Every person should have care – not lethal drugs | Letters
The argument that the legalisation of assisted suicide in Oregon in 1997 has not started a “slippery slope” is dangerously misleading (‘Slippery slope’ fears over assisted dying have echoes of abortion debate, 24 November).While Oregon’s eligibility criteria have changed little, their interpretation has widened and safeguards have been relaxed.Oregon’s law, like Kim Leadbeater’s proposed bill, allows assisted suicide for adults with a “terminal illness that will lead to death within six months”.Interpretation of “terminal illness” has expanded such that physicians have prescribed lethal drugs to people with anorexia and arthritis.As for safeguards, Oregon’s 15-day “waiting period” (similar to that proposed in Kim Leadbeater’s bill) ceased to be mandatory in 2020.
The following year, exemptions were made in one in five cases; the year after that, one in four.In the first three years after Oregon’s law passed, 28% of those seeking assisted suicide were referred for psychiatric evaluation; in 2022, only 1%.It is also worth noting that in the first year after Oregon’s legalisation passed, 13% of patients seeking assisted suicide cited fear of being a “burden” as a motivating factor.In 2021, that figure stood at 54%.Sick, elderly and disabled people are not burdens.
They are, like every person, valuable.Like every person, they need and deserve care – not lethal drugs.Katherine BacklerOxford I have looked after approximately 50,000 dying patients in my career.Fewer than 20 have asked for help to go to Dignitas in Switzerland; to my knowledge, none went.Kim Leadbeater’s terminally ill adults (end of life) bill has no mention of a proper palliative care assessment first.
Many calls to die can be resolved without terminating a life.The bill states that patients with a prognosis of less than six months are eligible.Research shows how poor even experienced doctors are at prognosticating, often getting life expectancy very wrong.As drafted, the bill allows for the medical assistant to be in the room next door, leaving the patient potentially to be pressured by family and carers if they are wavering.Not all families are loving and benign.
No mention is made about the death certificate recording the medical assistant’s name for later scrutiny,I have met doctors who are happy to help people die; without that audit trail, we would be setting up a legal route for the next Harold Shipman,I have grave concerns about the bill based on my experience,The answer to a good death is better palliative care as a priority,Dr Julia RileyConsultant in palliative care Having read the article by Diane Abbott and Edward Leigh, I would like to endorse their concerns about vulnerable people (Our politics could not be more different – but we’re united against this dangerous assisted dying bill, 20 November).
I have worked in the field of adult social care and dealt with cases of the abuse of elderly people, many of which concerned financial abuse,I think this bill would offer a further means for abuse to occur, and I am aware that prevention and detection of such abuse is very difficult,I hope that this bill will not be passed and that the needs of severely and terminally ill people will be met through proper palliative care services,Janet EvansLlandudno Junction, Conwy As doctors, we took an oath to first do no harm to our patients,Though modern medical schools eschew this oath, the principle of primum non nocere remains ensconced as a pillar of good medical practice.
Doctors take a dim view of other doctors intentionally harming their patients, which is why the case of Harold Shipman “putting an end” to his elderly patients filled everyone with revulsion.Surgeons, of course, cut patients.However, this is not with the intention of harm but to heal.And yet, if you wanted to trust someone with killing a patient humanely, who would you call?GPs will receive requests to “sign off” on patients thought to have less than six months to live.Realistically, who would be able to argue that someone is ineligible? Where would the line be drawn? Could a 20-year-old severely depressed patient be as eligible as a bed-bound nonagenarian with end-stage dementia? And when would a need for assisted dying become an obligation?Of course the benefits of having patients assisted to death would be numerous.
We would no longer need to monitor some of our chronically ill patients,If palliative care beds aren’t available, we could offer death instead, granny dumping in A&E will be a thing of the past, and hospital beds could be unblocked by offering death as a management option,However, each time we visit a chronically unwell, frail old patient at home, would they think of it as a visit by captains of the merchants of death? Would they trust us with their lives?Dr Stuart Reiss GP in London, Dr Basilio Hernandez GP in Oxford Your article (What are the key issues in the assisted dying bill debate?, 22 November) makes the worryingly common mistake of overemphasising the role of hospices and palliative care specialists in end-of-life care provision,An increasing number of people die outside hospital in the UK,Most are looked after by community nurses with the support of GPs, backed up by specialist palliative care teams who advise when necessary – luckily it usually isn’t necessary to involve them, in my experience.
If, as taxpayers, we want to improve community palliative and end-of-life care, our first priority should be to invest more in community nurse teams, where recruitment and retention are extremely challenging,Of course, improving access to specialist palliative care would be good, too, especially services that provide advice and care in people’s homes, but please can commentators stop talking as if the need for good end-of-life care either should or could be met by “all-round hospice care”, as Gordon Brown (Spending time with people in their final days showed me that we need not assisted dying, but better end-of-life care, 22 November) appears to think?Louisa PolakRetired GP, Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk The main argument in favour of the assisted dying bill has been based on cases where people have suffered extreme pain,The bill itself, however, does not address this issue,(The only reference to pain is in the requirement for a review of the working of the act in five years’ time,) There is instead a huge leap from arguing that without the bill people will suffer great pain, to saying that anyone with only six months to live may have medical support to end their life.
As many have argued, the first response to suffering should be to improve palliative care.The reliance on an expected lifespan of only six months is in any case weak – such prognoses are not always reliable.The whole concept, which also underlies the withdrawal of full care at end of life, seems to be that if there is only a short while to live, why not go now? This is a gross misunderstanding of life.As in many other matters, the principle of supply and demand applies.If a commodity is in short supply, it becomes more valuable.
If you only have a few months to live then every day becomes more important.This is true not just for the patient but for those around them who can share their company.Suicidal intentions are generally seen as a mental health problem that needs to be addressed.Why is this any different in the (presumed) last six months of life? Practically anyone who is facing a terminal diagnosis is going to feel depressed and this is going to distort their decision-making.Yet for many there may well still be good days to be had, visits and phone calls from family and friends being the most obvious.
If in a period of depression the patient has been helped to end their life, those good days will never happen.Raymond SmithDorking, Surrey Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Mo matcha mo problem? How to get your green tea fix in a global matcha shortage
It’s “bold, green and attractive”, has boomed in popularity in Australia and on social media, and there are reports of a global shortage. But are we actually running low on matcha – and what are some alternatives to get your green tea hit?Megumi Kanaike, manager of Sydney tea shop Simply Native, says suppliers of the Japanese ground green tea powder have placed limits on orders. She attributes the reported shortage to an “unexpected worldwide boom” in the popularity of a tea that is only harvested once a year in Japan.While matcha production has remained consistent, international demand, driven by social media, has prompted concerns about a shortfall.Kanaike says matcha sales have risen by an “insane” 250% over the past six months at her store
Rukmini Iyer’s quick and easy recipe for spiced roasted cauliflower with chickpeas, halloumi and lemony bulgur
An easy weeknight dinner, with enough for a lunchbox the next day, too. Chickpeas, halloumi and pomegranate are always a winning combination and were a constant on my summer table, but you’ll add plant points and an autumnal touch with the lovely, baharat-spiced cauliflower and hearty, lemon-spiked bulgur wheat base.If you don’t have baharat, substitute with ras el hanout or a few generous tablespoons of rose harissa instead.Prep 15 min Cook 25 min Serves 31 medium cauliflower, cut into medium florets, plus any young leaves400g tinned or jarred chickpeas, drained and rinsed1 red onion, peeled and cut into eight250g halloumi, cut into 2cm chunks2 garlic cloves, peeled and finely grated2 tbsp olive oil 2 heaped tsp baharat 1 tsp sea salt flakes ½ tsp caster sugar (optional)200g bulgur wheat 400ml hot vegetable stockJuice and finely grated zest of 1 lemon, plus 2 strips lemon zest2 tbsp extra-virgin olive oil Seeds of ½ pomegranate15g fresh mint, leaves pickedHeat the oven to 200C (180C fan)/390F/gas 6. Tip the cauliflower, cauliflower leaves, chickpeas, onion and halloumi into a large roasting tin, then mix in the garlic, olive oil, baharat, salt and sugar, if using
Rachel Roddy’s recipe for polenta with buttery garlic mushrooms | A kitchen in Rome
Polenta is occasionally known as pulenda. It’s a reminder that both the name and the cooking method has its roots in antiquity and in the Latin word puls, a blanket term for a universal method: long-cooked, semi-liquid dishes, or “mushes”, based on cereals or legumes. Which leads us to another nice word-link: puls is also the root of the word pulses. But back to antiquity, where the nature of the mushes depended on where in the world they were made, and what was available.The Guardian’s journalism is independent
The nut of the future! 17 delicious ways with pistachios, from cakes to salads to cocktails
Pistachio farmers are having a bumper year – and looking forward to many more. These recipes will help you make the most of the glutPistachios are booming. In California, which has overtaken Iran as the top exporter in recent decades, growers are expected to harvest 1bn lb (about 450m kg) of them this year, a figure that is projected to double by 2031.At a time when all forms of agriculture face stark choices because of climate breakdown, pistachio orchards are expanding: the trees are more drought-tolerant than many crops, including other nuts such as almonds. But if pistachios end up becoming the nut of the future, how will we cope with record-breaking harvests? For now, here are 17 delicious ways to use up your personal allotment of this year’s yield
The truth about salt: how to avoid one of the world’s biggest hidden killers
Most of us consume far too much, which can lead to high blood pressure, heart attacks and strokes. But there are some simple ways to retrain your palate and reduce your intakeLast Tuesday, I bought lunch on the go. I fancied something hot, tasty but healthy, so I chose a vegan ramen from the Japanese-inspired chain Wasabi. The soup was packed with turmeric noodles, vegetable gyozas, mushrooms, bean sprouts, pak choi, pickled ginger and sesame seeds, in a soy and miso broth. It was delicious
Notes on chocolate: why an advent calendar is such a sweet delight
Tasty ways to count down the days to ChristmasThe Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link. Learn more.Once upon a time advent calendars were simply perforated windows you opened on to a festive scene, but now everything can be adapted, come this time of year, into an advent calendar. I even saw one for the Gilmore Girls the other day
‘I do both the Beyoncé and the Jay-Z parts of Crazy In Love’: Edith Bowman’s honest playlist
Bonhams auction house facing claims it is selling looted Roman antiquities
Helen Mahoney obituary
‘We recognise it in this very primal way’: Stephen Fry, Brie Larson, Chris Ofili and more on why we can’t get enough of Greek mythology
From Strictly Ballroom to Sydney’s saviour: how heritage town halls are staging a comeback
Rufus Wainwright: ‘I had a great party trick, but it once blew up in my face’