Concern over ‘asbis’ after report finds people jailed for sleeping rough and feeding birds
Almost 250 people have been imprisoned for breaching antisocial behaviour injunctions (asbis) since 2020, with people being jailed for sleeping rough, begging, feeding birds and making a noise.Analysis from academics at the universities of York and Coventry found that out of 242 cases examined from 2020-2024, there were 72 cases of imprisonment for general nuisance, 61 for abusive language and 51 for noise.They found that 57% of people did not have legal representation at the breach hearing that led to their imprisonment: out of 97 recorded cases, 55 defendants were not represented.“People are not getting proper representation and they get sent to prison for sometimes long periods, weeks and months.There’s no sentencing guidance for this,” said Prof Caroline Hunter from York Law School.
“People might have a lot of issues that need to be dealt with, but they’re not dealt with by sending them to prison,”An asbi is a civil injunction used to tackle antisocial behaviour, and can be issued to anyone age 10 or over in England, Wales and Northern Ireland,Breaching an injunction is not a criminal offence, but those who disobey an order are guilty of contempt of court and can be sent to prison,Civil injunctions are also used in cases involving protesters, and land disputes involving Gypsies and Travellers,Hunter, along with Rona Epstein, an honorary research fellow at Coventry law school, found that people who are destitute, homeless, have mental health issues, neurodiversity or learning disabilities were disproportionately affected.
They highlighted cases such as that of Pukakdandawa Lanka, an asylum seeker not represented or present in court, who was imprisoned for 12 weeks for breaching an injunction by sleeping rough and leaving belongings in front of St Albans civic centre.They also flagged the case of Jacqueline Reilly, who was imprisoned for 18 months for repeatedly entering a YMCA building to sleep in the communal areas.One man, who breached an injunction by continuing to feed pigeons on his balcony after being instructed not to was imprisoned for 15 weeks.“I started feeding birds with my mum in the 1960s.In recent years, feeding the birds has helped with my grief, depression and ongoing sobriety.
I owe them,I lost my partner, mother, brother and best friend in the space of a few years,” said Nicholas,“I tried to tell him about how feeding the birds saved me from drinking again, and helped my grief,I had a solicitor, who said that it was a mental health issue, but the judge disagreed,”The academics also raised concern about the case of Floyd Carruthers.
He was diagnosed with schizophrenia in 2003, and in April 2021 breached an asbi by banging on his neighbour’s door and damaging it.He was jailed for 66 days, and died in prison of sepsis after not eating for four days.“Many people [imprisoned] were addicted to drugs or to alcohol, or they’d been in mental health hospitals.Some of them were people who had been bereaved; one woman had lost her baby.It’s extraordinary,” said Epstein.
“The whole system has been put in place to deal with behaviour that is disagreeable and a detriment to the citizen, but imprisonment belongs in the criminal code.“And there’s no public data on this, so there’s no oversight.”The analysis was published by the Manifesto Club, a civil liberties campaign group, which said the government’s proposed respect orders could lead to more people being unfairly imprisoned.In November, the home secretary announced that people who persistently exhibit antisocial behaviour will face up to two years in jail under new respect orders, with police and councils handed powers to ban persistent offenders from town centres.Manifesto Club’s director, Josie Appleton, said: “Civil injunctions have led to terrible injustices, and respect orders will be even worse.
These powers aren’t targeting ‘hooligans’, they are targeting those in poverty or with mental health problems, and they are being imprisoned for nothing more than going into a certain area or asking for 50p.“The criminal justice system should focus on real crimes, not pensioners feeding the birds or someone trying to find somewhere to sleep for the night.”The asbi replaced the antisocial behaviour orders (asbos) in 2010, except in Scotland.“There’s no interest [in asbis] as there was for asbos, but actually what we’re seeing is a lot going on with local authorities and social landlords using this with very little oversight,” said Hunter.Housing associations accounted for 45% of the asbis where someone was committed for sentence, while local authorities accounted for 41%.
The analysis found people were imprisoned for an average of 95 days for breaches, with Gypsy and Traveller cases disproportionately more likely to receive a higher sentence – 70% of those cases were in the highest quartile for sentencing, compared with 24% of antisocial behaviour cases.The reports raised concerns about people being imprisoned even where there was no evidence of harm or inconvenience caused.A Home Office spokesperson said: “New Respect Orders will give police and councils the powers they need to clamp down on persistent antisocial behaviour and to place tough restrictions on the worst offenders.”
Graham Sergeant obituary
The British doctor Graham Serjeant, who has died aged 86, lived and worked in Jamaica for more than 50 years, researching sickle cell disease and treating patients with the genetic condition. His long-running research study and publications helped transform doctors’ understanding of the disease, as demonstrated by two contrasting experiences.At the beginning of his career in 1968, Serjeant found it difficult to get a medical journal to publish an article about Jamaicans aged 30 with sickle cell. The journal editors were sceptical because the textbooks of the day said few people with the condition survived beyond childhood.In 2009, Serjeant again had difficulties getting a paper published
Concern over ‘asbis’ after report finds people jailed for sleeping rough and feeding birds
Almost 250 people have been imprisoned for breaching antisocial behaviour injunctions (asbis) since 2020, with people being jailed for sleeping rough, begging, feeding birds and making a noise.Analysis from academics at the universities of York and Coventry found that out of 242 cases examined from 2020-2024, there were 72 cases of imprisonment for general nuisance, 61 for abusive language and 51 for noise.They found that 57% of people did not have legal representation at the breach hearing that led to their imprisonment: out of 97 recorded cases, 55 defendants were not represented.“People are not getting proper representation and they get sent to prison for sometimes long periods, weeks and months. There’s no sentencing guidance for this,” said Prof Caroline Hunter from York Law School
Pensioner with severe learning disabilities could face eviction over care costs dispute
A pensioner with severe learning disabilities who was a victim of one of the most notorious care home abuse scandals of recent years has been told he faces eviction over a dispute about who pays for the costs of his state-funded care.The family of Hugh Kirsch, 66, said they had been warned he would have to leave his supported home because the council that funds his care refused to increase fees in line with costs and his care provider could no longer afford to subsidise the price.The case is one of a growing wave of evictions of vulnerable residents caused by the crisis in adult social care funding in which hundreds of contract disputes erupt between cash-strapped councils and financially struggling care providers.Kirsch’s sister Oona Herzberg said he was “trapped in the crosshairs of funding issues that have nothing to do with him”, and urged his funder, Haringey council, to fulfil its responsibilities to meet his care needs.She told the Guardian: “It would be cruel and inhuman to evict Hughie
Gen Z students in Manchester to learn ‘soft skills’ such as empathy and time management
Thousands of gen Z students in Greater Manchester are to learn “soft skills” such as empathy and time-management in a UK-first trial aimed at teaching “everyday but essential” tools.The pioneering programme will teach young people how to thrive in the workplace after employers said “digital natives” were too afraid to speak on the phone or do job interviews.Prof Sandeep Ranote, a leading child psychiatrist, said those born between the mid-1990s and early 2010s – known as gen Z – had grown up in a very different global world that had left them lacking some key social skills.“Young people are going into a world with huge challenges that certainly I didn’t have,” she said. “I call it the five Cs: they lived through Covid, climate change, cost-of-living, cyberspace and conflict
Tens of thousands waited more than 24 hours for hospital beds in A&E last year
About 49,000 A&E visits last year resulted in patients waiting 24 hours or more for a hospital bed, with people aged 65 or over making up almost 70% of cases.According to a freedom of information request by the Liberal Democrats, some patients went 10 days before getting a space on a ward.The analysis, which used data from 54 trusts in England, showed that of the 48,830 “trolley waits” of 24 hours or longer in 2024, 33,413 were experienced by people aged 65 or over.The term “trolley wait” refers to the time between a patient being transferred to a ward after a decision has been taken to admit them to hospital.The Lib Dems said East Kent’s NHS trust had the highest number of day or longer trolley waits last year at 8,916, up from 30 in 2019 – pre-pandemic – followed by Liverpool University hospitals trust with 4,315, up from 10 in 2019
UK prison officers to demand electric stun guns for dangerous jails
Prison officers will demand the immediate issue of electric stun guns to protect staff guarding Britain’s most dangerous jails when they meet the justice secretary this week.Wednesday’s meeting with Shabana Mahmood was called after the attack on three guards at HMP Frankland, allegedly by the convicted terrorist Hashem Abedi. Two were seriously injured after being doused in hot cooking fat and stabbed, one five times in the torso, in a sustained assault.The body representing prison officers will call for all staff to have stab vests, and also for electric stun guns for selected officers. It will also demand that an American “Supermax”-style regime is imposed on Britain’s worst inmates
Rachel Roddy’s homage to Anna del Conte and Vincenzo Corrado’s fennel with pistachio, lemon and anchovy sauce | A kitchen in Rome
‘It was very difficult to hold on to’: are Michelin stars a blessing - or a curse?
From kumquats to lime caviar: UK foodies embrace a whole new world of citrus
Notes on chocolate: elegant treats for when the Easter eggs are gone
Dove, London: ‘inventive, unusual, tantalising’ – restaurant review
Mediterranean producers unite in the face of dire adversity