Scottish Greens table amendment to scrap king’s stamp duty exemption

A picture


Opposition politicians in Scotland have called for King Charles to lose his unique exemption from paying stamp duty on his property transactions,The Scottish Green party has tabled changes to a housing bill which would require the king to pay tax on any new property he buys in Scotland in the same way as all other property buyers would,Under a longstanding convention, British monarchs are exempt from paying taxes, including on their personal income, shareholdings, inheritances, property transactions or business income from their extensive private estates,However, the king voluntarily pays the standard rate of income tax on some of his personal income, and capital gains tax,The royal household would not comment on the Scottish Green proposals but said he also pays local property rates voluntarily.

The king personally owns more than 80 houses in Scotland on his extensive private estates at Balmoral and Delnadamph in the Highlands, as well as Balmoral castle itself, his holiday retreat at Birkhall, and part of a Georgian townhouse in Edinburgh,He inherited the properties after the queen died but he did not pay inheritance tax,The estates and houses are conservatively estimated to be worth at least £80m and are run on his behalf by a private trust,Ross Greer, the Scottish Greens’ finance spokesperson and a republican, said the royal family ought to pay the same taxes as everyone else,“The Scottish Greens would obviously scrap the monarchy in a heartbeat, but even royalists must agree that this is an absurd and undeserved perk for someone more than capable of paying his fair share towards our public services,” he said.

“The Scottish parliament may not have the power to end every tax perk enjoyed by the Windsors, but we can end this one and set an example for the UK government to follow.”Greer’s amendment would delete a section of the Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Scotland) Act 2013, which controls property sales taxes in Scotland, to remove the part which states: “Nothing in this act affects [his] majesty in [his] private capacity.”A Scottish government spokesperson confirmed that Greer’s proposals will be considered by MSPs during the local government’s committee’s review of the bill during stage 2 of its passage through Holyrood.Under the Scottish system, anyone buying a home worth more than £145,000 pays a transactions tax of 5-12%, depending on its value, as well as an additional dwelling supplement for second homes or rental properties.Votes of this kind are very rare in any UK legislature but Holyrood has slowly begun reforming how it approaches the royal family’s constitutional privileges.

Ministers must now tell MSPs at an early stage if the king has been allowed to vet a new bill in advance, often to ensure the monarch is personally exempt from that legislation,This mechanism is known as crown consent,This follows a Guardian investigation which found the then queen had personally vetted at least 67 pieces of Scottish legislation; Scottish civil servants admitted some had been amended to secure her approval,
politicsSee all
A picture

MPs should not do media work that ‘monetises’ their role, says government

The government has backed proposals to stop MPs taking second jobs they have been offered because of their role in parliament, and expressed concern that some paid media roles allow them to “monetise” their privileged positions.It set out its detailed thinking on how the rules could be tightened on MPs’ outside interests in evidence to the House of Commons standards committee.The policy statement said it supported asking MPs to sign up to certain principles, as suggested by the parliamentary standards commissioner, Daniel Greenberg.In particular it favours a draft principle saying: “Members are expected not to accept offers of paid outside interests that are made, or that a reasonable observer might think are being made, primarily because of their membership of the house.”The government also said it had concerns about some instances in which MPs were paid by the media

A picture

Badenoch declines to criticise Jenrick over Reform coalition comments – as it happened

Kemi Badenoch has not criticised Robert Jenrick, or disciplined him, over his comments about the possible need for a Conservative/Reform UK “coalition” by the time of the next election. (See 9.04am.)Speaking at a post-PMQs briefing, Badenoch’s spokesperson said the Tory leader “agrees” with Jenrick that that “we need to bring centre-right voters together”.Asked about Badenoch’s reaction to the Sky News report about what Jenrick said, Badenoch’s spokesperson said:She took his words at face value

A picture

Russia imposes sanctions on 15 UK MPs over ‘hostile statements’

Russia has imposed sanctions on 15 UK MPs and six members of the House of Lords, banning them from the country over what it called “hostile statements and unfounded accusations” about Moscow.The Russian foreign affairs ministry published a statement on Wednesday accusing the UK of “fabricating anti-Russian narratives” and attempting to “demonise” the country.The ministry announced sanctions against 21 British politicians from across the political spectrum, targeting parliamentarians who have called for frozen Russian assets to be seized and used to fund Ukraine’s war effort.Those hit with sanctions include Labour’s Phil Brickell, Jeevun Sandher, Johanna Baxter and Blair McDougall, and the Liberal Democrats’ Alistair Carmichael, Chris Coghlan, Helen Maguire and James MacCleary.Stephen Gethins, of the Scottish National party, and Jim Shannon, of the Democratic Unionist party, are also on the list

A picture

Labour must do the right thing on two-child benefit cap | Letters

If ministers are “privately ruling out” scrapping the two-child social security limit in part because polls suggest that voters support it, that is profoundly depressing (Ministers privately ruling out scrapping two-child benefits cap, 21 April). Tony Blair once observed that politicians face a tension between wooing and leading the electorate. This is an issue on which to lead.If voters see the two-child limit as “a matter of fairness”, as claimed, we have a responsibility to explain why it is so unfair on children and on their parents, both in and out of work. While lifting the two-child limit is not a sufficient condition for eradicating child poverty, it is a necessary condition

A picture

UK overtures to China worry Hongkongers | Letter

As a Hongkonger with a British national (overseas) – BNO – passport who is now living in Britain, I read your editorial about the UK’s evolving position on China with both personal and political weight (The Guardian view on UK-China relations: a dilemma made sharper by Brexit, 16 April). For many of us who left Hong Kong following the imposition of the national security law, the threat from the ruling regime was not abstract – it was immediate, personal and existential.Our migration was not simply a search for better opportunities but a necessary departure from a city whose freedoms were being rapidly dismantled.The UK’s cautious recalibration of its relationship with Beijing raises complex emotions. On one hand, I understand the economic pressures that compel governments to engage with China

A picture

Scottish Greens table amendment to scrap king’s stamp duty exemption

Opposition politicians in Scotland have called for King Charles to lose his unique exemption from paying stamp duty on his property transactions.The Scottish Green party has tabled changes to a housing bill which would require the king to pay tax on any new property he buys in Scotland in the same way as all other property buyers would.Under a longstanding convention, British monarchs are exempt from paying taxes, including on their personal income, shareholdings, inheritances, property transactions or business income from their extensive private estates.However, the king voluntarily pays the standard rate of income tax on some of his personal income, and capital gains tax. The royal household would not comment on the Scottish Green proposals but said he also pays local property rates voluntarily