The Ukraine crisis has accelerated a reset of UK-EU relations – but will it last?

A picture


Barely a day passes, it seems, without Keir Starmer talking to another European leader or preparing for a continental summit.The crisis over Ukraine has very much pushed the UK closer towards the centre stage than at any point since Brexit.But is this a new era or a false dawn?One thing is certain: the optics of engagement have changed.Starmer never shared Boris Johnson’s almost active pride in stoking a row with Brussels, but particularly before the election his advisers were wary of reminding voters about his past as a diehard remainer.With support for Ukraine about as close as the UK gets to an all-party consensus, things are very different.

Starmer can be photographed at the very centre of a gathering of mainly European leaders, as he was on Sunday, safe in the knowledge that even Nigel Farage will praise him for his diplomacy.Donald Trump’s apparent abandonment of Ukraine and reversal away from decades of Nato defence guarantees “has really accelerated the rapprochement between Britain and Europe, not just the EU”, said Peter Ricketts, the former senior UK diplomat and government national security adviser, who is now a crossbench peer.“All the reports I’ve heard from European friends in Brussels and Paris and elsewhere are that they are impressed and pleased with the Sunday meeting, and the sense that Britain is back in its natural place as a leader in European security,” he said.“It has taken the crisis, in a way, to really galvanise the improving relations that were already under way.”This is happening amid what could be seen as a wider political shift.

Polls about Brexit increasingly show that many voters view it as a mistake, and while there is arguably minimal appetite to revisit an issue that crippled UK politics for several years, trade unions are now pushing for closer EU ties.So could the necessities of supporting Ukraine help smooth the way for a close EU-UK relationship on trade? Lord Ricketts said he would be surprised if any of these Brussels red lines were suddenly blurred.“I would draw a distinction between defence issues and the treaty-based issues about trade, fishing and energy markets and so on, which are all rooted in EU texts or EU-UK legal texts, which are going to be slower to change,” he said.“I think even with a crisis in Europe, in those sorts of areas it’s going to be slow going.”Ukraine is to an extent a distinct issue.

Defence links are often separated from Brussels, while the still-emerging “coalition of the willing” to fill the security vacuum covers some non-EU European states such as Norway, as well as Canada and potentially Australia.“The defence and foreign policy wonks were already comfortable with a closer relationship with the UK,” said Ian Bond, another former UK diplomat, who is deputy director of the Centre for European Reform thinktank.“The problem is what happens in other parts.”He added: “The thing will be to keep as much as possible of the new relationship at the level of leaders.Macron gets it, I think that when Friedrich Merz becomes German chancellor he will get it.

“If their fishing ministers don’t get it, that’s something which hopefully they will manage domestically, rather than the reset of the EU-UK relationship coming to a grinding halt over how many sand eels Danish fishers are allowed to catch off the Dogger Bank.”And what of the domestic political considerations for Starmer? According to Paula Surridge, a professor of political sociology at the University of Bristol and the deputy director of the UK in a Changing Europe thinktank, these are thus far relatively minimal.Sign up to Headlines EuropeA digest of the morning's main headlines from the Europe edition emailed direct to you every week dayafter newsletter promotion“At the moment, there’s not really a downside to him being pictured with all the other European leaders,” she said.“One thing some voters have been worried about recently is the waning influence of the UK, and seeing that makes people think that we have a seat at the table in world affairs, in a way we haven’t seen really since 2016.”Similarly, even Reform UK, seen as a looming electoral threat to Labour, is not making a fuss, with Farage even claiming that Starmer’s role in trying to find accord between the US and Europe was a direct benefit of Brexit.

There is, of course, a much greater external factor at play: what happens with the ever-unpredictable White House.“A lot is going to depend on what happens with Washington over the coming weeks,” Bond said.“If Trump calms down and stops trying to ensure that Ukraine loses, which is what he seems to be doing at the moment, I can see that traditional British reflexes of ‘we must at all costs protect the special relationship’ kick in pretty hard.“But if Trump continues to try to destroy Ukraine and to normalise relations with Russia, and keeps threatening to invade Greenland and absorb Canada, I think it’s going to become increasingly difficult for the Brits to pretend that nothing has happened.”
politicsSee all
A picture

Reform MP Rupert Lowe hits back at party leadership after losing whip

Rupert Lowe has compared dealing with the Reform party leadership to smashing his head against a brick wall amid a public war of words that has revealed deep tensions at the heart of the rightwing party.Lowe posted a statement on X asking the party leader, Nigel Farage, to have dinner with him less than 24 hours after Lowe lost the Reform whip, having been accused of threatening the party chair, Zia Yusuf.The party reported the Great Yarmouth MP to the police, and Scotland Yard said a complaint of “verbal threats” made on Thursday about an alleged incident last December was being assessed by officers.In a post on Saturday morning, Lowe said: “I have been betrayed more times than I care to remember, but never by people I would have called friends. It’s not a very pleasant feeling, to be entirely honest …“Does requesting regular meetings of MPs make me a monster? Is asking to even just see policy before it’s made public unreasonable? Is it fair to be insulted because I want people to finally talk to each other?“I have torn out what remaining hair I have left over the last few months trying to talk

A picture

‘Nigel Farage feels real’: why young British men are drawn to Reform

Josh is 24 years old and works as a carer. It’s not easy work, but he prefers it to his old job in a supermarket: most of his clients are elderly and “just want someone there with them, because they’re lonely”. In his spare time Josh used to be into boxing. But lately he’s got into politics instead.Like many of his gen Z contemporaries, he’s thoroughly disillusioned with the mainstream kind

A picture

Britain’s biggest unions call for much closer UK-EU ties amid ‘volatile’ global economy

The UK should forge much closer ties with Europe amid an increasingly “volatile and unpredictable” global economy, Britain’s biggest trade unions will argue as they push for new workers’ rights across the continent.In its first major intervention on Europe in five years, the Trades Union Congress (TUC) will call for a “much-needed” closer relationship with the EU, in a joint statement with European counterparts.Ahead of Keir Starmer’s reset talks with Brussels, the union umbrella body will say negotiations must cover new opportunities for quality jobs for UK workers in the EU and for EU workers in the UK, though it will stop short of calling for a return to freedom of movement.Starmer has spent his first six months in power laying the groundwork for a better relationship with Brussels, with the UK hoping for better defence cooperation and smoother trade, and the EU seeking a mobility scheme allowing for greater travel by young people in return.Cooperation between the UK and the rest of Europe has recently intensified after the return to power of Donald Trump in the US, with European leaders agreeing to higher military spending to counter the threat of Russia in a world where they will have to rely less on US backing

A picture

Divided Reform UK reports own MP to police amid bullying claims

Reform UK has erupted into open civil war after the party said its MP Rupert Lowe had received complaints about bullying and had made threats against the party chair, a day after Lowe criticised Nigel Farage for being “messianic”.Lowe responded with anger, saying there was no evidence to back up the bullying claims, and that it was “entirely untrue” that he had made threats. He again criticised Farage, saying Reform was “our party as much as it is Nigel’s”.He also explicitly linked the allegations to his decision to criticise Farage, saying that the day after he had done this, he had received “a knife in my back over false allegations”.In a joint statement by the chair, Zia Yusuf, and Reform’s chief whip, Lee Anderson, they said they were “obligated to disclose that the party received complaints from two female employees about serious bullying” in Lowe’s offices

A picture

‘Don’t punish the vulnerable’: Labour MPs uneasy over planned welfare cuts

Dozens of backbench Labour MPs are unhappy with plans to cut billions from the rising welfare bill, with ministers holding meetings to convince them that the changes to disability benefits are necessary.Labour MPs told the Guardian there were deep concerns within the parliamentary party that the changes would take money from the poorest, which was not what they had entered government to do.No 10 is preparing to make the case for welfare cuts before Rachel Reeves’s spring statement, with Keir Starmer’s spokesperson saying on Friday that there had been an “unsustainable rise in welfare spending”.“Our broken social security system is holding our people back, our economy back,” he said. “We’ve got 3 million people out of work for health reasons, one in eight young people [are] not currently in work, education or training, and that is a shocking situation to be in

A picture

The Ukraine crisis has accelerated a reset of UK-EU relations – but will it last?

Barely a day passes, it seems, without Keir Starmer talking to another European leader or preparing for a continental summit. The crisis over Ukraine has very much pushed the UK closer towards the centre stage than at any point since Brexit. But is this a new era or a false dawn?One thing is certain: the optics of engagement have changed. Starmer never shared Boris Johnson’s almost active pride in stoking a row with Brussels, but particularly before the election his advisers were wary of reminding voters about his past as a diehard remainer.With support for Ukraine about as close as the UK gets to an all-party consensus, things are very different