Lowering the voting age will benefit democracy | Letters

A picture


Simon Jenkins disagrees with the government’s proposal to reduce the voting age to 16 (Votes for 16-year-olds? Sorry, but I’m not convinced, theguardian.com, 17 April).But the voting age of 18 is an arbitrary threshold.Quite a recent one too – until 1969 the minimum voting age in Britain was 21.Other countries have minimum voting ages from 16 to 21.

In Vatican City, voting for a new pope is restricted to cardinals under the age of 80,The usual argument for denying the vote to 16- and 17-year-olds hinges on their supposed lack of certain capacities such as political awareness or powers of reasoning,But if we accept this, perhaps we should also put a ceiling on voting age too, as they do in the Vatican,After all, for every 16-year-old too clueless to understand what they are doing in a voting booth, there must be several geriatrics (and several more not so geriatric) who are just as incompetent,Moreover, while some 90-year-olds have pin-sharp minds, so too are there plenty of 16-year-olds who easily clear any reasonable cognitive threshold we might set for voting rights.

Of course they should be able to vote if they want to.Robin PriorWargrave, Berkshire Simon Jenkins questions the case for votes at 16 without acknowledging the existing statutory subject that helps prepare young people for democratic life: citizenship.Citizenship has been a national curriculum subject since 2002.It equips pupils with essential knowledge about democracy, law, rights and how to engage critically and responsibly in civic life.It also directly supports the development of media and information literacy – skills urgently needed, as highlighted in recent findings by the NASUWT teaching union on the harmful influence of social media in schools (Teachers warn of rise in misogyny and racism in UK schools, 19 April).

This context makes the current Department for Education curriculum and assessment review a vital moment to reassert the importance of citizenship education.A coherent, statutory citizenship curriculum from primary age through post-16 would give all students the tools to understand complex issues, challenge harmful narratives and participate meaningfully in society.If society wants young people to vote, contribute and take responsibility, we must ensure that they are taught to have an understanding of how democracy works.Citizenship education is the best foundation we have – and it already exists.Let’s recognise it, strengthen it and give it the place it deserves in our education system.

Liz MoorseChief executive, Association for Citizenship Teaching Simon Jenkins suggests that many 16-year-olds may not vote.There are many reasons why young people may not wish to engage in politics, and they are as vulnerable to misinformation as any other group.But with general elections every four or five years, the first opportunity for them to vote in one may be when they are 21 or 22.By this time, they will have been excluded from the democratic process for so long that they will not feel they can shape the laws that we are supposed to respect.I know from debates with sixth formers that many of them are as well qualified as any other age group to engage sensibly in informed political discussion.

Nobody is suggesting that it should be compulsory for them to vote, and we should not block their participation because they might vote the wrong way.Chris RennardLiberal Democrat, House of Lords Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
cultureSee all
A picture

Jimmy Kimmel on the pope’s death: ‘Now we know JD Vance is bad at praying, too’

With several hosts on post-Easter holiday, Jimmy Kimmel recaps Donald Trump’s hypocritical messages on religion and the death of Pope Francis at the age of 88.“Between Easter and 4/20, a lot of stuff got rolled yesterday,” said Jimmy Kimmel on Monday evening, and “our Peep-headed president got in the Easter spirit yesterday” with an “unusually warm” message on Truth Social wishing “peace and joy for all who celebrate the resurrection of Jesus Christ”.But Trump then followed up with a darker message: “Happy Easter to all, including the Radical Left Lunatics who are fighting and scheming hard to bring Murderers, Drug Lords, Dangerous Prisoners, the Mentally Insane, and well known MS-13 Gang Members and Wife Beaters, back into our Country.” (The post went on at length in similar fashion.)“It’s Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde your tax returns,” Kimmel joked

A picture

‘Be playful, try new things!’ The Southbank Centre’s Mark Ball on his new festival, Multitudes

The arts centre’s artistic director is on a mission to bring new audiences to the joys of classical music. He explains why mixing it with circus, grime, poetry, and film might be the way to do itCan you name the UK’s top five most visited attractions? A 2024 survey placed the British Museum and Natural History Museum in the top two spots, then Windsor Great Park and the Tate Modern. No surprises there. But the fifth is perhaps less expected: the Southbank Centre, with 3.7 million annual visitors

A picture

Celebrities pay tribute to Pope Francis: ‘Thank you for being an ally’

Numerous celebrities, many among the nearly 1.3 billion Catholics worldwide, expressed condolences for the late Pope Francis, who died early on Monday – the morning after Easter Sunday – at the age of 88.Martin Scorsese, who has grappled with Catholic faith in several of his films, called Pope Francis, “in every way, a remarkable human being” in a statement to Variety. “He acknowledged his own failings. He radiated wisdom

A picture

Post your questions for Nigel Havers

Nigel Havers has forged a career playing quintessential, charming, good-looking, well-educated Englishmen. The younger son of one-time Lord Chancellor Sir Michael Havers, Havers Jr opted against Eton, moving into theatre, radio and briefly training as a wine merchant, before finding fame as the lead of the 1977 BBC adaptation of Nicholas Nickleby, and opposite Bob Hoskins in 1978 Dennis Potter BBC musical drama, Pennies from Heaven.By the time he was cast in 1981’s Chariots of Fire, Havers was a familiar face on British television. Here, he got to play his first lord – Cambridge student Lord Andrew Lindsay – and run, barefooted and in slow motion, across West Sands beach in St Andrews, earning him a Bafta nomination in the process. Roles soon followed as the public school-educated but class-conscious Ronnie Heaslop in 1984 epic period drama A Passage to India, and as father figure Dr Rawlins in Steven Spielberg’s 1987 war film Empire of the Sun

A picture

Arts Council England a victim of ‘London-centric’ media coverage, CEO says

The chief executive of Arts Council England has launched an impassioned defence of the organisation, claiming it has suffered because of “London-centric” media coverage.Darren Henley, who saw in his 10th anniversary as Arts Council England CEO last week, told the Guardian there was an imbalance in media coverage.He said London-based figures were able to get newspaper coverage while regional arts leaders to whom ACE has redistributed funds were not getting the same access. ACE is charged with distributing public and lottery funds to arts organisations in England.Henley said: “I observe the London-centricity in our media

A picture

‘When medieval times return, I’ll be ready’: Bella Ramsey on friendship, fashion and The Last of Us

The young actor’s life has been transformed since they landed the lead role in what turned out to be a TV phenomenon. As the much-anticipated second season begins, they discuss growing up in the glare of fameBella Ramsey self-recorded their audition tape for The Last of Us at their parents’ home in Leicestershire and sent it off more in hope than expectation. Ramsey, who was 17 at the time, had never played the post-apocalyptic zombie video game on which the new TV series was based, but knew it was a big deal: released in 2013, it had sold more than 20m copies. It would later emerge that Craig Mazin and Neil Druckmann, the show’s creators, looked seriously at more than 100 actors for the role of Ellie, the sassy and quirky but also complicated and vicious American protagonist of The Last of Us. “Yeah, I’ve been told,” says Ramsey with a wry smile