Labour’s investment in AI isn’t as clever as it thinks it is | Letters
There are at least three major concerns to raise with the government’s apparent betting the future of the UK on so-called artificial intelligence (‘Mainlined into UK’s veins’: Labour announces huge public rollout of AI, 12 January).The Guardian’s journalism is independent.We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link.Learn more.First, as Prof Shannon Vallor at the University of Edinburgh has pointed out in her book The AI Mirror, generative AI is not creative; it only looks backward.
It can only remix and reproduce what we have done before, the same errors, failures and biases that have got us into our current mess.Second, there’s the question of resources.One study suggests the same work done by AI systems can use 33 times as much energy as a traditional program; Ireland is already seeing about a third of its electricity going into datacentres.How much AI can the planet afford?Third, if the government’s extremely austerity-limited resources are directed towards moving into AI, then it is not actually tackling the pressing problems of poverty, terrible public health and environmental destruction: changing processes does nothing in itself to deliver results.You could add in privacy and data control concerns, security, resilience – and a concern about this government following the last in clinging desperately to rhetoric about “world-leading”.
How about we focus on delivering a healthy, functioning democracy and society, rather than trying to “beat” any other nation.Natalie BennettGreen party, House of Lords It appears from your report that Labour’s embrace of “renewables and small modular nuclear reactors” is not intended to replace the energy sources that supply our current needs, and thus help us move to a more humane and sustainable way of life on our fragile planet.It is instead aimed at fuelling “energy-hungry AI systems” and being onside with the world’s biggest technology companies.So much for dealing with the fundamental causes of climate change, which are rooted in our obsession with growth, and the endless growth in consumption needed to sustain it.This is why our most beautiful valleys and landscapes are to be despoiled with miles of huge pylons – to enable Microsoft and others, who already exert huge influence over our lives, to become even richer and more dominant while the rest of us just have to accept the risks that AI poses to our livelihoods and our security.
Christopher TannerSt Ives, Cambridgeshire The government is placing immense faith in AI as a means of improving the economy and living conditions in the UK(Why Starmer and Reeves are pinning their hopes on AI to drive growth in UK, 12 January).It might help the Treasury if they asked a well-known search engine for advice on how to improve and finance public services.Its AI summary’s first recommendation is to invest more in public health, youth services and benefits and to increase taxation.I’m not holding my breath.Philip WardSheffield I’m afraid most of us don’t wish to join the Labour genuflection before the altar of AI.
We foresee the jobs lost and the personal information shared with some of the planet’s more unsavoury characters.Palantir, chaired by the Trump acolyte billionaire Peter Thiel, already runs the NHS’s federated data platform.How long before the chums in UnitedHealth access the details to flog us health insurance? Rachel Reeves may dream that she can now ask Alexa how to “grow” the economy, but we mere mortals can still recognise snake oil when we sniff it.The perceptive AI commentator Helen Beetham has written: “Despite AI’s known biases and colonial histories, its entirely predictable use to target women and minorities for violence, to erode democratic debate and degrade human rights; and despite the toxic politics of AI’s owners and CEOs, including outright attacks on higher education – still people will walk around the herd of elephants in the room to get to the bright box marked ‘AI’ in the corner.”Kevin DonovanBirkenhead, Merseyside It’s heartening that AI will now be used for spotting potholes, as clearly in the past councils have had such trouble finding them despite all the real intelligence received.
Giles du BoulayAylesbury, Buckinghamshire Do you have a photograph you’d like to share with Guardian readers? If so, please click here to upload it,A selection will be published in our Readers’ best photographs galleries and in the print edition on Saturdays,
Bank of England delays rules designed to avoid banking crash by a year
The Bank of England will further delay capital rules meant to prevent another 2008-style crash, as it weighs the impact of Donald Trump’s return to the White House and the chancellor Rachel Reeves’s call for regulators to help drive UK growth.The Bank’s regulatory arm said it was delaying the date by which banks had to implement Basel 3.1 rules by a year, to January 2027.The Bank’s regulator, the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA), said it made the decision after consulting with the Treasury, and that it had taken “competitive and growth considerations” into account.It marks the third delay by the central bank, which is buying time to see how far the Trump administration will go in watering down regulations
IMF upgrades UK growth forecast and takes swipe at Trump plans
The International Monetary Fund has upgraded its forecast for UK growth this year in an update to its biannual assessment of the global economy, while taking a swipe at plans by Donald Trump’s incoming US administration for the potentially destabilising effect of large-scale tax cuts, import tariffs and weaker regulations.In a fillip to the Labour government, the Washington-based organisation said it expected the UK economy to grow by 1.6% in 2025, up from an earlier forecast of 1.5%.The IMF judged that Labour’s increase in investment spending, improved household finances and a series of interest rate cuts by the Bank of England would give the UK economy a lift this year
Can Donald Trump circumvent a TikTok ban?
As the app is on the brink of being expelled, the president-elect has been working to make good on his pledge to save itIn the run-up to the election, Donald Trump made a plea to his followers. “FOR ALL THOSE THAT WANT TO SAVE TIK TOK IN AMERICA, VOTE TRUMP!” he posted to his Truth Social account in September. Since then, he’s been working to make good on that pledge.He hosted TikTok’s CEO, Shou Chew, at his Mar-a-Lago estate in December, implored the US supreme court to delay a TikTok ban and he’s now reportedly considering an executive order to postpone the app’s disappearance. Chew is slated to join Trump at his inauguration in what appears to be a show of solidarity with the embattled executive
Russian hackers target WhatsApp accounts of ministers worldwide
Russian state-linked hackers have targeted the WhatsApp accounts of government ministers and officials around the world with emails inviting them to join user groups on the messaging app.The WhatsApp tactic marks a new approach by a hacking unit called Star Blizzard. Britain’s National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) has linked Star Blizzard to Russia’s domestic spy agency, the FSB, and has accused it of seeking to “undermine trust in politics in the UK and likeminded states”.According to a blogpost by Microsoft, victims receive an email from an attacker impersonating a US government official, enticing the recipient to click on a QR code that gives the attacker access to their WhatsApp account. The code, instead of giving access to a WhatsApp group, connects an account to a linked device or the WhatsApp Web portal
Draper delighted hard work paying off after hat-trick of Melbourne marathons
Jack Draper says his trio of five-set victories at the Australian Open are evidence of the hard work he has put into his career, effort that is finally paying off for him in the biggest matches.“I still have a long way to go, but this is a huge drive forward, the fact that I’ve come through three five-set matches, mentally and physically, it doesn’t happen often,” said Draper. “That’s a testament to the work I’ve done and the place I’m in. So very, very proud of that.”At 12:55am on Saturday morning in Melbourne, Draper, the 15th seed, closed out his third five-set win in as many matches to reach the fourth round with a 6-4, 2-6, 5-7, 7-6 (5), 7-6 (8) victory over Aleksandar Vukic of Australia
Windsor embraces return of jumps racing with cash at the Million festival
When Windsor staged what was billed as its last ever jumps meeting in December 1998, the final race on the card was the Norwegian Blue Handicap Hurdle – a clear sign that as far as the track was concerned, jumping was no more. It had ceased to be.A generation later, though, it is suddenly showing distinct signs of life. There were just under 5,000 racegoers at Windsor last month for the first officially scheduled jumps meeting for 26 years, and the queues at the turnstiles on Friday – the first of two days as part of the first Berkshire Million festival, with the Clarence House Chase card at Ascot as the meat in the sandwich – suggested plenty of those fans had come back for more.There was a total of £18,299 in win prize money on offer for the seven races in 1998
Apple suspends AI-generated news alert service after BBC complaint
UK TikTokers say goodbye to US followers as ban looms: ‘It’s a really beautiful community’
Elon Musk knows little about UK and Germany and should not interfere – poll
Donald Trump reportedly weighing up TikTok ban delay
UK Meta staff ‘concerned’ over scrapping of factcheckers and DEI programmes
Stronger age checks to come into force for online pornography sites in UK