RFU’s annual report shows a worrying decline. Has it lost its purpose? | Gerard Meagher
Beneath headline figures of the chief executive’s bumper income, what does the RFU stand for and want to achieve?There have been suggestions in recent years, little more than rumours – though plenty of them – that the Rugby Football Union’s chief executive, Bill Sweeney, might have been preparing his exit strategy.That finding a replacement for Eddie Jones could be his parting gift, that negotiating the new eight-year agreement with the Premiership could be his intended legacy.Eventually the whispers grew loud enough that Sweeney publicly denied it and, after it emerged on Monday he was paid £1.1m thanks to the maturation of a bonus three years in the making, we appear to have a pretty good idea as to why.The first thing to say about Sweeney’s eye-watering raise – a performance-based payment of £358,000 on top of a base salary of £742,000 – is that you can hardly blame him for taking it.
Admittedly, he will have likely negotiated the details of the long-term incentive plan that has so lined his pockets but would you really expect him to turn it down? The blame lies with the RFU’s board and remuneration committee for signing off on a scheme that has made Sweeney the best-paid chief executive of a UK sports governing body – excluding payouts – at a time when 42 redundancies have just been made and a loss to reserves of £42m has just been announced.The second, and perhaps the most remarkable, thing to say about Sweeney’s bumper bonus is that, had all targets been met, he would have trousered £100,000 more.As it was, while the “metrics” that the RFU’s annual report refers to were 100% met on finances – curious as the report also states that “we narrowly missed our total revenue target” – and participation in men’s community rugby, they were completely missed for participation in women’s and girls’ community rugby as well as inclusivity.One day the RFU may escape perceptions that have lingered since the days of amateurism, but it will not be today.Keep reading the report and, amid the bullishness that seems at odds with record losses, the troubling acknowledgement from the outgoing chief financial officer, Sue Day, of overreliance on the investment by the private equity group CVC into the Six Nations, the insistence that the union is a greener organisation because Twickenham’s toilets now have hand dryers with “variable speed drives”, you start to ponder existential questions.
What exactly is the point of the RFU?In base terms, it is, of course, a governing body, plain and simple,But what does it stand for? What is it trying to achieve?Men’s matches at Twickenham are, as Sweeney has happily admitted, the cash cow but is the RFU’s top priority the success of Steve Borthwick’s side? If it is, the union should unashamedly say so and hold the head coach to greater account after only five wins from 12 matches this year,These reports used to spell out targets in terms of world rankings, win percentages, but there is little of that in what was released on Monday,“The England men’s team has shown huge progress under Steve Borthwick’s stewardship in his first full season as head coach, with notable performances against strong opposition in the Six Nations and tightly-fought contests in New Zealand,” is about as far as it goes which is a) highly debatable claptrap, and b) followed on the same page of the report by, “The England Senior Men’s team had a win rate of 65% this year, which does not include the two summer matches against New Zealand in July,” Do matches against the All Blacks count or not?Sweeney is yet to give his public views on England’s autumn but while he is said to be “disappointed”, he gives the impression of someone happy enough if Twickenham is selling out with a head coach who isn’t about to hammer the private school system in public.
On the topic of schools, credit where it is due to the RFU for commissioning a report into schools rugby but the findings were excoriating.If the point of the union is to grow the game at junior level, at amateur level, to be more inclusive, to avoid becoming a “declining minority sport” as the schools report warns it could, there is considerable work to do.According to the annual report, 40% of people believe rugby union is a sport for all, which is both a 6% increase on the previous year and a desperately depressing statistic.The report also reads: “Despite a year-on-year increase in age grade player registrations, insights highlight the risk of a decline in popularity of rugby for young people, which is driven by several societal factors.This downturn could negatively impact the future of the game, including player numbers, volunteers, coaches, match officials, and the sustainability of local clubs.
Age grade girls’ game participation not meeting projected levels highlights a risk of growth in the women and girls’ game,”Sign up to The BreakdownThe latest rugby union news and analysis, plus all the week's action reviewedafter newsletter promotionWhat about the RFU’s position on the world stage? Is it committed to growing the sport beyond traditional territories? Abdel Benazzi was the candidate for change at the recent election for the next World Rugby chairman but he lost out to Australia’s Brett Robinson, who was endorsed by the RFU,Robinson was the conservative candidate but Sweeney has found southern-hemisphere allies in the Australian and his namesake Mark, the chief executive of the New Zealand Rugby Union,Indeed, Sweeney and Mark Robinson have struck up quite the friendship,Robinson is 50, 17 years younger than Sweeney, and was an All Black, playing alongside Jonah Lomu.
On the topic of age, modernisation is another area in which the RFU has identified the need to improve.Twickenham is fast becoming a relic.After toying with a move to Wembley, then Birmingham, the union is committed to renovating Twickenham but it would cost £663m to overhaul the stadium entirely.Much faith, meanwhile, is being put in the RFU’s digital transformation programme and privately the union’s hierarchy acknowledges that the ageing profile of supporters, particularly match-goers, is chief among the threats to the sport’s future – on a par with the continuing brain injury litigation.Sweeney is smart enough to know what was coming his way upon release of Monday’s report.
He has felt the heat before, is likely to ride this out too and will see the strong prospect of an England Womenvictory at a home World Cup next year as too good an opportunity to let pass him by.At this stage, however, it is hard to see his legacy, whenever he does depart, being anything other than someone who was adept at surviving the storm.For £1.1m, it is not unreasonable to expect more.
Senior UK bankers will get bonuses years earlier under plan to relax rules
Senior UK bankers will receive their bonuses years earlier under plans by the Bank of England to relax post-financial crisis restrictions.The proposals are to reduce the bonus deferral period for some of the most senior bankers from eight years to five .Less senior bankers would get their bonuses after four years, in a further relaxation of the restrictions. Bankers would also be able to receive some of their bonus in the first year, instead of having to wait until the third year.In the EU, bankers’ bonuses are typically deferred for three to five years, while the US has no such restrictions
Donald Trump’s trade tariffs could cost US consumers $2,400 a year – business live
Two-thirds of Americans think Donald Trump’s tariff plans will only add to rising costs if implemented, and many are planning purchases ahead of his inauguration anticipating higher prices, according to a Harris poll conducted exclusively for the Guardian.Trump declared on Monday evening that he would impose 25% tariffs on all goods from Canada and Mexico, and an additional 10% on China, if they did not stop what he claimed was illegal immigration and fentanyl smuggling.But although he has called tariffs the most “beautiful word in the dictionary”, about 69% of Americans think tariffs on imports will lead to higher prices, according to the poll.The majority of Democrats (79%), independents (68%) and Republicans (59%) all believe that tariffs will increase the prices of the goods they pay for in the US. Nearly the same percentage of respondents said that tariffs will have a significant effect on what they can afford
How the far right is weaponising AI-generated content in Europe
From fake images designed to cause fears of an immigrant “invasion” to other demonisation campaigns targeted at leaders such as Emmanuel Macron, far-right parties and activists across western Europe are at the forefront of the political weaponisation of generative artificial intelligence technology.This year’s European parliamentary elections were the launchpad for a rollout of AI-generated campaigning by the European far right, experts say, which has continued to proliferate since.This month, the issue reached the independent oversight board of Mark Zuckerberg’s Meta when the body opened an investigation into anti-immigration content on Facebook. The inquiry by the oversight board will look at a post from a German account featuring an AI-generated image emblazoned with anti-immigrant rhetoric.It is part of a wave of AI-made rightwing content on social media networks
Oxford scientist resigns from Royal Society over Elon Musk’s continuing fellowship
A leading scientist at the University of Oxford has resigned from the UK’s national academy of sciences over concerns about Elon Musk’s continuing fellowship.Prof Dorothy Bishop, emeritus professor of developmental neuropsychology and a leading expert on children’s communication disorders, said she handed back her fellowship of the Royal Society last week.Bishop told the Guardian her move was a gut reaction, adding she had met the president and the chief executive after indicating her decision to resign, who stressed the need to follow due process over Musk.“I just started to think, you know, the Royal Society seemed to be set up to make it very, very difficult to ever get somebody to resign or to actually get thrown out, and given all I know about Musk, it felt grubby, to be honest,” she said.“It just felt having him in the Royal Society seemed such a contradiction of all the values of the Royal Society
Phillip Hughes: the loss of a daring and bright-eyed future is still keenly felt | Geoff Lemon
It’s tempting to say cricket is not important when thinking about Hughes’s death 10 years ago. But the loss of his career is symbolic of a broader lost futureSo here it is. 27 November, the centrepiece of a desperately sad sequence of dates. 25 November, the day 10 years ago when Phillip Hughes was struck by a cricket ball and hospitalised. 27 November, when his life support was ended as futile
World Chess Championship: Ding Liren leads Gukesh Dommaraju after Game 2 draw
Ding Liren was unable to stretch his World Chess Championship lead as Game 2 against Gukesh Dommaraju petered out to a 23-move draw in Singapore.Following victory in Game 1 for Ding, the defending champion, the scores now sit at Ding 1.5-0.5 Gukesh with up to 12 classical games remaining.Gukesh, playing Black, offered stiff defence and declared himself happy getting off the mark with the draw, which was settled after around three hours
Walmart to phase out DEI initiatives amid escalated attacks from conservatives
Female executive directors in FTSE 250 down 11% since 2022
FCA fines Macquarie Bank £13m for fictitious trades amid ‘serious failings’
UK prices for car repairs and electrical goods expected to rise due to budget
Philadelphia workers at Amazon’s Whole Foods file for first union election
Trump’s talk of tariffs raises fears of hit to economies worldwide