Fears for UK boomer radicalisation on Facebook after Meta drops factcheckers
Experts fear the decision by Meta to drop professional factcheckers from Facebook will exacerbate so-called boomer radicalisation in the UK.Even before what Keir Starmer described as “far-right riots” in England last summer, alarm bells were ringing amid fears older people were even more susceptible to misinformation and radicalisation than younger “digital natives”.Suspects were generally older than those charged in the 2011 unrest, according to a Guardian analysis of hundreds of defendants that found that as many as 35% were in their 40s or older.However, after Mark Zuckerberg announced last week that Meta would replace factcheckers with a crowdsourced system and recommend more political content, there is now new concern about the potential radicalisation risks on Facebook, the social media platform of choice for many older people.“It’s clearly a retrograde step that comes with all sorts of risks,” said Dr Sara Wilford of De Montfort University, a lead researcher on a pioneering Europe-wide project called Smidge (Social Media Narratives: Addressing Extremism in Middle Age).
“X might be the model for the crowdsourced ‘community notes’ approach that Meta seems to be embracing, instead of professional moderators, but it just won’t work in the same way with Facebook, which very much operates in little silos or closed groups,I’m concerned that, for middle-aged Facebook users who risk being exposed to extremist content, it will be even harder to discern the truth,”The anti-extremism campaign group Hope not Hate also told the Guardian it feared Zuckerberg’s announcement was a prelude to far-right figures and groups, such as Tommy Robinson and Britain First, being allowed back on to Facebook,Britain First proved particularly adept at using the platform before it was banned, amassing 2m likes – at that stage surpassing Labour (1m) and the Conservatives (650,000),In terms of perpetrators of crime, young men still account for the majority of culprits.
Yet before the riots, discussion about boomer radicalisation had already been sparked by cases such as Darren Osborne, who was 48 when he was jailed in 2018 for his lethal terror attack at a mosque in north London’s Finsbury Park, having been, in the words of the judge, “rapidly radicalised” online.Another man, Andrew Leak, was 66 when he firebombed a Dover migrant centre in 2022 in what police described as an “extreme rightwing” attack, later killing himself but leaving behind an internet history riddled with racism.When it came to the riots, Hope not Hate said Facebook was used in a particular way by the far right, in contrast to other platforms.“Telegram was for whipping up the most extreme hate, or sometimes plotting and planning, while X was used to to disseminate that message,” said Joe Mulhall, the anti-racism campaign group’s director of research.“Facebook was then often where you would see a group creating hyperlocal targeted content, with a page popping up around a specific event.
We’ve also seen over the last three to four years that anti-migrant protest Facebook groups were really fundamental in organising the targeting of asylum centres.”Users of such pages often skew older, in line with broader Facebook usage.An Ofcom report last year found that overall, social media users were most likely to describe Facebook as their main social media site (48%), but added: “This was driven by its significant popularity among older social media users.” It also warned that older adults were less likely to recognise a fake social media profile.Wilford said her research suggested some older Facebook users were often particularly vulnerable, for reasons including a reluctance to factcheck and a tendency to trust online content at face value when it came packaged like conventional news output.
Sign up to First EditionOur morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what’s happening and why it mattersafter newsletter promotion“We are also talking about people – an invisible generation – sometimes looking back on a life that might not have been as they wanted it to be, whether it was their job or social conditions,” she added,“But when they go online and interact with other Facebook users, they are embracing an echo chamber that makes them feel good,They’re listened to and find validation,”The problem of misinformation seeping through to Facebook groups devoted to everyday life has drawn a response from some councils, which have devoted resources to training members of the public who moderate on local community groups,But Britain’s seismic political events of recent years have also transformed the Facebook experience for many whose first innocent interactions may have been sharing pictures with family or posting neighbourhood news.
Brexit, Trump’s 2016 win and the Covid pandemic acted as catalysts for engagement with more extreme forms of rightwing politics via Facebook, according to Dr Natalie-Anne Hall, a lecturer at Cardiff University and author of Brexit, Facebook, and Transnational Right-Wing Populism.“Facebook is a key site for algorithmically driven encounters with these harmful ideas within people’s everyday practices of social media use.Meta should be doing more, not less, to combat this harm,” she said.“Zuckerberg’s comments and Meta’s new position on this issue will only serve to embolden the misplaced sense of victimhood among those with antiprogressive views that research has shown feeds into radicalisation.”When asked to comment on the concerns about misinformation and extremism, Meta referred to a blogpost, which said its “complex systems” to manage content had “gone too far”.
How to politicize the truth on Facebook, Instagram, and Wikipedia
Hello, and welcome back to TechScape. Last Tuesday, I predicted Meta would enter a new political era after the departure of Nick Clegg. Two hours after I published last week’s newsletter, Mark Zuckerberg declared that the new conservative phase would begin. It was sooner and more brazen than I had expected – and faster-paced. Zuckerberg announced he would disband Meta’s US fact-checking operation because he believes his fact-checkers have been too politically biased
Google investigated by UK watchdog over search dominance
Google is being investigated by the UK competition watchdog over the impact of its search and advertising practices on consumers, news publishers, businesses and rival search engines.The tech company accounts for more than 90% of general searches in the UK, according to the Competition and Markets Authority.The CMA estimates that search advertising costs the equivalent of nearly £500 for each UK household a year, which could be kept down with effective competition.The watchdog announced on Tuesday it will investigate if Google is blocking competitors from entering the market, and whether it is engaging in “potential exploitative conduct” by the mass collection of consumers’ data without informed consent.It will also investigate whether Google is using its position as the pre-eminent search engine to give an unfair advantage to its own shopping and travel services
Amazon makes ‘largest ever’ UK order of electric trucks to cut carbon emissions
Amazon is to deploy nearly 150 electric heavy goods vehicles as well as piling packages on to trains and post-style trolleys in an effort to reduce the carbon footprint of delivering goods in the UK.The tech company said it had bought more than 140 electric Mercedes-Benz heavy goods vehicles (HGVs) and eight Volvo lorries – which it says is the UK’s biggest order of electric trucks – that can take loads of up to 40 tonnes.The vehicles will hit the road over the next 18 months, increasing the online retailer’s electric HGV fleet from nine at present.The US-owned company’s switch to electric logistics is partly funded by the government under its zero emission HGV and infrastructure demonstrator programme (ZEHID). Amazon plans to install fast-charging points across its UK network to keep the trucks in action
Ministers consider ban on all UK public bodies making ransomware payments
Schools, the NHS and local councils will be banned from making ransomware payments under government proposals to tackle hackers.In a crackdown on such cyber-attacks, operators of critical national infrastructure will be barred from bowing to demands when criminal gangs hold IT systems hostage.Payouts by private companies will have to be reported to the government and could be blocked if they are made to sanctioned groups or foreign states. Reporting ransomware attacks will also be made mandatory if the proposals become law.The plans, described by one expert as “the most significant intervention against ransomware by any national government to date”, will bring other public bodies into line with government departments, which are already banned from making payments
Meta’s ditching of factcheckers is potentially dangerous and a disservice | Letters
Meta’s move to scrap factcheckers is not about “complexity”, as it says (Report, 8 January), but to support Donald Trump and Elon Musk’s agenda.It is widely agreed that effective, fast and unbiased factchecking is essential for the proper functioning of social media platforms. Similarly, principles of free speech are foundational to fostering communication and public debate in a healthy democratic society. Mark Zuckerberg’s announcement that Meta is to follow X in introducing user-generated notes raises serious concerns.The shift will intensify pressures on vulnerable groups, including children, minorities, gender rights advocates and LGBTQ+ communities, who are already targeted by hate speech
Water shortage fears as Labour’s first AI growth zone sited close to new reservoir
Labour’s first artificial intelligence growth zone will be sited close to the UK’s first new reservoir in 30 years, sparking fears that the AI push will add to the “severe pressure” on water supplies in the area.Keir Starmer announced on Monday that he would hugely increase artificial intelligence capacity and reduce planning restrictions on companies that wanted to build datacentres by setting up “growth zones” with fewer constraints.The first of these will be in Culham, Oxfordshire, only seven miles from a reservoir planned by Thames Water in Abingdon, which was supposed to provide water to people in the severely water-stressed south-east of England. This is the area of the country most at risk of running out of water, according to the Environment Agency. Oxfordshire has faced particular issues, with areas reliant on bottled water during heatwaves
Wellcome Trust charity criticised over £11m in payouts to investment team
Warhammer maker Games Workshop plans fourth UK factory as sales boom
Could Keir Starmer’s AI dream derail his own green energy promise?
British novelists criticise government over AI ‘theft’
Borthwick backs ‘world-class’ Itoje as England captain after stripping George
Alex de Minaur brings main character energy in Australian Open straight-sets win