Telegram fined nearly $1m by Australian watchdog for delay in reporting about terrorism and child abuse material

A picture


Encrypted messaging app Telegram has been fined nearly $1m by Australia’s online safety regulator for failing to respond on time to questions about what the company does to tackle terrorism and child abuse material on its platform.The notice was issued to Telegram, among other companies, in May last year, with a deadline to report back in October on steps taken to address terrorist and violent extremism material, as well as child exploitation material on its platform.Sign up for Guardian Australia’s breaking news emailBecause Telegram failed to respond for nearly 160 days, eSafety has issued an infringement notice to the company for A$957,780.“If we want accountability from the tech industry we need much greater transparency.These powers give us a look under the hood at just how these platforms are dealing, or not dealing, with a range of serious and egregious online harms which affect Australians,” the eSafety commissioner, Julie Inman Grant, said in a statement.

“Telegram took 160 days to provide information that was asked in the reporting notice and providing this information so late has obstructed eSafety from delivering its functions under the Online Safety Act for almost half a year.”A joint statement by the Five Eyes security agencies, including the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation and the Australian federal police, last year named Telegram as one platform through which young people were accessing extremist propaganda videos.“Research and observation have shown us that this material can normalise, desensitise and sometimes radicalise – especially the young who are viewing harmful material online that they cannot unsee,” Inman Grant said.Telegram has 28 days to request the withdrawal of the infringement notice, pay the infringement notice, or seek an extension to pay the infringement notice.A spokesperson for Telegram described the penalty as “unfair and disproportionate” and said the company intends to appeal.

If Telegram does not pay the fine, the commissioner could take other action, including seeking civil penalties in the federal court.Telegram has signalled its willingness to be more cooperative with regulators across the globe after the company’s CEO, Pavel Durov, was arrested in France in August last year and charged with several counts of failing to curb extremist and terrorist content.He remains on bail and has been banned from leaving France until the case is heard.Wired reported this month it could be a year before the case goes to court.Since Durov’s arrest, Telegram has begun releasing transparency reports for its responses to law enforcement requests.

According to the most recent report, for 2024, Telegram fulfilled 14 requests for IP address and/or telephone number information from Australian law enforcement, affecting 23 users.The eSafety report containing the responses from Telegram, Meta, WhatsApp, Google and Reddit will be released in early March.When Elon Musk’s X was given a notice to provide similar information, it appealed against the decision to the Administrative Review Tribunal, with the case still ongoing.In a different set of cases in the federal court, eSafety fined X more than $610,000 for failing to adequately respond to notices, and took X to court, while X also sued over the notices.The cases are ongoing.

politicsSee all
A picture

Calls to toughen Lords rules as it is revealed one in 10 peers are paid for political advice

Ninety-one members of the House of Lords have been paid by commercial companies to give political or policy advice, amid concerns that their activities are not being properly regulated.Analysis by the Guardian shows that more than one in 10 peers have taken payments from businesses such as lobbyists and companies operating in the banking, defence and energy sectors. Peers can earn tens of thousands of pounds a year for such roles.They include the former Conservative health minister Andrew Lansley and the ex-Labour home secretary David Blunkett.The Guardian’s analysis found 91 members of the Lords were being paid for their political advice by organisations such as Santander bank, the French arms manufacturer Thales and the British digger-maker JCB

A picture

Revealed: how members of House of Lords benefit from commercial interests

A Guardian investigation into the House of Lords raises questions over the accountability of parliament’s second chamber, with revelations about how a string of peers are benefiting from commercial interests.One in 10 members have been hired to give political or policy advice, according to their own declarations, and others do paid work for companies that could conflict with their role as legislators. The findings expose weaknesses in the Lords code of conduct and raise questions about whether the rules on lobbying and paid employment should be tightened in line with restrictions signed up to by MPs.The investigation sheds new light on the extent to which money flows into politics from those who hold peerages or go on to secure them, with more than £100m given to the three main parties over the last two decades, much of it by a small group of influential super-donors.Many members of the Lords make a valuable contribution to its main purpose of refining and scrutinising legislation

A picture

Starmer and Macron agree to show ‘united leadership in support of Ukraine’

Keir Starmer and Emmanuel Macron have agreed to show “united leadership in support of Ukraine” when they separately meet Donald Trump this week.The UK prime minister and the French president spoke on Sunday afternoon to reiterate the importance of Ukraine being at the centre of any negotiations to end the war, Downing Street said.Their call before an important week for both leaders highlights their desire to present a united European position against Russia’s aggression, after the US president launched extraordinary attacks on Volodymyr Zelenskyy, dismissing the president of Ukraine as a “dictator without elections”.The prime minister appeared determined to have vital discussions with allies before his Washington visit: he also spoke to Justin Trudeau, the prime minister of Canada, and Mark Rutte, the Nato secretary general, on Sunday night.Starmer and Rutte agreed “there could be no negotiations about Ukraine, without Ukraine”, and noted the importance of European leaders stepping up to ensure the security of the region, Downing Street said

A picture

Starmer condemns Farage and Reform UK for ‘fawning over Putin’

Keir Starmer has condemned Nigel Farage and Reform UK for talking the language of workers’ rights online but wanting to charge people to use the NHS and for “fawning over Putin”.The prime minister said Labour must be ready for the test Farage’s party presents, saying there had been a rise in “dangerous rightwing politics” and those who claim to be seeking to “tilt politics towards the interests of working people”.Speaking to the Scottish Labour conference in Glasgow, Starmer announced a £200m investment for the Grangemouth oil refinery, which is expected to go towards creating a new industrial purpose for the site. It is scheduled to close in the summer with a loss of more than 400 jobs.However, the prime minister also used his address on Sunday to attack Reform UK’s politics, hours after the US president, Donald Trump, had praised Farage as a “great guy” when addressing the Conservative Political Action Conference at the National Harbor in Maryland

A picture

Keir Starmer pledges £200m for Grangemouth oil refinery site

Keir Starmer has announced £200m in funding to boost investment at Grangemouth oil refinery, which is closing down with the loss of more than 400 jobs.The prime minister said the national wealth fund would provide £200m in state investment for up to five companies who moved to Grangemouth, where several thousand jobs in the wider supply chain are also at risk. He said that should leverage up to £600m more in private investment.Speaking to reporters after his announcement at Scottish Labour’s annual conference, he rejected suggestions this had come too late for the scores of Grangemouth workers recently given redundancy notices, or those who will be laid off in the coming months.He said Labour had acted as quickly as it could, but it took time to work up a credible proposal

A picture

Starmer unlikely to unveil plan for rise in defence spending this week, says minister

Keir Starmer is unlikely to set out a plan this week for when the UK will increase its defence spending to 2.5% of GDP, a cabinet minister has indicated.The education secretary, Bridget Phillipson, said the target was ambitious, despite Labour previously claiming it would set out a path to meeting the spending goal after the strategic defence review in the spring.The prime minister will meet Donald Trump at the White House on Thursday amid strained relations between Washington and the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy.The US president added to the tensions on Friday when he said that Starmer and the French president, Emmanuel Macron, “haven’t done anything” to end the war in Ukraine, after his claims that Zelenskyy was a dictator