Timid FCA has retreated too far on its ‘name and shame’ proposals
Lobbying victories for the City do not come much more comprehensive.Last year, the Financial Conduct Authority, the industry regulator, put forward a proposal that it should be able to name firms under investigation more frequently.Greater openness at an earlier stage, argued the FCA, could deter bad behaviour and protect consumers.A “public interest” test on disclosure would be better than the existing “exceptional circumstances” rule that was so stifling that the FCA was silent even as British Steel pensioners, in a well-publicised scandal in 2017, were fleeced by unscrupulous financial advisers who gave them terrible advice.But the uproar from City firms and lawyers over the FCA’s proposals was loud and persistent.
They painted the plans as an offence against natural justice.Mere disclosure of an investigation could harm a company’s reputation even if it was found eventually to be innocent – and 65% of FCA’s cases, they noted, have historically resulted in no further action.The “name and shame” shorthand for the proposals stuck.The lobbyists’ trump card was the familiar one that the FCA would damage the City’s competitiveness and UK growth.Ministers, under the last Tory government and today’s Labour one, adopted the line.
Thus the outcome on Tuesday of the FCA’s review of “transparency around enforcement investigations” was expected: reform is scrapped.The only surviving elements are ones nobody could possibly have regarded as objectionable, such as ending the absurdity whereby the FCA could not confirm the fact of an investigation even when the corporate subject of the inquiry had itself revealed the news in a public filing to an overseas regulator.Otherwise, it’s a full retreat by the FCA.“Given the lack of consensus,” said its chief executive, Nikhil Rathi, the regulator will stick to its old “exceptional circumstances” test.Some of the City’s criticisms were reasonable, it should be said.
The FCA’s initial proposals were vague on how the “public interest” bar would be applied.While the regulator obviously wasn’t going to risk a run on a bank, there wasn’t much else to go on.And it was true that few other jurisdictions had attempted anything similar, which left the door open to the grumble about London imposing anti-competitive rules on itself.Yet one still comes back to cases such as the British Steel pension scheme.Even City opponents of the FCA’s proposal tended to concede it was a nonsense that the regulator felt it couldn’t intervene to prevent a small scandal becoming a big one.
Is the FCA seriously saying it would have to do the same again in a similar case? It seems it is.Rathi confirmed that “our current interpretation” is that a British Steel-like example still wouldn’t qualify under the “exceptional circumstance” bar.The reason is that poor financial advice doesn’t count as “exceptional”.That is a depressing outcome to this consultation.Even an uncontentious, minor consumer-friendly improvement has been lost for the sake of protecting City competitiveness.
No wonder consumer and whistleblowing groups are dismayed.The only token tilt in their direction is the FCA’s idea of publishing occasional thoughts on “issues” under investigation without naming names.But that reads as a formula for talking in code.It is all a very long way from the original intention to use greater transparency to “support public confidence” and “reassure consumers”.Sign up to Business TodayGet set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morningafter newsletter promotionThe FCA’s hand, one can agree, was forced if the government of the day is opposed.
And, yes, growth obviously matters: in another corner of its patch, the FCA’s reforms to listing rules for public companies have generally been pragmatic.But consumer protections are also important.A watered-down compromise version of the transparency proposals should have been possible.Instead, there’s nothing left.
Elon Musk claims ‘massive cyber-attack’ caused X outages
Elon Musk claimed on Monday afternoon that X was targeted in a “massive cyber-attack” that resulted in the intermittent service outages that had brought down his social network throughout the day. The platform, formerly known as Twitter, had been unresponsive for many users as posts failed to load.“We get attacked every day, but this was done with a lot of resources,” the platform’s CEO posted. “Either a large, coordinated group and/or a country is involved.”Downdetector, a website that monitors outages on various sites and platforms, showed thousands of reports of outages that initially spiked at about 5
The making of Elon Musk: how did his childhood in apartheid South Africa shape him?
The billionaire and now Trump adviser grew up amid the collapse of white rule, attending an all-white school and then a more liberal oneWith an imposing double-winged redbrick main building, and school songs lifted directly from Harrow’s songbook, Pretoria boys high school is every inch the South African mirror of the English private schools it was founded in 1901 to imitate.Elon Musk, who has rapidly become one of the most powerful people in US politics, spent his final school years in the 1980s as a day pupil on the lush, tree-filled campus in South Africa’s capital, close to his father’s large detached home in Waterkloof, a wealthy Pretoria suburb shaded by purple jacaranda blossoms in spring.South Africa was rocked by uprisings as apartheid entered its dying years. In 1984, black townships across the country revolted. By 1986, the white minority government had imposed a state of emergency
Skype shutdown surfaces sweet memories: ‘I proposed marriage’
Microsoft announced on the last day of February that it would sunset Skype. By the time the death knell tolled, the video chatting software that once revolutionized communications had become a ghost of its former self. Experts chimed in with half-hearted eulogies for the platform that Microsoft spent years neglecting, yet few were surprised, and even fewer shed tears.The Guardian’s journalism is independent. We will earn a commission if you buy something through an affiliate link
Who bought this smoked salmon? How ‘AI agents’ will change the internet (and shopping lists)
Autonomous digital assistants are being developed that can carry out tasks on behalf of the user – including ordering the groceries. But if you don’t keep an eye on them, dinner might not be quite what you expect …I’m watching artificial intelligence order my groceries. Armed with my shopping list, it types each item into the search bar of a supermarket website, then uses its cursor to click. Watching what appears to be a digital ghost do this usually mundane task is strangely transfixing. “Are you sure it’s not just a person in India?” my husband asks, peering over my shoulder
Internet shutdowns at record high in Africa as access ‘weaponised’
Digital blackouts reached a record high in 2024 in Africa as more governments sought to keep millions of citizens off the internet than in any other period over the last decade.A report released by the internet rights group Access Now and #KeepItOn, a coalition of hundreds of civil society organisations worldwide, found there were 21 shutdowns in 15 African countries, surpassing the existing record of 19 shutdowns in 2020 and 2021.Authorities in Comoros, Guinea-Bissau and Mauritius joined repeat offenders such as Burundi, Ethiopia, Equatorial Guinea and Kenya. Guinea, Nigeria, Senegal and Tanzania were also on the list. But perpetrators also included militias and other non-state actors
Skype got shouted down by Teams and Zoom. But it revolutionised human connection | John Naughton
So Microsoft has decided to terminate Skype, the internet telephony company it bought in 2011 for $8.5bn (£6.6bn). Its millions of hapless users are to be herded into Microsoft Teams, a virtual encampment with a brain-dead aesthetic that makes even Zoom look cool. This eventuality had been telegraphed for quite a while but, even so, it comes as a jolt because Skype was a remarkable venture, and its demise closes a chapter of an interesting strand of technological history
Poor results at Puma and Zara owner fuel fears of slowing US consumer demand
Timid FCA has retreated too far on its ‘name and shame’ proposals
ChatGPT firm reveals AI model that is ‘good at creative writing’
iPhone 16e review: Apple’s cheapest new phone
Borthwick deserves credit after bold selection for England’s Wales test
Steve Borthwick may use three fly-halves for Six Nations finale in Wales