UK’s assisted dying law won’t be ‘slippery slope’ says California doctor who has helped dozens end their life
A California doctor who has helped dozens of terminally ill people end their lives at a time of their own choosing has said decades of experience in the US showed that there was no danger of a “slippery slope” if assisted dying legislation was robustly framed.Dr Catherine Sonquist Forest, a family physician based in Santa Cruz, said the proposed legislation due to be voted on by MPs at Westminster this week was “impressive”.Since California legalised assisted dying eight years ago, there had been no broadening of the criteria, and in neighbouring Oregon, there had been no change to the law in nearly three decades.“I don’t see change coming any time soon,” Forest told the Observer.Forest has trained thousands of doctors to help terminally ill people to die, and has been personally involved in dozens of assisted deaths.
All were “profound experiences” and a privilege, she said.The option of assisted dying gave people a degree of control over their own body, she said: “The decision is theirs alone – not their family’s, not their doctor’s and certainly not the government’s.“This is their agency.As in any situation, contingency planning gives most people great peace of mind,” she said.California’s End of Life Option Act allows terminally ill adults to request medication from their doctor that will end their life.
But they must have a life-limiting illness with a prognosis of six months or less, plus mental capacity, to be eligible for what is termed aid in dying,Medication must be self-administered,“We prescribe a combination of drugs that cause someone to lose consciousness within between 20 minutes and two hours,The person’s heart stops about two hours after taking the medication and they die,” said Forest,“It’s like a deep anaesthetic.
We don’t see any sign of suffering,”She explains to patients what will happen, and offers to stay with them until they die “but it’s their call,It’s quite a privilege to be present at such a profound moment,”Only about one in 10 people who embarked on the road to assisted dying “follow it through to the end”, she said,Some just want the security of knowing an assisted death is available, some “want every possible minute” with loved ones, and for others changing medical circumstances mean it is no longer possible.
Overall, fewer than 1% of all deaths in the state were the result of the legislation, Forest said: “Many physicians will never face [an assisted death], but those that do, want to do it well.”Forest’s first experience of people asking her to help them die was at the height of the HIV/Aids era in San Francisco: “In the 1980s we had no treatments that would alleviate much of the suffering.Many of them requested assistance, which at that time was illegal in my state.”In 2009, Forest’s mother was terminally ill.“She had terrific palliative care in a hospice, but there was nothing they could really do to alleviate her suffering.
She would have used aid in dying if it was legally available,“She asked me if there was anything that I could do, with my privilege and my training, to help create the option of aid in dying,Up to that time, I’d been rather opposed,”Sign up to Headlines UKGet the day’s headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morningafter newsletter promotionForest became involved in helping to draft the law’s protocols: “I was asking, how could we do this at the very top of our field, with compassion but also with skill?”“I think that dying is very much like childbirth, in that we can offer treatments that reduce suffering, and which sometimes shorten labour, but it’s not up to the physician or the government to decide what level of suffering is being experienced,”Her first assisted dying patient was a Vietnam veteran: “The suffering he had, the pain, the difficulty breathing was paramount.
I was at his bedside when he died, and it was a profound experience because I’d been at many deaths over the years when we didn’t have the tools or the wherewithal to help with a person’s suffering.”A few years ago, Forest’s husband was diagnosed with a neuromuscular disease that destroys nerve cells in the brain and spinal cord.“It causes the muscles to waste away, and the mind is completely intact.My husband was a brilliant scientist.He was an epidemiologist, toxicologist, decorated by our state for his work.
He went from being an athletic, burly man to wasting away.There was no treatment for what he had.”“When he got the terminal diagnosis he said, ‘If I didn’t have the option of aid in dying, I would be desperate right now.’ Just knowing there is a way to avoid inevitable suffering for someone who’s dying is an incredible treatment in itself.”Eventually, after an “excruciating night”, he decided it was time, said Forest.
“We rolled his hospital bed out to the back porch, and he took the medication, and within 20 minutes he was unconscious.And very soon after that, he took his last breath.It was calm, he was not suffering, it was not traumatic.“He was 65 years old, just retired, and he really wanted to live.And I would have taken care of him for ever.
But for him, it was the right thing.” This article was amended on 24 November 2024.Catherine Sonquist Forest’s husband was diagnosed with a neuromuscular disease, not with the neurological disorder Lou Gehrig’s disease as an earlier version said.
Lammy urged to keep promise of envoy to help free Britons held abroad
Families of prominent British prisoners detained abroad have urged the foreign secretary to deliver on pledges to help secure their release amid signs of growing resistance from diplomats.David Lammy, the foreign secretary, vowed in opposition to appoint a special envoy to help secure the freedom of those detained for years without a fair trial. Giving British citizens a legal right to consular access when they run into trouble overseas was also a Labour manifesto pledge.But there are fears that pushback against the envoy plan in particular is being mounted by senior UK diplomats who fear it would cut across relationships with other countries and affect trade deals, the Guardian has been told.Richard Ratcliffe, the husband of Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe, who was detained in Iran for six years, said: “My personal worry is that Lammy will miss the opportunity to change this and the special envoy will be stalled by civil servants until he leaves office
Liz Kendall says young people who won’t take up work will lose benefits
Young people who refuse to take up jobs or training will lose their benefits in the government’s crackdown on worklessness, Liz Kendall has said.The work and pensions secretary said on Sunday: “If people repeatedly refuse to take up the training or work responsibilities, there will be sanctions on their benefits.”Asked on Sky News’s Sunday Morning With Trevor Phillips if this meant losing those benefits, Kendall replied: “Yes.”Ministers are preparing to announce sweeping changes to the welfare system and out-of-work support next week. It forms part of a drive to get more people into work and cut the government’s welfare bill, which has ballooned since the Covid crisis
The John Prescott I knew: Blair’s ‘beautiful people’ tried to erase him – he had other plans
Once frozen out by the New Labour elite, John Prescott fought his way in from the cold to become a loyal deputy leader. Toby Helm recalls a bruising political careerIt was normally Friday evening when he would ring. There was never a “hello, how are you?” or any pleasantry like that. He just dived straight in. “What you up to for Sunday?” he would ask, meaning he had a story for me
Why it was such a joy to interview John Prescott and discover his sweet, sad soul | Rachel Cooke
One of the bad things that comes with being a middle-aged interviewer, as opposed to a younger one, is the tendency to complain loudly that people in public life used to be so much less controlled, so much more wild and free and apt to say the wrong (the interesting) thing.No one likes a nostalgist, after all. But in the case of politicians, I’m afraid there’s no getting away from it. In 2024, unbridled they aren’t. Every word is rehearsed
Starmer seeks to hire EU negotiator in pursuit of relations reset
Ministers are hiring a new EU negotiator as Keir Starmer seeks to reset Britain’s relationship with Europe.The post, worth at least £153,000 a year and advertised by the Cabinet Office, would act as a representative for all of the UK’s dealings with the bloc.The role is described as “principal adviser to the prime minister and the minister for European Union relations [Nick Thomas-Symonds] on matters relating to relations with the EU and delivering the ‘EU reset’ and on international economic issues”.The applicant would also represent the prime minister at negotiations.The trade and cooperation agreement, the basis for the UK-EU relationship after Brexit, will be subject to renewal talks in 2025
Anti-racism campaigner’s London book events cancelled amid threat of far-right violence
Hanif Kureishi, Billy Bragg and freedom of speech groups have voiced alarm after a number of venues cancelled events to promote a book by an anti-racism campaigner amid threats and fears that the recent riots have emboldened the far right.An east London bookshop this week became the latest venue to pull plans to promote Rebel Sounds, a book about the role music plays in the fight against racism and other struggles.It follows the scrapping of similar events at bookshops and pubs over the last few weeks, and the cancellation by the BFI London film festival (LFF) last month of a screening of a documentary about the far right.Joe Mulhall, the author of Rebel Sounds and director of research at the anti-racism organisation Hope Not Hate, said: “Sadly, it feels like we are going backwards.”Mulhall held an event at a secret location last Sunday night after a pub cancelled what was intended to be an evening of discussion and music about the book
Retailers prepare for cautious Christmas as a chill settles on consumers
Passwords are giving way to better security methods – until those are hacked too, that is
Labour could be knocked off course as it sticks to £40bn mission | Heather Stewart
Without the EU, the joke is on us if Trump gets his tariffs | William Keegan
Remember the global financial crisis? Well, high-risk securities are back
Jaguar boss defends new ad and rebrand amid ‘vile hatred’ online