his party believe that Starmer’s safety-first approach to media is ill-suited to modern politics, where the news agenda moves rapidly and traditional outlets have less power than ever,One minister said: “Trump and [the vice-president] JD Vance have shown the advantage of getting out there and not worrying about making mistakes.

“In the run-up to the election, Vance did multiple disastrous podcast interviews, but people did not focus on them for long,Eventually he started getting noticed for the things he wanted to say,”They added: “That style of media strategy seems to make a lot more sense than making the occasional appearance on the [BBC] Today programme or Laura Kuenssberg,”Another Labour MP added: “I watched the first few days of the Trump administration with envy,He was out there making announcements all the time.

“Imagine if we had done the same thing.It doesn’t even matter whether your announcements are going to happen – the point is you are telling people who you are and what you want to do.”Even in his first term as US president, Trump took an unusual approach to communications, often making policy announcements or even firing people on social media.He would also call in to his favourite Fox news shows to give impromptu and freewheeling interviews.Trump and Vance took a similar approach in their recent election campaign, often taking part in lengthy podcast interviews with hosts such as Joe Rogan, Logan Paul and Theo Von.

Those interviews would often throw up awkward moments, such as when Vance laughed along with Von’s reference to the Sackler family, who are Jewish, as “money lizards”.But they were generally regarded as having reached parts of the electorate – often young and male – that other politicians struggle to engage.Since taking over, Trump has extended this strategy even further, going as far as to broadcast large portions of his first cabinet meeting, at which the billionaire Elon Musk defended his plans to slash the size of the American government.After his recent televised row with the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, the president remarked to the press: “This is going to be great television.”Sign up to Headlines UKGet the day’s headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morningafter newsletter promotionThe approach echoes what the Trump ally Steve Bannon told the writer Michael Lewis in 2018, when he said: “The Democrats don’t matter.

The real opposition is the media.And the way to deal with them is to flood the zone with shit.”Starmer’s Downing Street, however, prefers to keep a much firmer grip on message discipline, issuing reams of “lines to take” for ministers to follow in interviews and cancelling interviews at the last minute if they have not been entered into the No 10 “grid” of planned media appearances.“Politicians need today to be able to communicate in 30 seconds on TikTok, but also for three and a half hours on Joe Rogan,” said Lee Cain, Boris Johnson’s former communications chief and founding partner of the public relations firm Charlesbye.“The ‘line to take’ is dying, the ‘grid’ is dying,” he added.

“That whole process where we send politicians on to news programmes with a goal of not saying anything, not creating news, not making a mistake, killing authenticity – is a failing strategy.”A recent analysis by Charlesbye found Rogan’s podcast now attracts almost as many daily listeners in the UK as BBC Radio 4’s entire output.Facebook has overtaken the BBC as the most widely consumed source of news, while for the under-35s, TikTok dominates.Some in Labour, however, while acknowledging that the media landscape has changed, believe it would not work for Starmer to try to take advantage of it in the way Trump has.One Labour MP said: “Trump can do that because that is his authentic persona.

If Starmer suddenly tried to follow suit, it would not look authentic – and what matters most in this media landscape is authenticity.”
businessSee all
A picture

Do those so-called US recession indicators actually mean anything? | Gene Marks

As someone who keeps a close eye on the economy, I often bump into those strange metrics that people like to write about that, supposedly, unlock the secret of whether or not a recession is looming.Given what’s going on, it’s no surprise that they are back again. Just last week Bloomberg reported a cut in spending at hair stylists. There’s the “lipstick index” – in tough economic times, women load up on lipstick instead of spending their dwindling funds on bigger-ticket items. Former Fed chair Alan Greenspan liked to follow men’s underwear sales because hey, when times are tough, we guys are not willing to buy new shorts

A picture

Jim Ratcliffe’s chemicals business under pressure from Trump tariffs, Moody’s warns

Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s loss-making chemicals business could take longer than expected to recover its financial health because of Donald Trump’s trade tariffs, analysts have said.The billionaire industrialist has faced growing concerns over the state of his chemicals group amid problems with his business interests in Manchester United and All Blacks rugby.In a fresh cause for concern, one of the key companies within Ratcliffe’s sprawling business empire, Ineos Quattro, has reported that its financial losses more than doubled to €819m (£702m) at the end of last year, from €291m in 2023, its first loss in at least five years.The chemical company, which supplies a range of industries including carmakers and pharmaceutical companies, said in its annual report that its “substantial indebtedness” crept almost half a billion euros higher during 2024 to reach nearly €7.7bn

A picture

Labour must focus on risk to global financial stability posed by Trump policies, not only trade | Heather Stewart

Keir Starmer and Rachel Reeves have underlined how much the world has changed after Donald Trump’s “liberation day”, with the UK prime minister even declaring an end to globalisation.But as the chancellor prepares to fly to Washington this week to meet her global counterparts at the International Monetary Fund meetings, Labour appears to see the risks purely in terms of the hit to international trade.While frantically negotiating with Washington over tariffs, the government is pressing ahead with plans to deregulate the City – just as global financial stability appears threatened by the chaos unleashed by the White House.Labour has taken a muscular approach to saving the steelworks in Scunthorpe, and Reeves has written of the need for a “strong, smart and agile state to support key industries”.Yet Labour’s stance on the UK’s highly globalised financial sector appears to remain the one set out in the chancellor’s Mansion House speech in November: that rules imposed after the 2008 crash have “gone too far”

A picture

Another crisis, another IMF summit: but unlike 2008, the delegates are disunited

When the world’s finance ministers and central bank governors gather at the International Monetary Fund in Washington this week, it may kindle memories of another meeting, also held against the backdrop of a global economic crisis, in autumn 2008.Then, as the aftershocks from the collapse of Lehman Brothers ripped through financial markets, central banks coordinated drastic emergency rate cuts, and the UK chancellor, Alistair Darling, urged his G7 counterparts to emulate the UK’s approach and shore up stricken banks.Policy mistakes, including lax financial regulation, were partly to blame back in 2008 – but as this week’s IMF and World Bank spring meetings convene, the chaos confronting key decision-makers in the global economy has been entirely manufactured in the White House.Donald Trump’s arbitrary “reciprocal” tariffs have been paused for 90 days, with many governments hoping they will never be reinstated. But the 10% across-the-board levy that remains in place – alongside eye-watering increases in tariffs on the US’s great geopolitical rival, China – still represents a historic shock to the global trading system

A picture

‘It might be gutted’ – Boots braces for dose of private equity’s bitter medicine

The 176-year-old chemist is preparing for another change of hands. What’s the mood of staff and residents at its home base in Nottinghamshire?‘We’ve had several rounds of cost-cutting and it could happen again,” says a Boots worker. Fears are running high as the Nottinghamshire-based chemist prepares to change hands – perhaps twice in quick succession.The US private equity firm Sycamore Partners is close to finalising a $10bn (£7.8bn) deal to take over the listed US owner of Boots, Walgreens Boots Alliance

A picture

It’s not poverty that’s breeding the new populism. It’s wealth | Phillip Inman

Steve Coogan wants ­people to see his new film, The Penguin Lessons, and think about how they might be living in a wealthy cocoon, disengaged from the world.The film’s central character – a Briton teaching expat children in Argentina – rescues a penguin and tries to help local people persecuted by the rightwing government. Re-enacting a true story, Coogan is showing how it’s possible to be involved in local communities even when the protagonist is an outsider.Coogan is concerned about a political shift to the right built on a more selfish outlook, one that focuses on close family and casts a cold eye on people less fortunate. We see it in the US, in the rise of Reform in the UK, and in France and Germany