Cochlear implants make a useful addition to sign language | Letters
As a deaf researcher focused on language deprivation among deaf individuals, I am often asked about cochlear implants and their role in the lives of deaf children (The cochlear question: as the parent of a deaf baby, should I give her an implant to help her hear?, 11 December),While cochlear implants are a technological tool that provides access to sound, the critical issue is not the implant itself, but the decision to exclude signed languages from a deaf child’s upbringing,Language is a fundamental human right and the foundation of cognitive, social and emotional development,For deaf children, access to a visual language – such as American Sign Language or British Sign Language (BSL) – is essential, particularly in the early years when the brain is most receptive to language acquisition,Without this access, many deaf children can face significant delays in language development, which leads to lifelong challenges in education, employment and mental health.
Cochlear implants are not guaranteed to provide complete access to spoken language, and outcomes can vary significantly based on factors such as the child’s age at implantation, the quality of auditory training, and individual differences in how the brain processes sound,Even when cochlear implants are successful, it does not create effortless acquisition of language and they should not replace a robust foundation in a signed language,Research shows that bilingualism in both a signed and spoken language enhances cognitive flexibility, academic achievement and social integration,Introducing a signed language does not hinder spoken language development; rather, it does the opposite, while also providing a safety net that ensures the child always has a fully accessible language,Parents face complex decisions, but they should not be pressured to choose between cochlear implants or a signed language.
Both can coexist, offering a holistic approach that respects the child’s potential and humanity,My hope is for families and professionals to prioritise the child’s linguistic rights and wellbeing, fostering a world where no deaf child experiences language deprivation,Dr Wyatte HallAssistant professor of public health sciences, University of Rochester Medical Center, New York, US Thank you for Abi Stephenson’s article on cochlear implants,My wife and I are proud parents to four children, the eldest three who were born profoundly deaf,Our local hospital, Addenbrooke’s in Cambridge, was amazing in the support we were given as parents and the support our children received.
We were set on the cochlear implant (CI) route when they were infants and all three were implanted before their fourth birthdays.It was a difficult decision given the thinning of the skull surgery required for the computer element and the invasive surgery that went with the insertion of the implant itself.We agonised over the decision.Would our older children resent our choices for their lives? The internet was in its infancy and of little comfort.Opposition to CI was vociferous, from the US especially.
We figured, as the article states, that we were providing optional doors in later life for our infant children, which they could choose to open or close as adults.Two decades later, our children are all successful in their lives.They all sign.They all speak.They all access the hearing world but enjoy and thrive in their deaf communities.
My eldest daughter has passed her level 6 BSL course and my youngest daughter, who was born hearing, is finishing her degree this year as a speech and language therapist.So many parents of deaf children have to go through hoops unimaginable for most parents: the lack of invitations to birthday parties in primary years; the Sat exams not entered for; the lack of ambition from careers advisers; and the aiming-low mentality of many.The loneliness of deaf children at times is heartbreaking.Did we make the right decisions? Our children’s lives suggest so, but after all these years my wife and I still have many moments of guilt.Simon GairSteeple Bumpstead, Essex Abi Stephenson fully understood the difficulty of choosing whether a young child should be given a cochlear implant.
Essentially, the issue of choosing for her to be Deaf (those who use signing and identify with the Deaf community) or deaf (those with a hearing impairment who communicate orally).I recognise and respect those who choose to be Deaf and recognise the richness and value of sign languages.As a deaf person, I received a great deal of support that allowed me to undertake full‑time education as an older adult in a creative career, allowing me an equal experience.I received a cochlear implant as an older adult.I had worked and lived among hearing people with increasing levels of deafness for years.
From my own experience, I found it possible to live a full and fulfilled life in the hearing world but it needed a good deal of effort and adaptation from both myself and those I worked and lived with,Even with support it was exhausting,One issue that is rarely highlighted is the primary effect of deafness on engagement and relationships with others,It is my relationships with other people, hearing or deaf, at every level, that have been revolutionised by my cochlear implant, not just my ability to hear music (the most difficult) and to hear surrounding noise,Ruth HoltHalesworth, Suffolk Abi Stephenson’s article was a compelling long read, and I am glad her daughter is thriving with her implant.
Since 1980, I have been involved in the Deaf scene with a son who lost his hearing to meningitis at five months,In the 1980s, cochlear implants were in their infancy,An ENT consultant confirmed the deafness, suspected by an astute young nurse on the isolation ward, and said Tom would go on a list to be one of the first to receive one in 10 years’ time,Sounded good to us, naive as we were,Without the peripatetic teacher of the Deaf assigned to us, we would have been left floundering.
Signing was suggested and Tom’s language became the delight it remains to this day,He could play his rightful part alongside his brothers in a hearing family and our local community,As a teenager, Tom requested an implant, which took years and much pressurising of the NHS to be fitted just before his GCSEs,Many of the sometimes contentious points Abi describes are ones I considered for his biography,Generations of deaf families hand down Deaf culture and their beautiful BSL within the Deaf community – but his sudden deafness did not mean our son inherited that world.
I agree with Tom Bertling’s warning in his A Child Sacrificed to the Deaf Culture that “parents should cast a cautious eye towards anyone wanting to sacrifice a deaf child towards preserving a culture”.Our son embraces both worlds and his three hearing children are bilingual – which says it all.Jenny FroudeAuthor of Making Sense in Sign: A Lifeline for a Deaf Child Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication in our letters section.
Arno Rabinowitz obituary
My father, Arno Rabinowitz, who has died aged 90, was a pioneering educational psychologist and a widely admired mentor, counsellor and confidant. His existence was down to a confluence of luck: his mother, Tilly, was one of three siblings evacuated from eastern Europe in the early 1920s during the pogroms against Jews. These three were “Ochberg Orphans”, fortunate recipients of the philanthropy of another émigré, the industrialist Isaac Ochberg, who enabled Jewish orphans to emigrate to safety in South Africa.Arno was born in Johannesburg, to Tilly (nee Abrahams) and Danny Rabinowitz, a hotelier. He went to school at Highlands North in Johannesburg and later studied English and politics at the University of the Witwatersrand in the 1950s
Cochlear implants make a useful addition to sign language | Letters
As a deaf researcher focused on language deprivation among deaf individuals, I am often asked about cochlear implants and their role in the lives of deaf children (The cochlear question: as the parent of a deaf baby, should I give her an implant to help her hear?, 11 December). While cochlear implants are a technological tool that provides access to sound, the critical issue is not the implant itself, but the decision to exclude signed languages from a deaf child’s upbringing.Language is a fundamental human right and the foundation of cognitive, social and emotional development. For deaf children, access to a visual language – such as American Sign Language or British Sign Language (BSL) – is essential, particularly in the early years when the brain is most receptive to language acquisition. Without this access, many deaf children can face significant delays in language development, which leads to lifelong challenges in education, employment and mental health
Breaking the social care reform logjam | Letters
The “deep reform” that social care needs (Editorial, 3 December) must break the cycle of short-term fixes and insufficient funding, which leaves the sector in a perpetual state of uncertainty – forever playing the role of Oliver Twist asking for more, yet lacking long-term security.A better-funded version of the current system won’t suffice to address the profound demographic, societal and technological shifts shaping the future. Having helped steer the Care Act into law and set up the Dilnot commission, I know how challenging it is to get long‑term reform agreed upon.Landing the cap on lifetime care costs proved nearly impossible during my time as a minister. A workable solution fell victim to a classic case of “making the best the enemy of the good”, with no consensus on what “best” meant
The Guardian view on the victims of conflict: at the end of a brutal year they need support | Editorial
Wars in Gaza, Sudan, Ukraine and elsewhere have made 2024 a brutal and bloody 12 months. For this year’s Guardian and Observer appeal, in aid of three conflict-linked charities, we are asking readers to give out of compassion for those affected, and in the hope of promoting peace in a safer world. As well as alleviating immediate suffering, and saving lives, our voluntary-sector partners play a vital role in helping to restore civil society in places where it is devastated by conflict. Their work with children, in particular, is essential to efforts to build a better future.The year began with fierce fighting and mass displacements in southern Gaza
Pat Milner obituary
My friend Pat Milner, who has died aged 91, was one of the first student counsellors in the UK. Her career started in 1965 when she applied for a pioneering diploma course at Reading University.In a 2001 interview with her former colleague Stephen Palmer, she described it as a “road to Damascus experience”. “For the first term, I believed the theories of this man, Carl Rogers, were ludicrous and would never work,” she said. “What did he mean ‘really listen’? Of course we listened! In practice, genuineness, warmth and empathy opened up a new world of human understanding
Pop-up heart-health hubs sought for Premier League clubs in England
Premier League football clubs across England could soon offer fans a one-stop clinic, designed to scan, diagnose and treat some early signs of cardiovascular disease after a successful screening pilot.Almost one in three football supporters screened at Everton football club’s pop-up clinic this autumn were diagnosed with hypertension, the leading preventable risk factor for heart failure, heart attack and stroke.Almost one in five of those diagnosed were discovered to require emergency hospitalisation, which was averted by the immediate prescription of life-saving drugs.“We were able to test, diagnose and provide vital medication within 60 minutes – a process that can take up to six months in the NHS,” said Dr Rajiv Sankaranarayanan, consultant cardiologist and clinical lead for the Beat Breathlessness Hub, run with the Everton in the Community charity.Fans received a blood test, an AI echo heart scan and a specialist review
Smartphones are an unwelcome distraction | Letters
Elon Musk showcases grip on Washington by impeding spending bill
Man who falsely claimed to be bitcoin creator sentenced for continuing to sue developers
Why are Amazon workers on strike – and what does it mean for Christmas deliveries?
AI learns to distinguish between aromas of US and Scottish whiskies
UK arts and media reject plan to let AI firms use copyrighted material