Steve Borthwick may focus on results but England fans want to see an identity | Gerard Meagher
About an hour after the final whistle on Saturday, England’s victorious players still swigging from the Calcutta Cup, Steve Borthwick was deep inside Twickenham discussing how his players finally got their hands back on the trophy.He was justifying their route-one tactics, explaining why England showcased so little with ball in hand; essentially, why they seemed to revert to a tactical approach that wins matches but few admirers.Borthwick was asked a perfectly reasonable question – was it the coaches’ decision to do so or the players adapting on the hoof in response to Scotland’s gameplan? – and he did not answer it properly.He was bristling, looking for hidden meaning in the question that just wasn’t there.He was asked it again and once more failed to provide an answer.
Make no mistake, Borthwick cares a great deal about how his team are perceived.The boos sting, the derogatory implications of “Borthball” bother him.About an hour and a half earlier, the old stadium was groaning again.The Twickenham faithful can be notoriously hard to please – it costs a pretty penny to be there, after all – and as Alex Mitchell and Fin Smith hoisted the ball to the skies, boos and jeers rang out.Borthwick must feel as if he cannot win at times.
There was no such booing two weeks earlier during another one-point victory, against France, yet the post-match statistics tell you Smith made more passes against Scotland than he did two weeks earlier.Statistics can always be manipulated and by most metrics England were significantly less effective in attack against Scotland than they were against France.Just 79 carries for 474 metres on Saturday compared with 95 for 700m against Les Bleus, two line‑breaks compared with eight a fortnight previous and – of course – one try that arguably should not have been awarded, compared with four scored against France.Which brings us back to the question Borthwick wouldn’t answer.Was it the intention to kick possession away from the outset, was it the coaches who decided to do so as the match was going on, or was it the players? “Under those circumstances where you spend a week prepping for something and scrapping to be in it at half‑time, then come in and have the messages change, it was good,” the prop Will Stuart said, hinting at the answer.
The closest Borthwick came to answering was to justify the approach rather than explain how it came about.“I’ve been very clear that I want the team to play with ball in hand, to attack with it, to be brave, aggressive with the ball, there is another team trying to stop you and they’re pretty good at it,” the head coach said.“Ultimately they’re strong in defence, strong at the breakdown, and take the game to this kicking game.That leads to slow ball, and effectively they’re waiting for you to run the ball against their high double tackles, and then attack the breakdown.You’ve got to be very good and very judicious about when you go, and I thought the players did it well.
It’s not necessarily how we want to play, but there were two teams out there and we found a way to win.”It may not be pretty, but this has to be deemed a degree of progress.England have been accused regularly of lacking a plan B over the past 12 months, so successfully adapting to their opponents is a step forward.They have also been accused of defensive frailties and, while Scotland enjoyed plenty of joy out wide – Duhan van der Merwe running riot down the left in the first half – England’s scrambling was again impressive on Saturday.They made 187 tackles and it was their determination to work for each other that had Borthwick most pleased.
“I’d point out how hard the team run for each other, which is definitely something that’s developed,” he said.“I am a believer that you get back what you put in.I’m a believer that if you keep trying to do the right things, if you keep working hard you will get rewarded.It’s the way I was brought up, it’s the way I believe in.So that’s what we will continue to do.
That’s part of my roots, part of my make-up.I’ve always believed in it.If you put in the hard work, you’ll get the reward.”Sign up to The BreakdownThe latest rugby union news and analysis, plus all the week's action reviewedafter newsletter promotionEvidently, it is an area of the game the players relish.Listen to Ben Curry, who came on after 36 minutes and made a significant impact.
“My personal view on defence is that it’s got to mean more than just tackling,” he said.“You’ve got to want to hit people.It’s an unnatural thing to put yourself in a dark place where it shouldn’t be.You’ve got to have a deeper reason to do that, especially in our defence.“We want to try and tackle in twos – so it requires you to be on the same page as your mates.
You don’t want to go in half-heartedly because you know your mate’s going in 100%, it’s like guilt.You know he’s flying in, I’m not going to let him down.”That togetherness is, at present, the foundation of this England side but maybe what riles supporters is that they still do not know the team’s identity.Are they a side who, as Borthwick promises, want to be brave and attack with ball in hand? Are they a team who grind out results? Ultimately, fans are crying out for England to impose their gameplan emphatically on their opponents rather than hang in the fight and squeeze over the line and – though it seems unfair after two hard‑fought, overdue victories – they are growing impatient waiting for it.
Far-right links and Putin praise: fears over £600m UK history theme park plan
French family behind project visited Kremlin in 2014 to discuss building ‘Tsarland’ in annexed CrimeaWith its spectacular shows featuring Viking longboats, Roman charioteers and sword-wielding knights who perform death-defying stunts, Puy du Fou in France is consistently ranked among the world’s best theme parks. Each performance of its centrepiece Cinéscénie show, which depicts 700 years of French history, features more than 1,000 actors, hundreds of horses and about 800 fireworks.Now the company has set its sights on bringing its brand of immersive history to the UK via a £600m investment to build its mock medieval castles, hotels and restaurants on farmland just off the M40 in Oxfordshire. It has asked the upmarket property firm Savills to help with its planning applications and is expected to look for British co-investors for a project that it says will create thousands of jobs.Some who live near the site, however, are dismayed at the lack of attention given to what they see as the French company’s dark underbelly, including ties to the far right and a past flirtation with Vladimir Putin
Oil workers ‘could strike’ to protect jobs in green transition; Trump tariffs hit US economic growth – as it happened
Oil workers and tanker drivers could take strike action in an effort to force UK and Scottish ministers to protect jobs threatened by the green transition, Sharon Graham, the Unite general secretary has predicted.Graham told trade union activists based at PetroIneos’s Grangemouth oil refinery near Edinburgh, which is set to close over the next 18 months with the loss of 400 jobs, that direct action was being considered.Speaking outside Scottish Labour’s annual conference in Glasgow, she suggested Unite members could target petrol and diesel production, throttling fuel supplies to forecourts, our Scotland editor Severin Carrell writes.Graham told the rally:“Puts these politicians on notice, we are not going to allow oil and gas workers to be the coal miners of our generation. I have already been meeting with refinery reps up and down the countries in Britain, and we will escalate this action if necessary
A prize worth pursuing: has Elizabeth line shown what rail investment can achieve?
Halfway to a billion journeys, and it’s only just begun. Amid the recent gloom, struggles and doubts besetting Britain’s railway there is a bright beacon of hope: the Elizabeth line.Now accounting for one in seven national rail journeys, the east-west cross-London railway has smashed forecasts and remoulded the travel habits and urban geography of the south-east.So far, so good for the lucky Londoners upgraded from the tube to a far quicker, cleaner and quieter ride. But beyond, with the north of England still waiting for promised better railways, and a chancellor beating the drum for infrastructure investment, the line serves to demonstrate that the nation can indeed still build things, and that the people will absolutely come
UK regulator fines four banks £100m over traders’ sharing of information
The UK competition regulator has fined four major banks, including HSBC and Citi, more than £100m after it found traders had been using Bloomberg chatrooms to share sensitive information about government bonds.The penalties follow a long-running investigation by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) that discovered that individual traders at Citi, HSBC, Morgan Stanley, Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) and Deutsche Bank had messaged rival bankers about the buying and selling of UK government bonds – known as gilts – on specific dates between 2009 and 2013.The CMA said the banks had put in place “extensive compliance measures” to avoid similar behaviour by its staff, but it announced a series of fines on Friday. RBC received the largest fine (£34.2m), followed by Morgan Stanley (£29
Willingness to ease off ‘debt brake’ may decide the German election
Germany is used to running its economy with the brake on. Ever since the 2008 financial crisis Berlin has sought to burnish a reputation as the world capital of fiscal discipline, with a near-pious aversion to debt and pride in strong government finances.Under a rule known as the “debt brake” – introduced in 2009 by Angela Merkel to show Germany was committed to balancing the books after the banking crash – the federal government is required to limit annual borrowing to 0.35% of GDP.After this weekend’s elections it might not be long before the constitutional handbrake is relaxed to help reboot Europe’s largest economy with debt-funded firepower, and to find room for higher defence spending
St Pancras and Channel tunnel plan rail routes to Germany and Switzerland
St Pancras railway station in London and the Channel tunnel operator have agreed to work together to open up more trains from Britain to France, and routes to Germany and Switzerland.The agreement is the latest sign of growing momentum for new passenger rail links from England across the Channel, after Great Britain’s only international station announced plans to triple the number of people who can travel through every hour.St Pancras station is looking at ways to nearly triple the number of passengers passing through at peak times from 1,800 to 5,000, in an effort to open up more services to France and routes to Germany and Switzerland.London St Pancras Highspeed (LSPH) – the company formerly known as HS1 that runs St Pancras – and Getlink, the Paris-based Channel tunnel operator, said they would work together to shorten journey times, improve timetable coordination, align on growth strategies and introduce more trains each hour for international services in each direction.In January the rail regulator for Great Britain, the Office of Rail and Road, forced HS1 to cut the prices it charges rail companies for using its track between St Pancras and the tunnel to try to encourage new entrants
Energy giant AGL is disputing $25m fine for wrongly taking welfare money from hundreds as ‘excessive’
Consumers don’t have a debt problem. The US government does | Gene Marks
Telegram fined nearly $1m by Australian watchdog for delay in reporting about terrorism and child abuse material
Hackers steal $1.5bn from crypto exchange in ‘biggest digital heist ever’
Antoine Dupont to the fore as France run riot with 11-try thrashing of Italy
Steve Borthwick may focus on results but England fans want to see an identity | Gerard Meagher